ngu-Ben Norton, Januwari 8, 2018
Kusukela Fair.org
Okwenethiwekhi yezindaba zekhebula yase-US edumile MSNBC, inhlekelele enkulu kunazo zonke emhlabeni ngokusobala ayikufanelekeli ukunakwa—ngisho noma uhulumeni wase-United States uye wadlala indima ebalulekile ekudaleni nasekulondolozeni leyo nhlekelele engenakuqhathaniswa.
Ukuhlaziywa kwe-FAIR kuthole ukuthi inethiwekhi ehamba phambili yamakhebula ekhululekile ayizange isebenzise ingxenye eyodwa enikelwe ngokukhethekile e-Yemen engxenyeni yesibili ka-2017.
Futhi kulezi zokugcina cishe izinyanga eziyisithupha zonyaka, MSNBC inezingxenye ezicishe zibe ngamaphesenti angu-5,000 XNUMX ezazikhuluma ngeRussia kunezingxenye ezikhuluma ngeYemen.
Ngaphezu kwalokho, kuwo wonke u-2017, MSNBC yasakaza ukusakazwa okukodwa kuphela ezitelekeni zezindiza zaseSaudi ezisekelwa yi-US ezibulale izinkulungwane zezakhamizi zaseYemeni. Futhi ayikaze ikhulume ngobhubhane olukhulu lwekholera yesizwe esimpofu, oluthelele abantu baseYemeni abangaphezu kwesigidi esisodwa ezweni. ukuqubuka okukhulu emlandweni orekhodiwe.
Konke lokhu kwenzeka naphezu kokuthi uhulumeni waseMelika ubambe iqhaza elikhulu empini yezinyanga ezingama-33 ecekele phansi iYemen, idayisa. izigidigidi zamarandi zezikhali eya eSaudi Arabia, ifaka uphethiloli izindiza zempi zaseSaudi njengoba ziqhumisa amabhomu ngokungakhathali izindawo zabantu futhi zihlinzeka ezobunhloli nosizo lwezempi kumbutho wezempi waseSaudi.
Ngokusakazwa okuncane kwezindaba zebhizinisi kusuka MSNBC noma kwenye indawo, i-US-ngaphansi kwabo bobabili omongameli u-Barack Obama kanye no-Donald Trump-isekele ngokuqinile i-Saudi Arabia njengoba ivimbezela i-Yemen, ivikela ngokusemthethweni umbuso wobushiqela we-Draconian Gulf kunoma yiluphi uhlobo lwesijeziso njengoba selufake izigidi zezakhamizi zaseYemeni ngobuningi. indlala futhi yadudulela izwe elimpofu kakhulu eMpumalanga Ephakathi onqenqemeni lwendlala.
1 Ukukhulunywa kweSaudi Airstrikes; Akukhulunywa NgeCholera
I-FAIR yenza ukuhlaziya okuphelele kwe MSNBCUkusakaza kufakwe kungobo yomlando ku- I-Nexis isizindalwazi sezindaba. (Izibalo kulo mbiko zithathwe ku-Nexis.)
Ngo 2017, MSNBC yasakaza imisakazo engu-1,385 82 eyayikhuluma “ngeRussia,” “Russian” noma “Russian.” Nokho ukusakazwa okungu-XNUMX kuphela okusebenzise amagama athi “Yemen,” “Yemeni” noma “Yemenis” unyaka wonke.
Ngaphezu kwalokho, iningi lama-82 MSNBC ukusakazwa okukhuluma nge-Yemen kwenze njalo kanye nangemva kokudlula, imvamisa nje njengesizwe esisodwa ohlwini olude lwezizwe ezibhekiswe ekuvinjweni kokuhamba kukaMongameli uTrump.
Kulokhu kusakazwa kwe-82 ngo-2017, bekukhona eyodwa kuphela MSNBC ingxenye yezindaba enikezwe ngokukhethekile impi yaseSaudi esekelwa yi-US eYemen.
Ngomhla zi-2 kuJulayi, inethiwekhi yasebenzisa ingxenye ye-Ari Melber's The Point (7/2/17) enesihloko esithi “Isivumelwano sezikhali saseSaudi singase sibhebhethekise isimo saseYemen.” Ukusakazwa kwemizuzu emithathu kuhlanganisa amaphuzu amaningi abalulekile mayelana nokusekelwa kwe-US empini eyinhlekelele yaseSaudi e-Yemen.
Nokho le ngxenye yolwazi yema yodwa unyaka wonke. Ukusesha kusizindalwazi seNexis kanye ne Ithegi yaseYemen on MSNBCIwebhusayithi ye-'s ikhombisa ukuthi, cishe ezinyangeni eziyisithupha ngemuva kwalokhu kusakazwa kwangomhla zi-2 kuJulayi, inethiwekhi ayizange inikele enye ingxenye ngqo empini yaseYemen.
