Akukho cala liLungileyo eMfazweni

NguDavid Swanson, World BEYOND War, Novemba 14, 2023

Uninzi lwethu lubize iimfazwe ezinjengezo zase-Iraq nase-Afghanistan ngegama elithi "iimfazwe" okanye ngamanye amaxesha igama elithi "umsebenzi," kodwa imfazwe ekhoyo eGaza ngegama elithi "genocide." Bonke baye babulala kwicala elinye uninzi lwabemi - ukuza kuthi ga ngoku ubundlobongela bamva nje eGaza buncinci kwicala elinye kwaba bathathu. Kodwa ezimbini zazo zaziyimfazwe yase-US kwaye enye yazo yimfazwe yakwaSirayeli eyayingenakwenzeka ngaphandle kwezixhobo zase-US, i-vetoes yase-US kwi-UN, njl. Kwaye abo baqhuba iimfazwe bathetha ngendlela eyahlukileyo. Okanye ubuncinci sithanda ukulibala amaLungu eNkomfa afuna ukuguqula i-Iraq ibe yindawo yokupaka ngelixa siziva sothukile ngabo bathi ngoku ngeGaza. Mhlawumbi iyantlukwano mincinane kunokuba sicinga. Ukufumana iiyantlukwano ezinkulu kufuneka sijonge kwimfazwe yaseUkraine, apho abantu abaninzi abanegunya bathetha ngendlela eyahlukileyo malunga nokuxhobisa isizwe esihlaselweyo kunokuba isizwe sihlasele - nokuba umgaqo-nkqubo ulingana ngokulinganayo ukukhusela uxolo kunye nokwandisa ukufa nokutshatyalaliswa.

Ngexesha lenye yezi mfazwe / ukubulawa kwabantu kuphantse ukuba ngamanyala ukwenza naluphi na uqwalaselo ngaphandle kokuYIMA IT. Kwaye umntu kufuneka aqale ngecala lemfazwe esenza okubi kakhulu, kulo mzekelo urhulumente wase-Israel, kunye ne-monster yobukhosi exhobileyo kunye nokubonelela ngokhuseleko lobudlelwane obusemthethweni noluntu, oko kukuthi urhulumente wase-US, kunye naye wonke umntu othatha inxaxheba ngeendlela ezahlukeneyo, ezinkulu nezincinci, okanye ungenzi nto kwaphela. Ukuba kukho nantoni na, kwaye andiqinisekanga ukuba kukho, kodwa ukuba kukho nantoni na abaseNtshona abaye bafundiswa ukuba bangahlali ngexesha lokubulawa kwabantu. Ukuba ubuza umntu oqhelekileyo ocinga kancinci malunga nemfazwe okanye uxolo ukuba abize imfazwe ethethelelekayo baphantse bathethe i-WWII, kwaye ukuba babuzwa ukuba kutheni, ngokuqinisekileyo baqinisekisiwe ukuthetha elinye lamagama amabini e-H: UkuQothulwa Kwesizwe okanye uHitler. Kwaye ekucingeni kwabo imfazwe yayisenza into yokunqanda imbubhiso, nangona urhulumente wase-US ethethelela esidlangalaleni ukuba angawakhuphi amaYuda kunye nabanye aboyikiswa ngokubulala yayikukuba imfazwe yayibaluleke ngakumbi okanye ukuba uHitler akayi kusebenzisana, kunye nesizathu sangasese. kuba engaceli uHitler kukuba ngokuqinisekileyo uya kuvuma ukuthumela ngaphandle kwamaYuda njengoko wayezama ukwenza iminyaka kwaye ama-allies kufuneka amkele bonke abantu ababengabafuni-kwaye nangona imfazwe ayizange ibonakale esidlangalaleni. okanye ngasese yayinento yokwenza nokunqanda ukubulala kwaye yona ngokwayo yenza ukubulawa kwabantu abaninzi ngomlinganiselo omkhulu kunalowo weenkampu zokufa. Umntu onqabileyo uza kuzisa imfazwe abacinga ukuba bekufanele ukuba yenzekile eRwanda, ekucingelwa ukuba iye yayisisisombululo sokubulawa kwabantu-isizathu esikwasetyenziswa ngobuxoki ukuqala imfazwe eLibya. Kwaye ngoku sixelelwa ukuba sihlale ecaleni sibukele, okanye sijonge kude, okanye sizibandakanye kuyo nayiphi na inkqubo - engaqondakaliyo kum njengomthandazo - wokulungiselela ukuchitha imizuzwana elishumi sivotela uJoe Biden unyaka ukusuka ngoku.

