Ngo-1+1 ibanjwe ngu U-Youri Smouter, Januwari 13, 2023
Siyiqinisa kanjani inhlangano yokuthula ikakhulukazi ezindaweni lapho umnyakazo onjalo umncane kakhulu noma ungekho nje.
Ingabe kukhona ukucwasa ngokwebala, ukucwasa ngokobulili, okungahambisani ne-heteronormativity, kanye nokunyakaza kwemvelo okugqugquzela ukulwa nezimpi futhi uma kungenjalo kungani kunjalo?
Kungani amaFeminists, Queer liberationists, amaphoyisa abolitionists/abehlisayo, abezemvelo/i-eco-socialists, nalabo abazinikele ekuqedeni ubukhosi babamhlophe kungafanele bajoyine amasosha aseCanada noma basekele YILUPHI uhlobo lwezempi/impiriyali phesheya kwezilwandle.
Futhi sikukhuthaza kanjani ukunyakaza kokuthula, kungakhathaliseki ukuthi kuncane noma kukhulu kangakanani eRussia noma kwenye indawo, ukuqhubeka nokuhlangana ngokumelene nezimpi futhi sinjani isimo sokulwa nempi eRussia?
Lena ngeminye yemibuzo kanye nezihloko engathola ukubuza uMaya Garfinkel okhaliphile inhloko ye World BEYOND War Canada, kanye nesahluko saseMontreal senhlangano yokuthula yamazwe ngamazwe ophinde abe ngumgqugquzeli wezemvelo, umphakathi/ubuhlanga/ubulungiswa bemvelo, olwela amalungelo abantu besifazane, umfelandawonye weNative Lives Matter kanye nozakwabo/ilungu lenhlangano yenkululeko ye-2SLGBTQIA+.
Siphinde saxoxa ngokuthi izimpi ZONKE zifanelekile yini, siyithuthukisa kanjani imbangela yokuthula nokulwa nama-imperialism kanye ne-detente nokubambisana lapho iMpi YaseRussia-Ukraine nokuma ngobumpumputhe ngase-Ukraine kubhekwa "njengempi enhle" uma usohlangothini lwe-NATO, kanye nokuhlangana ngokumelene ne-Pivot to Asia/New Cold War e-China kanye ne-Sinophobia ekhulayo.
Impendulo eyodwa
Ngo-47:40 ngeshwa iMaya igwema ngokuphelele iqiniso. Ukumamatheka kukaMaya kuhle, ubuqotho bakhe buyiqiniso kodwa ngeshwa impendulo yakhe ithi gobbledygook. Ukugwema okuphelele. NgoFebhuwari odlule iRussia yahlasela i-Ukraine futhi yaqala ukubulala izakhamuzi. Isivakashi sakho siyenqaba ukuvuma ukuthi umbuso wangaphandle uhlasele kanjani futhi waqala ukubulala nokuthi bekunesidingo sokuthi abantu base-Ukrainian nabangane bazilwele ukuze bavimbele ukuqothulwa kohlanga, uPutin ethi i-Ukraine yayingekho ngempela. Sekuyiminyaka futhi konke amaMaya akho angakwenza ukugoqa kancane, enze ama-cutesy kancane (amamomotheka amaningi kakhulu) bese enganaki ngokuphelele iqiniso lempi yamakholoni. Labo abangakwesobunxele abayizishoshovu zokuthula kumele nabo babe namaqiniso: kumele siphikisane nalawo mazwe ahlasela futhi aphoqelele amazwe ukuba athole izindlela zokuzivikela, athole izindlela zokunqanda ukubulala. Kunalokho i World Beyond War Umkhulumeli uyakhubeka ngokungaphenduli futhi ashintshe ngokushesha akhulume ngemizabalazo yeSizwe Sokuqala "yenkululeko" eCanada futhi aveze imizabalazo yokuthula ePalestine. Inkinga yonke imizabalazo ehluke ngokuphelele. Kungani? Ngokusobala ngoba umkhulumeli we-W BW ubanjwe ngokungqubuzana kwenqaba ukukhuluma: uma umuntu ungumuntu we-pacifist - njengoba enjalo- futhi wenqaba ukuvuma ukuthi ukuzivikela ngokumelene nokuhlukunyezwa kuyadingeka, usekela umhlaseli. UGeorge Orwell waze wamangalela ama-pacifist aseBrithani ngokusekela uHitler. Labo abenqaba ukusekela ilungelo lase-Ukraine lokuzivikela - ukumisa ukubulawa kwezingane ngokungaqondile- basekela uPutin. Umuntu angaphikisa kanjani ngenye indlela? Ukuma ngenkathi iRussia ibulala amashumi ezinkulungwane zezakhamizi akunandaba nhlobo. UMaya, njengomkhulumeli we-WBW, akanacala, unecala.
Ngempela yonke le ngxoxo no-Youri izacile kangangokuba kuncane okungafundwa lapha kunoma ubani ocabanga ngokujulile ngomlando, ngohulumeni, noma ubulungisa.
Ukubungaza ukuwina kumamashi e-Standing Rock noma amalungelo omphakathi ngeminyaka yawo-1960 njengoba kwenza umkhulumeli we-WBW kubalulekile. Kuhle kuwe ngokubona ukuthi ngezinye izikhathi ukungabi nodlame kungasebenza kanjani ngezinye izikhathi, kodwa esimweni sokuthola ukuthi ungayiqeda kanjani iMpi YaseRussia lokhu kumane kungaphezulu kokuthi « bla bla bla » (njengoba uGreta ehlukanisa izithembiso zemvelo zosopolitiki abaningi.) Izishoshovu zokuthula zilindele ukuthi zibe ngcono nakakhulu. ngaphezu kuka-bla bla bla kumuntu omele World Beyond War.
"Akekho onqoba izimpi" akunalutho njengesiqubulo.
Izishoshovu zokuthula ezeseka ilungelo le-Ukraine lokuzinqumela "azisekeli" i-Ukraine. Bakhuluma iqiniso, bathi kumele kumiswe isiqhwaga sixoshwe ezweni ngaphambi kokuthi kuqale izingxoxo zokuthula okuhlala njalo. Izingcingo zokuthi "ziqede zonke izimpi" zifana nokubiza "" u-ayisikhilimu wamahhala wabo bonke" noma "Ubulungisa kubo bonke," zizwakala kahle uze uzihlole futhi ubone ukuthi azinalutho, zichitha isikhathi ngoba kude kakhulu nalokho kwenzeka empilweni.
Okuwukuphela kwesikhundla esinesibopho sokwakha ukuthula esinengqondo manje sifuna ukuthi "uPutin ayeke ukubulala izakhamizi futhi aphume e-Ukraine. “Uma sekwenzeka lokho la mazwe womabili angakhuluma.
Kodwa ukungabi nombono ngemva konyaka wempi lapho umuntu ethi uyisishoshovu sokuthula akugcini nje ngokunganaki kuyethusa ngoba empeleni kuwubizo lokwandisa impi, kwandise ukuhlupheka, kwamukele ukuthi isibalo sezingane ezifile sizokhula. .
Akusona isishoshovu sokuthula, siwusekelo olusebenzayo lombuso wama-fascist waseRussia. I-pro-war! So sorry to be negative njengoba ngiyazi ukuthi usho kahle futhi wenza umsebenzi omuhle kwezinye izindawo. Kodwa endabeni yempi yaseRussia unephutha ngokuphelele.