Ukusesha kwe MSNBC Ukusakazwa kukhombisa nokuthi, ngenkathi inethiwekhi kwesinye isikhathi ngaphakathi kokusakaza okufanayo isho kokubili i-Yemen kanye nezindiza, ayizange-ngaphandle kwengxenye eyodwa ka-Ari Melber-ivume ukuba khona kwezindiza zomfelandawonye wase-US/Saudi. on I-Yemen.
Okusondele kakhulu inethiwekhi ngenye indlela bekuyingxenye yangoMashi 31, 2017 ku Izwi Lokugcina NoLawrence O'Donnell, lapho uJoy Reid athi, “Futhi njengoba i New York Times kubika, i-United States iqale ukuhlasela okuningi eYemen kule nyanga kunangonyaka odlule. " Kodwa uReid wayebhekisela ku-a New York Times bika (3/29/17) ezihlahleni zezindiza zase-US ku-Al Qaeda eNhlonhlweni yase-Arabia (ezinezinombolo eziningi), hhayi ukuhlasela kwezindiza komfelandawonye wase-US/Saudi endaweni elawulwa ngabakwaHouthi e-Yemen (ebalelwe ezinkulungwaneni).
Ngenkathi ungazinaki izindiza zomfelandawonye wase-US/Saudi kanye nezinkulungwane zezakhamizi abazibulala, nokho, MSNBC ibike ngokuhlaselwa kwamaHouthi emikhunjini yempi yaseSaudi ogwini lwaseYemen. Embukisweni wakhe I-MTP Nsuku zonke(2/1/17), u-Chuck Todd ukhulume kahle nge-anti-Iran ukuthunyelwa kukaTrump kanye nomeluleki Wezokuphepha Kuzwelonke uMichael Flynn. Yena ngokudukisayo wakhuluma ngamaHouthi njengabameleli base-Iran futhi wanika lowo owayeyinxusa laseMelika u-Nicholas Burns inkundla yokusho ukuthi, "I-Iran iyinkinga egcwele udlame eMpumalanga Ephakathi." NgoFebhuwari 1 no-2, uChris Hayes naye wabika ngokuhlaselwa kwamaHouthi.
MSNBC yayimagange ukugqamisa ukuhlaselwa yizitha ezisemthethweni zase-US, nokho amashumi ezinkulungwane zezindiza zase-Saudi Arabia ezethule eYemen-ngezikhali, uphethiloli kanye nobuhlakani obuvela e-US nase-UK-zenziwe zacishe zangabonakali ngokuphelele yinethiwekhi.
Iminyaka yokuqhuma kwamabhomu komfelandawonye wase-US/Saudi kanye nokuvinjwa kweYemen nako ngokunjalo kwacekela phansi uhlelo lwezempilo lwalelo zwe elimpofu, lwalufaka kubhubhane lwekholera eselubulale izinkulungwane zabantu futhi lwaphula wonke amarekhodi angaphambili. MSNBC akazange nakanye ayivume le nhlekelele, ngokosesho lwe-Nexis kanye Iwebhusayithi ye-MSNBC. ikholera kwakhulunywa ngakho kuphela I-MSBNC ngo-2017 kumongo weHaiti, hhayi Yemen.
Nginentshisekelo Kuphela Lapho AmaMelika Efa
Ngenkathi MSNBC azange azihluphe ngokukhuluma ngobhubhane lwekholera yaseYemen, izwakalise intshisekelo enkulu ekugaseleni okuyinhlekelele kweNavy SEAL uMongameli uDonald Trump okugunyazwe ezweni, okwashiya kushone umMelika. Ikakhulukazi ekuqaleni konyaka, inethiwekhi inikeze ukusabalala okukhulu January 29 ukugasela, eyabulala inqwaba yabantu baseYemeni kanye nesosha elilodwa laseMelika.
Ukusesha kusizindalwazi seNexis kukhombisa lokho MSNBC ikhulume ngokugasela kwe-US okugunyazwe nguTrump eYemen ngezigaba ezihlukene ezingama-36 ngo-2017. Yonke imibukiso emikhulu yenethiwekhi ikhiqize izingxenye ezigxile ekuhlaseleni: I-MTP Nsuku zonke ngo-January 31 nango-March 1; Bonke Ku ngo-February 2, February 8 no-March 1; OkweRekhodi ngo-February 6; Izwi Lokugcina ngo-February 6, 8 no-27; I-Hardball ngo-March 1; kanye ne URachel Maddow Show ngo-February 2, February 3, February 23 kanye no-March 6.