Eyona nto iphambili kuthi njengabahlali base-United States kukufuna ukuba kupheliswe ukuthunyelwa kwezixhobo, kupheliswe ukungakhuseleki okusemthethweni, kupheliswe ipropaganda exhasa ukubulawa kwabantu. Ukufuna izilumkiso ezifanelekileyo ngaphambi kokuba indlu iqhunyiswe, okanye unqumame ukuze abantu bahlanjululwe ngokobuhlanga, okanye iilori zokutya kubantu abanokukrazulwa zibe ziingceba ngaphambi kokuba bakwetyise kuyahlazisa. Ukufuna ukuba kupheliswe imfazwe ngoxa uthumela izixhobo ezingakumbi ngenqanawa ibiya kuba lilinge lobudenge lokukhohlisa. Kufuneka siqonde kwaye senze ngokuvisisana nenyaniso elula yokuba ukubulala amadoda, abafazi, abantwana, neentsana kubububi. Xa intombazana eqeqeshwe kakuhle yaxoka ukuba i-Iraq yayikhupha iintsana kwi-incubators kwathathwa njengesizathu sokubulawa kwabantu kunye nokutshabalalisa. Le ntombazana ikhulile ngoku kwaye iqhayisa ngento eyenzayo. Ngoku abantwana abazalwa ngaphambi kwexesha abakhoyo ngokwenene bafa kwi-incubators banqatshelwe umbane ngurhulumente ngokuphandle ofuna ukuphelisa amaGazans, kwaye kufuneka sivale imilomo yethu okanye sibhalwe ukuba sichasene ne-antisemitic? Enkosi ukulunga abantu abaninzi abalungileyo abayilandeli loo miyalelo. Banqanda ukuthunyelwa kwezixhobo, ukubuza abawiswa-mthetho, amajelo osasazo aqhankqalazayo, bathabathe iindawo zikawonke-wonke, kwaye ngobuchule nangobulungisa badanduluke bekhwaza bevusa abangasekhoyo engqondweni, abatyebileyo, abangakhathaliyo, nabalahlekisiweyo.

Kodwa ukuba sifuna abantu abaninzi benze ngakumbi nangaphezulu, kwaye sicenge ngakumbi kwabo kufuneka sibajoyine, kuyabaluleka ukuba sifumane iinkcukacha ngokufanelekileyo. Andithethi-ukuba kukho nantoni na endithetha ngokuchasene nayo-into ethethwa yimithombo yeendaba xa isithi uSenator othile onjengoBernie Sanders uthatha indlela echuliweyo nengenamagingxigingxi ngakumbi kunesilogeni esilula. Ukubonelela nge-inshorensi yembubhiso yohlanga akuyongxaki; lulwaphulo-mthetho.

Kodwa ndiyathetha ukuba kufuneka sibe nobuqili kunabo bahlalutyi beengcaphephe emfazweni, njengoChris Hedges ohlala eqaqambile, ocebisa ukuba iHamas inesicwangciso esilumkileyo sokuxhokonxa ngokwazi ukubulawa kwabantu abaninzi baseGazan kuba iyabuqonda umlo we-asymmetric. Kwaye ndicinga ukuba kufuneka sibe nobuqili kunokuba amajelo eendaba afuna ukusichaza njengaxa sisenza ingxelo ngeendibano ze-pro-Palestine ezifuna inkululeko ukusuka emlanjeni ukuya elwandle. Ndikhe ndancokola neqela labantu abathe bandixelela ukuba bafuna iindibano zabo zibe ngabaxhasi bePalestina, baphephezelise iiflegi zasePalestina, baze bafune inkululeko yamaPalestina ukusuka emlanjeni ukuya elwandle. Asikuko ukuba abafuni ukuba iindibano zabo zibe zezokuphelisa imfazwe okanye ezoxolo okanye ezoluntu, koko bangaboni mahluko phakathi kwezo zinto nezinye. Ke, ndibacebise ukuba xa abapolitiki bakwa-Israel bebulala uhlanga befuna umlambo oya elwandle kumaSirayeli oko kuthetha ukubulawa kwabantu, kwaye abantu abanjalo kunye nabasebenzi babo beendaba baya kuva kwa elo binzana lifana nelokutshatyalaliswa kohlanga xa lithethwa egameni lamaPalestine nokuba njani. ithetha ukuthi, kwaye akukho mfuneko yokunceda abo basasaza inkohliso, akukho mfuneko yokwenza izinto zibe lula kubo, akukho mfuneko yokuba babe ngabaphembeleli boxolo abachasene nenkcitho yasemkhosini kodwa bayibiza ngokuba "inkcitho yokhuselo" ngaphandle kokucela umrhumo kwizixhobo. iinkampani zokwenza oko.

Into engummangaliso apha, eyona nto inqabileyo yesilivere, kukuba abanye abantu bayabubona ububi bokubulala amaGazan KUNYE nasekubulaleni amaSirayeli. Loo nto phantse ayaziwa. Akuzange ngaphambili kumava am okanye kulwazi lwam lwembali kubekho imfazwe apho naliphi na inani elibalulekileyo labantu ekulindeleke ukuba libe kwicala elinye livakalise ukuba omabini amacala akalunganga. Kunqabile kakhulu, kangangokuba ayikaphuhlisa isikrweqe sobuciko ukuyikhusela kwizigxeko ezahlukeneyo zeekhathuni, njengoluvo lokuba ukuze omabini amacala abekwimpazamo kufuneka abe ngokulinganayo ngokulinganayo kwimpazamo, okanye ukuba amacala omabini abe. ngokungalunganga onke amaxhoba kufuneka abe netyala kwaye oorhulumente bakhululwe, okanye ukuba amacala omabini abe nempazamo nokuba leliphi na icala elichaswa ngumntu othile kufuneka libe lilungile.

Ndifuna ukukucaphulela i-imeyile endiyifumene kutsha nje kwimpendulo ye-imeyile evela kuyo World BEYOND War ngemigudu yoxolo ehlabathini lonke:

"Ndizikhuphele phantsi kodwa ndothukile xa usasaza ubuxoki beHamas abanqolobi [sic]! I-gaza [sic] imbubhiso yakwaSirayeli yi-100% yempazamo yabanqolobi beHamas! Kungaphaya kokusoleka ukuba ihlabathi lizele yintiyo nokuchasa ubuYuda kangangokuba ngokungathandabuzekiyo baxhasa ubuxoki kunye nobuxoki behamas/abanqolobi!”

Uyakuqaphela ukuba inkxaso yembubhiso eGaza ihlala ithatha uhlobo olwahlukileyo kunokuxhasa ukubulawa kwabantu eGaza. Uninzi luhlala luthatha uhlobo lokutshintsha incoko ekubulaweni kwabantu abaninzi bakwaSirayeli yiHamas. Kukwathatha uhlobo lokugxeka i-Hamas ngokugcina amajoni okanye izixhobo kufutshane nabemi, ngaloo ndlela inyanzelisa urhulumente wase-Israel ukuba abulale wonke umntu. Okanye kuthatha uhlobo lokukhanyela nje ukuba kwenzekani kuba, nangona kukho iingxelo ezingapheliyo kunye namavidiyo kunye neefoto, urhulumente we-Hamas uyavuma ukuba kuyenzeka kwaye ngoko akunjalo. Okanye ayenzeki ngenxa yokuba urhulumente wase-Israel uyayenza kwaye ngoko ke i-antisemitic ukuvuma ukuba iyenzeka. Esi sisityholo esithandwayo esivela kwabanye abantu abachasene ne-antisemitic.

Iindlela ezahlukeneyo zokuthethelela imbubhiso zinento enye ezifanayo: inkolelo yokuba elinye icala lilungile nge-100% kwaye elinye i-100% linetyala. Ukuba uqwalasela ngononophelo elona lizwe liyinyaniso, nalapha ekhaya, nakwindlu yakho, akukho nto inokuthi ibeke ityala nge-100%. Ukuba asikwazi ukulahla inkqubo yobulungisa engenangqondo eziphatha ngokungathi ukugwetyelwa (nokuba ngobuxoki) kulungisa ulwaphulo-mthetho kwaye kukhulule wonke umntu emhlabeni, sinokuyeka ukucinga njengabatshutshisi. Ityala alipheleli nje okanye lilula. Kwaye ukubulawa kwabantu abaninzi akuthetheleleki kuba kuchasene norhulumente obeke ityala.

Ndikhe ndathetha kwiminyhadala kwezi ntsuku zamva nje apho abantu bandikhwaza besithi iGaza yintolongo evulekileyo, ukuba ukubulala ama-Israel akuwabulali amaSirayeli kuba kukuqhambuka kwejele. Ewe, yintolongo evulekileyo, kodwa ukubulala abantu akunakwenziwa ukuba ungabulali abantu ngenxa yokuba iyenye into. Abantu baseGaza kunye nabantu behlabathi abangaphumelelanga ukubaxhasa ngokwaneleyo bahlala kwihlabathi apho isenzo esingenalo ubundlobongela siphumelele ngakumbi kunobundlobongela. Ukubulala amaSirayeli kuhlala kubi nangona uyazi ukuba kuya kubangela ukubulala abantu baseGaza amaxesha amaninzi. Enyanisweni kubi kakhulu ngenxa yoko, nokuba ukhulula inkcazo ye-erudite malunga nezicwangciso zexesha elide zemfazwe ye-anticolonial asymmetric.

