#2 I-2013 Gas Attack eGhouta, eSiriya
I-Argumentum ad Hitlerum

Ama-propagandists nabalusi basidlala ezintweni zethu zokungazi lutho-ukudla kwethu okusheshayo Ukucabanga okungazi lutho. Ukuze silwisane nalokhu kudingeka senze ukucabanga okunzima okucatshangayo kokulinganisa ubufakazi futhi Isizathu.

Buka ividiyo engezansi kaJohn Kerry enkomfeni eParis ecela ukwesekwa ukushaya ibhomu eSiriya ngokuphendula ukuhlasela kwe-GNuta Ghouta Gas-ucabanga ukuthi, siholwa ekufakweni okungekho emthethweni?

Yiziphi izinto eziphakathi kwe-2013 Paris kanye nezinkomfa ze-1938 Munich?

Khumbula ukuthi uHitler wayesebenzisa umqondo ongathandabuzeki wokusiza abantu ukuba banganaki imithetho yamazwe omhlaba futhi bahlasele isizwe esibukhosi.

E-1938 eJalimane, iBrithani, iFrance ne-Italy bamenywa eNkomfeni yaseMunich ukuthi baxoxe ngezinsolo zikaHitler zokushushiswa kwamaJalimane aseSudeten eCzechoslovakia nesisombululo sakhe; ukwengeza i-Sudetenland. Amazwe amabili azimisele ukulwa nobukhosi beCzechoslovak ayengaphandle, iCzechoslovakia ne-USSR.

E-2013 Syria, i-Iran neRussia ayengekho emhlanganweni weParis. UHitler waqala izinkulumo ngokuthi:

"I-Germany ngeke isakwazi ukungabi nandaba nokuhlupheka nobubha bamaJalimane aseJuseten. Isibalo sabantu sibhekene noshushiso olunonya ... Lesi simo esinzima sidinga isinqumo ezinsukwini ezimbalwa. "

Inkulumo yakhe yamukelwa yibo bonke abakhona. Iqiniso liwukuthi, nakuba iSudetens ingakanikezwa ukuzimela okwethenjiswe uhulumeni waseCzech (ngenxa yokukhathazeka kokuphepha) "ukucindezeleka" kwakuyisabela seCzech ekucaseni ngamaphekula aseSudet ahlaselayo futhi axhasiwe nguHitler.

Ngokufanayo eSiriya the I-US, Turkey ne-Gulf Monarchies kuye kwasekelwa amandla e-proxy okuvukelayo ukulwa noHulumeni waseSiriya futhi njengoba uKerry athi emlayezo, i-US icabanga ukuthi "ingaphatha" isimo ne-ISIS ukuze idilize i-Assad. (inothi uKerry uthola amanye amagama axutshwe kodwa uzilungisa ngokwakhe)

Uyini ubufakazi bokuthi ukuhlasela kweGhouta nakho kwakungamanga?

I-1. Ngisho uma uqala ukubuka izithombe ezansi ngezansi kwe-BBC kubonakala sengathi zisola.

• Okwesisulu kufanele kubekwe endaweni ethambekele kancane (ukufisa uketshezi lomzimba kuvame ukubulala).
• Amanzi ahlanzekile emzimbeni omhlophe abonakala engenakwenzeka (bheka umbono wezokwelapha ngezansi).
• "… Awekho (kulawa mavidiyo) akhombisa abafundi abakhombayo… lokhu kungakhombisa ukuvezwa kwama-organophosphorus nerve agents."
  -John Hart, oyinhloko ye-Chemical and Biological Security Project eStockholm International Peace Research Inst.
• "I-foam ibonakala imhlophe kakhulu, ihlanzekile kakhulu futhi ayihambisani nokulimala kwangaphakathi ongayilindela ukuyibona, ongayilindela ukuba yi-bloodier noma i-yellower." - UStephen Johnson, iCranfield University Forensic Institute
• "... abantu abazisizayo abanakho izingubo zokuzivikela futhi bengenakho ukuphefumula, empeleni, bazobe bengcolisiwe futhi babe nezimpawu." - UPaula Vanninen, umqondisi weVerifin, iFinnish Institute for Verification of i-Chemical Weapons Convention
• Amanye amavidiyo ku-documentary ye-BBC, Ukulondoloza Izingane ZaseSiriya, ukusakaza usuku olulandelayo ngemuva kokuthi iPhalamende livote ngokumelene nokungenelela eSiriya kubonakala sengathi, uma kuhlolwe, kube nokungabaza.