Kepha ngemuva kwalokhu kugasela kushiye umjikelezo wezindaba, kanjalo neY Yemen. Ukusesha kwe-Nexis kanye nethegi yaseYemen kuwebhusayithi ye-MSBNC kukhombisa ukuthi, ngaphandle kwengxenye ka-Ari Melber eyodwa kaJulayi, ingxenye yakamuva. MSNBC enikelwe ngokukhethekile eYemen ngonyaka ka-2017 URachel Maddow ShowUmbiko ka-March 6 mayelana nokuhlasela kwe-SEAL.
Umlayezo odluliswayo ucacile: kunethiwekhi yezindaba zekhebula ezikhululekile zase-US, i-Yemen ibalulekile uma kungabantu baseMelika abafayo-hhayi lapho kubulawa izinkulungwane zamaYemeni, kuqhunyiswa amabhomu nsuku zonke yiSaudi Arabia, ngezikhali zase-US, uphethiloli kanye nobuhlakani; hhayi lapho izigidi zamaYemeni zisengozini yokufa yindlala kuyilapho umfelandawonye wase-US/Saudi usebenzisa indlala njengesikhali.
Isiphetho sokuthi izimpilo zabantu baseMelika kuphela ezisematheni siqinisekiswa ukuthi uTrump wethule enye inhlekelele ukuhlasela eYemen ngoMeyi 23, lapho izakhamuzi ezimbalwa zaseYemeni ziphinde zabulawa khona. Kodwa amasosha aseMelika awafanga kulokhu kugasela, ngakho MSNBC wayengenasithakazelo. Inethiwekhi ayizange inikeze usizo kulokhu kuhlasela kwesibili kwe-Yemen.
Ukunakwa Njalo eRussia
Ngokosesho lwe-Nexis ekusakazweni kwenethiwekhi kusuka ngoJanuwari 1 kuya kuJulayi 2, 2017, "Yemen," "Yemeni" noma "Yemenis" kwashiwo ngo-68. MSNBC izingxenye—cishe zonke ezazihlobene nokugasela kwe-SEAL noma uhlu lwamazwe aqondiswe ekuvinjweni kukaTrump kwamaSulumane.
Cishe ezinyangeni eziyisithupha kusukela ngomhlaka-3 Julayi kuya ekupheleni kukaDisemba, amagama athi “Yemen,” “Yemeni” noma “amaYemeni” ashiwo ngezigaba eziyi-14 kuphela. Ezinxenyeni eziningi zalezi zigaba, i-Yemen ishiwo kanye nje ngokuhamba kwesikhathi.
Kuso lesi sikhathi esiyizinsuku eziyi-181 MSNBC zazingenazo izingxenye ezibhekiswe eYemen ngokuqondile, amagama athi “Russia,” “Russian” noma “Russian” ashiwo ekusakazweni okumangalisayo okungu-693.
Lokhu kusho ukuthi, engxenyeni yokugcina ka-2017, MSNBC yasakaza izikhathi ezingu-49.5 ngaphezulu—noma ngamaphesenti angu-4,950 XNUMX—izingxenye ezazikhuluma ngeRussia kunezingxenye ezazikhuluma ngeYemen.
Eqinisweni, ezinsukwini ezine kusukela ngoDisemba 26 kuya kuDisemba 29 kuphela, MSNBC yathi “Russia,” “Russian” noma “Russian” cishe izikhathi ezingama-400 ekusakazweni okuhlukene okungu-23, kuzo zonke izinhlelo ezinkulu zenethiwekhi, kuhlanganise I-Hardball, Bonke Ku, Rachel Maddow, Izwi Lokugcina, Hlangana nabezindaba Nsuku zonke futhi I-Beat.
Ngosuku olulandela uKhisimusi kwaboniswa ukuhlasela kweRussia. Ngo-December 26, amagama athi “Russia,” “Russian” noma “Russian” ashiwo izikhathi ezimangalisayo ezingu-156 ekusakazeni kusukela ngo-5 pm EST kuya ku-11 pm. Okulandelayo ukuhlukaniswa kwenani lokukhulunywa ngalo eRussia:
- izikhathi ezingu-33 I-MTP Nsuku zonke ngo-5 ntambama
- izikhathi ezingu-6 I-Beat ngo-6 ntambama
- izikhathi ezingu-30 I-Hardball ngo-7 ntambama
- izikhathi ezingu-38 Bonke Ku ngo-8 ntambama
- izikhathi 40 Rachel Maddow ngo-9 ntambama
- izikhathi ezingu-9 Izwi Lokugcina (u-Ari Melber egcwalisa u-O'Donnell) ngo-10 ebusuku
Ngalolu suku olulodwa, MSNBC ikhulume iRussia cishe izikhathi eziphindwe kabili emahoreni ayisithupha okusebenza kunalokho eyakusho ngeYemen kuwo wonke u-2017.