Kweminye yeminyhadala endiye ndaye ndafumana abantu befuna ukwazi ukuba yintoni na endifuna ukuba amaSirayeli ayenze, anikezele kwiintshaba zawo? Kodwa ukucinga ukuba umbuzo onjalo kukwamkela ngokupheleleyo ucalucalulo. Xa iUnited States yayijongene nesidingo sokuphelisa uJim Crow, kwakungeyomfuneko ukuba inikezele kwiintshaba zayo, kodwa ukuzihlanganisa, ukuze ibe sisizwe esiquka abantu abaninzi ngokulinganayo bonke abantu, abamelwane, abahlobo, amaqabane. Oku kwakungafane kucingelwe kwabo babenyanzelela uhlanga lwabamhlophe. KwaSirayeli akukho ngqiqweni kwabo bafuna uhlanga lwamaYuda. Kodwa kukho impendulo kuloo nto. Asiyompendulo ilula, nokuba kulula ukuyithetha. Impendulo kukuyeka ukucinga ngesizwe samaYuda kunye nokwenza ngathi into enjalo inokuba yidemokhrasi. Impendulo kukuseka umsebenzi onzima wokwamkela wonke umntu njengomntu kwimo ebanzi netyebileyo, nengenabundlobongela nentiyo, ngenkululeko yonqulo, yokuhlanganisana, yokuthetha, neyokuziphatha ngasese nenkcubeko.

Isisombululo semibuso-mibini sivakala sisengqiqweni ngakumbi, ngaphandle nje kokuba sithatha amazwe ocalucalulo achaseneyo afukama inzondo ekrakra, kwaye enye yawo ikwizindlu ezincinci ezizimeleyo ezilawulwa ngomnye urhulumente. Kufuneka siphinde siqwalasele ukuba yintoni na engaphezulu kunye nokuba yintoni engafanelekanga. Iimfazwe ezingapheliyo ziya kuba ncinci ngaphandle kwe-arsenal yase-US yocalucalulo, okanye ngokuvuma kwe-US ukwenza idemokhrasi kwiZizwe eziManyeneyo okanye ukujoyina imithetho esekelwe kwimigaqo yezivumelwano kunye neenkundla.

Kwimpelaveki ephelileyo eMadison, eWisconsin, ndaxoxa nonjingalwazi ovela eyunivesithi apho ngesihloko semfazwe yaseUkraine. Njengoko bekulindelekile, wayethanda izixhobo ezingaphezulu, esithi akaqondi ukuba i-US kunye ne-UK zithintele iingxoxo zoxolo, wathetha ngokungathi i-2014 coup yayingekho, ekholelwa ukuba ukuthambekela kobukhosi baseRussia kwacima nayiphi na indima edlalwe kukwandisa kwe-NATO (nokuba zingaphi Abahlalutyi be-NATO baxela kwangaphambili ngexesha lokwenyani), njl. ithiyori icinga, kwaye yintoni na ingqiqo yenkqubo yothethathethwano eyimfazwe eyalelayo. Kwaye okumangalisayo kukuba, yonke into ebicingwa ngala maqumrhu angengomntu ihambelana ngqo nento ecingwa ngumabonwakude kunye neenkampani zamaphephandaba - nokuba ibisemva kancinane kolwamkelo lwamva nje lobukho bomqobo ongenathemba.

Lo njingalwazi wayekrelekrele ngokwentelekiso kwaye enolwazi kwaye ethetha kakuhle, kodwa ebonakala engenazintloni zokuthetha ngokufanelekileyo ukuba wayezibandakanye kwingcinga yeqela. Akazange alisebenzise elo gama. Usenokuphendula ngelithi ubulumko bebutho elikhulu lezifundiswa bukhulu kunobo bomntu. Kodwa kuqala ukwamkela imfazwe uze uchaze oko abantu abazama ukuxelisa iikhompyutha bacinga ukuba kuya kwenzeka ngokulandelayo kwihlabathi elamkela imfazwe asiyonzululwazi okanye ukuziphatha. Lipolisa. Kwaye idlala kwingcamango yendlela efanelekileyo yokucinga, ngexesha apho zonke iintlobo zeendlela ezingafanelekanga zokucinga zivaliwe kwaye zohlwaywa egameni lentando yesininzi. Ke, ndiyabulela ngokundivumela ukuba ndithethe kanye le nto ndiyicingayo kwaye ndiyathemba ukuba nawe uya kwenza okufanayo.