Kutheni le nto kungekho mntu ulilela abaqalisi bemfazwe eAfghanistan?

I-Tehran, i-IRNA-Imithombo yeendaba yaseNtshona igxeka uMongameli uJoe Biden ngesigqibo sakhe sokukhupha amajoni aseMelika e-Afghanistan, kodwa akukho mntu ugwebayo abo baqala ukubulawa ngo-2001, itshantliziyo laseMelika lithi.

by I-Arhente yeendaba yeRiphabhlikhi ye-Islamic, Agasti 24, 2021

Amajelo eendaba atyhola uBiden ngokurhoxa, kodwa kuvavanywa ukuba akukho tyala kuye nabani na ngokuqala imfazwe, u-Leah Bolger, umongameli we-World Beyond War, uxelele i-IRNA ngoLwesibini.

"UMongameli Biden ufumene ukugxekwa ngenxa yokuphatha gwenxa ukurhoxa, kwiCongress nakumajelo eendaba aseMelika, kwaye kufanelekile, kodwa bekungekho nto igxekwayo kwisigqibo sokuqala 'iMfazwe yoBoyikiso' kwasekuqaleni," Umongameli wangaphambili weVeterans For Peace waphikisa.

Efuna ukuba kuhlolisiswe ngakumbi okwenzekileyo kumashumi amabini eminyaka yemfazwe e-Afghanistan, uBolger uqaphele ukuba nanamhlanje, akubangakho dliwanondlebe nabaphembeleli bemfazwe, abaphengululi, iingcali zommandla, oonozakuzaku, okanye nabani na ocebise ngokuchasene nokuqala kwemfazwe. indawo yokuqala.

UBolger ukugxekile ukuphazanyiswa kwe-US kunye nokuhlaselwa komkhosi ngokusekwe kwizityholo ezingenabungqina, esithi ziphantse zaba ngama-800 iziseko zomkhosi kumazwe angama-81. Le meko ilusizi kwakungeyomfuneko ukuba yenzeke. Ngapha koko, imfazwe ngokwayo ngekhe yenzeke. I-US yaphehlelela ngokungekho semthethweni umlo wobundlongondlongo kwilizwe elingakhange lihlasele i-US okanye libonakalise naziphi na iinjongo zokwenza njalo.

Emva kwe-9/11, bekukho umnqweno omkhulu wokuziphindezela, kodwa ngubani? Kwathiwa u-Osama Bin Laden wayenoxanduva lokuhlaselwa kwe-9/11, kwaye iTaliban yathi bazakumnika ukuba i-US iyeke ukuqhushumisa i-Afghanistan. Kwakungaphantsi kweveki emva kokuba kuqhushumbe iibhombu zokuqala, kodwa uBush walile eli thuba, endaweni yoko wanyula ukuba aqalise umlo ongekho mthethweni okwaqhubeka amashumi amabini eminyaka, utshilo.

Ubuye wabhekisa kuluvo lwabantu baseMelika kunye nabase-Afghans kwimpikiswano, ephawula ukuba amajelo eendaba ngoku axela ukuba abantu baseMelika abacingi ukuba imfazwe ibifanele, kwaye bekhala ngokufa kwemikhosi yama-2300, kodwa amajelo eendaba aseMelika ' buza ama-Afghans ukuba bacinga ukuba kufanelekile.

Ngokubhekisele kwiziphumo zemfazwe yabantu kunye nabezomkhosi, wathi akukho nto ingako ikhankanyiweyo ngama-47,600 (ngoqikelelo olulondolozayo) base-Afghani ababuleweyo. Akukho nto malunga nezigidi zeembacu, ukonzakala okungenakubalwa, ukonakaliswa okungenakulinganiswa kwamakhaya, amashishini, izikolo, imfuyo, iziseko zophuhliso, iindlela. Akukho kwanto ngamawaka eenkedama nabahlolokazi abangenandlela yakuziphilisa. Akukho nto malunga nokwenzakala kwabo basindileyo.

Ubuye wabuza amawaka abantu base-Afghani ababeka ubomi babo emngciphekweni ngokusebenzela i-US njengabaguquleli okanye iikontraki ukuba bacinga ukuba imfazwe iyifanele okanye ngabantu abafanayo abaseleyo ngasemva ukuba baphile ubomi babo bonke besoyikisa iTaliban; isilumkiso sokuba ngokuqinisekileyo imfazwe ayifanele, kuba imfazwe ayifanele.

Ebonisa usizi ngokwenzekileyo nakwinto eyenzekayo ngoku e-Afghanistan ngenxa yezigqibo zamagosa aseMelika, wakhankanya ukuba ukurhoxa e-Afghanistan akukho nto iphosakeleyo, esongeza ukuba abantu ababambelele kunene babambelele kwi-fuselage yenqwelomoya, iintsana nabantwana Ukugqithiswa ngaphezulu kwesandla ukuya ngaphambili phambi kwesihlwele, abazali ngokuqinisekileyo bafuna ukuba abantwana babo babaleke-nokuba abanako-andiyicingi into ebuhlungu.

Umzabalazo wakhomba kumgaqo-nkqubo wase-US wokuphelisa imfazwe e-Afghanistan, esithi nangona abongameli abaninzi bethethile ngokushiya i-Afghanistan kule minyaka ingamashumi amabini idlulileyo, kuyabonakala ukuba kwakungekho sicwangciso sayo nantoni na, mhlawumbi kuba kwakungekho njongo yokwenyani. ukushiya konke konke.

Unobhala Wezomkhosi wase-US u-Lloyd Austin kutshanje uxelele ukuba bekungekho khetho olufanelekileyo kwisigqibo sika-Mongameli Biden sokurhoxisa amajoni e-Afghanistan.

UMark Milley, usihlalo wase-US weeNtloko zabasebenzi, kunye no-Lloyd Austin bavumile ukuba akukho lwazi, lubonisa ukuba iTaliban izakuthatha ulawulo e-Kabul kungekudala.