Izindaba Zangempela: Debunking Inganekwane Ye-American Exceptionalism, noDavid Swanson

Izimpendulo ze-4

1. UDavid ushiya amanye amaqiniso abalulekile encwadini. Lapho exoxa ngeNgqungquthela ye-Evian (pp98-104), uphinda i-trope uFranklin Roosevelt "ayikhethile ukungenzi imizamo edingekayo yokusiza ababaleki abangamaJuda, ngaphambi, ngesikhathi, noma ngemuva kwengqungquthela." Ekhasini 29 lencwadi ethi “Ngokumelene Nesahlulelo Sethu Esingcono,” u-Alison Weir wasiphikisa leso simangalo, “Lapho i-FDR yenza imizamo ngo-1938, 1943, namaNgisi ngo-1947, ukunikeza ababaleki bamaNazi izindawo zokucasha, amaSiyoni amelana nale misebenzi ngoba ayengayifuni. zihlanganisa iPalestine.” Usekela lokho ngokugcwele emibhalweni yaphansi, ecaphuna uJohn W. Mulhall, CSP, no-Alfred Lilienthal. Ngokuphawulekayo, amaZionists aphikisana nesiphakamiso sikaBernard Baruch sika-1938 ahlanganisa uBrandeis noFrankfurter.

   Ngiyaqaphela ukuthi isihloko sikaDavid sithi I-American Exceptionalism, futhi ubufushane bubalulekile ukuze uthwebule izethameli eziningi. Kubalulekile ukuthi silungise amaphutha ethu kunokukhomba abanye ngeminwe, ngakho-ke mhlawumbe akufanele alindeleke ukuba adonse ingxoxo ejwayelekile yokuthi “ukhethwe” nguNkulunkulu, nokufana phakathi kwe-US kanye no-Israyeli engxoxweni, kodwa nginakho. isibopho sokulungisa ulwazi olunganembile.

   Phendula

   1. Njengoba ngikuthumelele i-imeyili, ngiyabonga, futhi nakuba ngingakwazi ngisho nokwenza umqondo ngo-1947 lapha ngingathanda ukuzwa ukuthi yayiyini imizamo ngo-1938 no-1943.

      Phendula

2. Sawubona, David..
   Ngithanda ukwazi ukuthi uyitholile yini impendulo evela kuBill Rood mayelana nemizamo yababaleki ngo-1938 nango-1943.
   Siyabonga!

   Phendula

   1. Angicabangi kanjalo.

      Phendula