Ngenkathi MSNBC alizange libe nengxenye enikelwe ngokukhethekile empini yaseYemen ngaphandle kokusakaza okukodwa kuka-Ari Melber kaJulayi, izwe lashiwo ngezikhathi ezithile lapho lidlula.
UChris Hayes uvume kafushane iYemen izikhathi ezimbalwa, nakuba engazange anikele ingxenye kuyo. Ekusakazweni kwangomhla zingama-23 kuNhlaba Bonke Ku, umsingathi uveze ukuthi, "Besihlomisa futhi sisekela amaSaudis njengoba ephishekela impi yommeleli eYemen ngokumelene namavukelambuso aseShia, amaHouthis." Ngaphandle kweqiniso lokuthi impi yommeleli yaseSaudi/Iran eYemen lapho uHayes ekhuluma ngokusobala iyiphuzu lokukhuluma elidukisayo eliye lagqugquzelwa uhulumeni wase-US kanye nezinhlaka zezobunhloli futhi lananelwa ngokuzithoba yimithombo yezokuxhumana (FAIR.org, 7/25/17), uHayes namanje akakaziboni izindiza zomfelandawonye wase-US/Saudi ezibulale izinkulungwane zabantu.
Engxoxweni yangoJuni 29 Bonke Ku, isishoshovu sase-Palestine-America uLinda Sarsour uphinde wakhulumela "ababaleki base-Yemeni abayizisulu zempi yama-proxy esiyixhasa ngezimali." UHayes wengeze wathi, "Obani ababulawa yindlala, ngoba empeleni sixhasa amaSaudis ukuze abavimbezele." Lesi kwakuyisikhathi esingavamile lapho I-MSBNC ukuvumile ukuvinjwa kwe-Saudi Yemen-kodwa, futhi, akushiwo lutho ngezindiza zaseSaudi ezisekelwa yi-US ezibulale izinkulungwane zamaYemenis.
NgoJulayi 5, uChris Hayes wakhuluma esebenzisa izinkulumo ezeqisayo, ethi, "Selokhu athatha izintambo, umongameli useguqelwe ukuthatha uhlangothi lweSaudi Arabia engxabanweni yayo neYemen." Uma sibheka ngale kweqiniso lokuthi "ingxabano" iwukubukela phansi okudabukisayo kwempi enonya eholele ekufeni kwamashumi ezinkulungwane, uHayes wehlulekile ukukhomba ukuthi owayengumongameli uBarack Obama, njengoTrump, wayisekela ngokuqinile iSaudi Arabia njengoba ibhomu futhi ivimbezele. Yemen.
U-Rachel Maddow uphinde waphinde washo kafushane ngokuhlasela kuka-January kwe-US okuyiphutha eYemen ekusakazweni kwakhe ngo-Ephreli 7 no-24. Wenza kanjalo noHayes ngo-Okthoba 16.
On I-MTP Nsuku zonke ngoDisemba 6, uChuck Todd ngokufanayo wakhuluma ngeYemen edlula, ebheka:
Kuyathakazelisa, Tom, ukuthi umongameli ubonakala enalawa madlelandawonye eGulf State. Ubanika i-carte blanche kancane kulokho abakwenzayo e-Yemen, kufana nokubheka kwelinye icala.
Kodwa kunjalo. Ngaphandle kwengxenye ka-Ari Melber ephuma kanye kaJulayi, ngo-2017 MSNBC yayingekho enye indaba yempi esekelwa yi-US eye yadala inhlekelele enkulu yobuntu emhlabeni.
Okugqamayo wukuthi MSNBC ngokusobala igxeka kakhulu uDonald Trump, nokho idlulisele elinye lamathuba amahle kakhulu okugxeka izinqubomgomo zakhe. Esikhundleni sokumboza ezinye zezenzo zikaTrump ezimbi kakhulu, ezinodlame kakhulu—izenzo zakhe zempi ezishiye izinkulungwane eziningi zezakhamizi zifile—MSNBC uzishaye indiva izisulu zikaTrump eYemeni.
Mhlawumbe lokhu kungenxa yokuthi kwakungumongameli weDemocratic Alliance-uBarack Obama, intandokazi yakhe MSNBC-owaqala ukwengamela impi yaseYemen cishe iminyaka emibili ngaphambi kokuthi uTrump angene esikhundleni. Kodwa MSNBCimbangi yakwesokudla, Fox News, ikhombise kaningi ukuthi ayinankinga nokuhlasela amaDemocrat ngokwenza lokho amaRepublicans akwenza ngaphambi kwawo.
Ungathumela umlayezo kuRachel Maddow ku Rachel@msnbc.com (noma nge Twitter: @Maddow). UChris Hayes angafinyelelwa nge Twitter: @ChrisLHayes. Sicela ukhumbule ukuthi ukuxhumana ngenhlonipho yikho okusebenza kahle kakhulu.
