Ifilimu entsha, Umshini Wezempi, ku-Netflix okulingisa kuyo u-Brad Pitt uqala njengenhlekisa futhi egculisayo kaJenene Stanley McChrystal, cishe ngo-2009, kanye nezempi jikelele. Kuyahlekisa ngenxa ye-deadpan idiocy eqotho. Ukwanelisa okungenani thina ebesilokhu simemeza sithi “Nenzani nina ziwula?” iminyaka eyishumi nanhlanu nengxenye edlule.

Ingabe kufanele sijabule ngokuthi ifilimu yaseHollywood isengenziwa inhlekisa ubudlova obubulalayo bamakholwa eqiniso ezempi, noma kufanele siphazamiseke ngokuthi amathiyetha ngeke abonise amamuvi anjalo futhi kufanele aphelele ku-Netflix? Ingabe kufanele sijabule ukuthi impi ehlaselwe e-Afghanistan ayizange ilinde amashumi eminyaka impi ehlukile, ngendlela Mash, noma kufanele sikhathazeke ngokuthi ababukeli abaningi ngeke bazi ukuthi impi yamanje ihlekwa usulu ngoba bakholelwa ukuthi impi yase-Afghanistan isiphelile noma abakwazi nje ukuhambisana nokwanda kwezimpi?

Noma kunjalo, ngincoma ukuthi uqinisekise ukuthi wonke abathandi bama-movie, umlandeli ka-Brad Pitt, umuntu omusha, nomuntu omdala babukele le movie. Buka umkhuzi wamasosha okholwa ngokweqiniso kanye nama-sycophants akhe ngokuqaphela bakhetha ukunqoba impi engenakunqotshwa, bephakamisa ubuso obuqondile ukuze basebenzele ukuvikela abantu ngaphandle kokubabulala - noma ukubabulala kancane, noma okuthile.

Iqiniso eliyisisekelo lokuthi abantu abafuni abantu bakwamanye amazwe abahlomile emadolobheni abo futhi bakhetha ukungaqhunyiswa ngamabhomu livezwa lapha ngezingxoxo eziqondile kanye nokushintshisana kwamahlaya. Futhi umlingiswa kaBrad Pitt, osuselwe kuStanley McChrystal, naku-akhawunti kaMichael Hastings kaMcChrystal, uvezwa ephendule isando somuntu, engakwazi ukubona inkinga njengenye into ngaphandle kwesipikili - isifiso sakhe "sokuwina" impi. eqhubekisela phambili ubumpumputhe bakhe ekunganqotshweni nhlobo kwemisebenzi yangaphandle noma "ukulwa nobushokobezi" noma "ukulwa nobuphekula," obukwaziwa nangokuthi ubuphekula.

Yonke le nto iyeka ukuba yinto ehlekisayo ezingxenyeni ezintathu kwezine zendlela yokungena emuvi, lapho imibhikisho yamasosha angakwazi ukuhlukanisa izakhamuzi ezitheni iba isibonakaliso sangempela salokho kungakwazi. Uma sibuka uJenene ophethe echaza wonke amazwi akhe avamile namanga angenangqondo (ngisho noma eziqambela amanga, usaqamba amanga) endodeni ingane yayo esanda kubulawa amasosha ase-US, ukuhleka kuphelile.

Ngisho noma sibona umholi wedolobhana ecela uJenene ukuthi "ngicela uhambe manje," kukhona ukwaneliseka okuncane kulokhu kunxusa kwabantu base-Afghan kule minyaka eyishumi nengxenye edlule kufinyelele ezindlebeni zase-US, ngoba siyazi ukuthi amasosha aseMelika ngeke lalela njalo.

Siyazi futhi ukuthi le movie ihlanganisa izinga lesijeziso uStanley McChrystal wangempela azoke asithole ngamacala akhe. Ngeke kube khona ukuqulwa kwecala, akukho sinqumo esingokomthetho.

Ukuqagela ngembangela yokufa kukaMichael Hastings kuyaqhubeka, kodwa ukuqagela kokuthi abantu abaphahlaze umshini wempi wase-US e-Afghanistan unyaka nonyaka babulale umzamo oyize nowobugebengu wokuqhubekisela phambili izimfuno zabo kufanele kuphele. Akungabazeki ukuthi bakwenzile futhi lokho bakwenza ngezinga elikhulu. Banjalo, njengoba le filimu ikhomba, futhi njengoba kungekho phephandaba lase-US noma isiteshi sikamabonakude esilokotha ukusho, beka i-United States engcupheni ngaphansi kwesiqubulo seziqubulo ezithi bayayivikela futhi bayayivikela.

Nansi ingxenye yencwadi evulelekile eya kuMongameli uDonald Trump ukuthi noma ngubani angayisayina lapha:

I-United States isebenzisa i-4 million ihora ngezindiza, i-drones, amabhomu, izibhamu, nezinkontileka ezingaphezu kwezindleko ezweni elidinga ukudla kanye nemishini yokulima, okuningi okungakunikezwa amabhizinisi ase-US. Kuze kube manje, i-United States isetshenzisiwe $ 783 billion futhi akukho lutho oluzobonisa ngalo ngaphandle kokufa kwezinkulungwane Amasosha ase-US , kanye nokufa, ukulimala kanye nokuxoshwa kwezigidi zabantu base-Afghan. Impi yase-Afghanistan ibilokhu futhi izoqhubeka, inqobo nje uma iqhubeka, iyizinzile umthombo okwesabisa izindaba of ukukhwabanisa futhi imfucuza. Ngisho nokutshala imali emnothweni wase-US le mpi iye yaba i-bust.

Kodwa impi iye yaba nemthelela enkulu ekuvikelekeni kwethu: isengozini yethu. Ngaphambi kokuba uFaisal Shahzad azame ukushaya imoto eThekwini Square, wazama ukujoyina impi ngokumelene ne-United States e-Afghanistan. Kwezinye izigameko eziningi, amaphekula ahlasela i-United States asho izisusa zawo njengokufaka impindiselo empini yase-US e-Afghanistan, kanye nezinye izimpi zase-US esifundeni. Asikho isizathu sokucabanga ukuthi lokhu kuzoshintsha.

Ngaphezu kwalokho, i-Afghanistan yilona isizwe esisodwa lapho i-United States ibamba khona impi enkulu nezwe eliyilungu le-International Criminal Court. Umzimba lowo unayo manje kumemezela ukuthi kunjalo uphenyo ukushushiswa okunokwenzeka kwamacala e-US e-Afghanistan. Phakathi neminyaka eyi-15 edlule, siphathwe ngokuphindaphindiwe kokuphindaphindiwe kwezinkathazo: ukuzingela izingane ezindizeni ze-helicopter, ukushaya izibhedlela nge-drones, ukuvuthwa ngezidumbu - yonke inkulumo-mpikiswano ephikisana ne-US, konke ukuhlukumeza nokuhlazisa ama-United States.

Ukuyala amadoda amancane nabesifazane abancane baseMelika ukuba baye emsebenzini wokubulala noma wokufa owenziwe eminyakeni eyi-15 eyedlule kuyinto eningi okufanele ibuze. Ukulindele ukuba bakholwe kulolo mishini kuningi kakhulu. Leli qiniso lingasiza ukuchaza lokhu: umbulali ophezulu webutho lase-US e-Afghanistan uzibulala. Umbulali wesibili wezempi waseMelika uhlaza okwesibhakabhaka, noma intsha yase Afghan eqeqeshwa yi-US iphendulela izikhali zabo kubaqeqeshi bayo! Wena ngokwakho wazi lokhu, Bethi: "Masihambe e-Afghanistan. Amabutho ethu abulawa ama-Afghans esiwaqeqeshayo futhi sichitha izigidigidi lapho. I-Nonsense! Yakha kabusha i-USA. "

Ukuxoshwa kwamabutho ase-US kuzoba kuhle kubantu base-Afghan, njengoba khona kwamasosha angaphandle bekuyisivimbela ekukhulumeni ukuthula. Ama-Afghani ngokwawo kufanele anqume ikusasa labo, futhi azokwazi ukwenza lokho kuphela uma sekuphela ukungenelela kwamanye amazwe.

Siyanxusa ukuba uvule ikhasi kulokhu kungenelela kwezempi okuyingozi. Letha wonke amabutho ase-US ahambe esuka e-Afghanistan. Yeka ama-airstrikes ase-US futhi esikhundleni salokho, ngenca yezingqikithi, usize ama-Afghani ngokudla, indawo yokuhlala kanye nemishini yokulima.