Izingane ezibhekwa ukuthi zelashwa ngokushiswa kwamakhemikhali zibonakala zibhekene necala lekhamera kanti usizo lwezokwelapha luya ngokushesha ukuphatha i-ankle lingaboni abanye ababonakala bebuhlungu kakhulu. Uma kusebenza akukona amazinga we-BBC.

I-2. Bona ividiyo ngezansi kweCarla del Ponte, owayengumshushisi e-International Criminal Tribunal ye-Yugoslavia yangaphambili (ICTY) kanye ne-International Criminal Tribunal yeRwanda (i-ICTR) kanye nommeli jikelele kanye nommeli waseSwitzerland:

I-3. Ingabe i-US yayizoyikhathalela ngempela ukuthi izikhali zamakhemikhali zazisetshenziswa ngokumelene nabantu. I-US isetshenzisile i-uranium esebenzile ne-phosphorus emhlophe nalapho i-Iraq isebenzisa ama-nervo ama-Kurds (ngezansi) nama-Irani i-US yasekela i-Saddam Hussein futhi yabekwa i-Iranians ngokuhlaselwa. Futhi phawula umbala ogazini wamanzi ophuma emlonyeni nasemakhaleni.

I-4. Isifundo se-Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) (phawula ukuthi omunye wabalobi ungumphathi we-UN Weapons inspector) wathola ukuthi amakhomishini kagesi awakungeke avele ezindaweni ezigcinwe nguhulumeni kodwa kuphela ezindaweni ezivukelekile. Iphuzu labo lokugcina libonakala liqaphela kakhulu namuhla.

I-5. Izihloko zikaPulitzer umlobi wephephandaba u-Seymour Hersh uchaza ukuthi izikhulu zamtshela kanjani ukuthi lezi zihlubuki nazo zinegesi lesishukela nokuthi:

"Izinguquko zika-Obama (kusukela ekuhlaseleni iSiriya) zavela ePorton Down, i-laboratory yokuvikela eWiltshire. Ukuhlakanipha kwaseBrithani kwakutholile isampula ye-sarin esetshenziselwa ukuhlaselwa kwe-21 Agasti nokuhlaziywa kwabonisa ukuthi igesi elisetshenzisiwe alihambisani namaqoqo awaziwa ukuthi abekhona e-Armedal yezikhali zamakhemikhali aseSiriya. "

I-6. Enkulumweni ne-Obama yeThe Atlantic:

"UJames Clapper, umqondisi wakhe we-intelligence kazwelonke, owaphazamisa uMengameli we-Daily Brief, umbiko osongela u-Obama uthola ekuseni ngokusuka kwabacwaningi bakaClapper, ukucaca ukuthi ukuhlakanipha kweSiriya ekusetshenzisweni kwegesi le-sarin, ngenkathi kunamandla, kwakungeyona" i-slam dunk " . "

I-7. Ukuhlasela kweGhouta kwenzeka ngemuva nje kokuhlolwa kwezikhali ze-UN wafika eDamaseku. U-Assad ucele ukuba bafike baphenye ukuhlaselwa kwegesi elivukelayo ezindaweni eziphethwe nguhulumeni waseDamusus. Kubonakala kuyimangalisa ukuthi u-Assad uzongena engozini yokusebenzisa izikhali zamakhemikhali, ikakhulukazi ucabangela "u-Red Line" ka-Obama.

Ngibona kanjani lokhu:

Uhlaka lukaKerry lokukhiqiza ukuthi u-Assad noHitler bobabili abashiqela.
Sonke sasizwile lo mqondo izikhathi eziningi kwabanye abashiqela (okuphikisana ne-US).
Ukuzijwayeza ngalowo mbono kwenza kube lula ukuzamukela kalula.

Kodwa uma sicabanga ngakho ngokujulile; Kungenzeka yini ukuthi indlela ebaluleke kakhulu yokuyihlela ukubuza ukuthi ubani osongelayo ukungayinaki imithetho yamazwe omhlaba futhi ahlasele isizwe esibukhosi usebenzisa inkohliso engamanga?

“Ngakho-ke, ukuqala impi yobudlova, akukhona nje kuphela ubugebengu bamazwe omhlaba; yibugebengu obuphakeme kakhulu emhlabeni wonke obuhluke kuphela kwamanye amacala ezempi ngoba buqukethe ngaphakathi kubo ububi obuqongelelwe bonke. ” ~ Justice Robert Jackson, Izivivinyo zaseNuremberg

Ingabe lokhu kube ukukhiqiza okuqondile? Ucabangani?

Amazwana: