NguDavid Swanson, World BEYOND War, UDisemba 10, 2023
Nge-9 kaDisemba, i-Hill yapapasha "Ngaba iMelika iya kusilela kuvavanyo lukaPeter Singer eUkraine?” nguAlexander J. Motyl, owaqala ngokuthi:
Ngaba iiRiphabhlikhi ze-MAGA ezifuna ukucima uncedo lwase-US e-Ukraine zisebenza ngokusesikweni? Ukuwubeka ngokucacileyo lo mbandela, ngaba bayaluxhasa ubugebenga bemfazwe obusenziwa yiRashiya eUkraine okanye akunjalo?”
Kucingelwa ukuba abo bethu bangathandi i-fascistic buffoons KUNYE neemfazwe ezingapheliyo ezibulalayo ezibeka emngciphekweni i-apocalypse yenyukliya ngelixa sixhela abantu, sitshabalalisa indalo esingqongileyo, sithintela intsebenziswano yehlabathi kwiingxaki ezingezizo ezokuzikhethela, ukutshabalalisa umthetho, ukugxila kunye nokuchitha ubutyebi obufunekayo, ukuxhaphaza uluntu lwethu. , kunye nokunciphisa iinketho zezopolitiko zase-US kwi-MAGA okanye i-MICIMATT, kwaye ngubani ofuna ukunqumla izixhobo e-Ukraine nokuba izixhobo zibizwa ngokuba "uncedo," kodwa ngubani ongathanda ukunyusa ngokukhawuleza uncedo loluntu kunye nendalo engqongileyo e-Ukraine nakwihlabathi liphela. , kufuneka ngokunjalo atyholwe ngokuziphatha ngokungekho mthethweni kunye nokuxhasa ukufudumala kweRussia kunye neeRiphabhlikhi ze-MAGA ezinezikhundla ezingaphezulu kwezethu kwaye ubukho babo buphawulwa kumaphephandaba.
UMotyl uyaqhubeka:
"Le mibuzo iyaphazamisa, kwaye iyacaphukisa, ngakumbi njengoko besinyanzela - kunye namaRiphabhlikhi e-MAGA - ukuba sibuze ukuba sinetyala njengamaRussia ekuxhaseni inkokeli, UVladimir Putin, nemfazwe etshabalalisa ngabom uhlanga.”
Ayingomdlalo lo. U-Motyl akazami ukukukhohlisa ukuba ucinge ukuba uyathandabuza malunga nokuxhobisa u-Israyeli okanye ukuphikisa ukuthanda kwehlabathi kwiZizwe eziManyeneyo zoxolo ePalestina. Le ngcamango, ndiqinisekile, ayizange ingene nasengqondweni yakhe. Wenza ngathi uhlobo lwentetho ekhapha imfazwe eGaza lukhapha imfazwe yaseUkraine. Ewe kunjalo, ndiyakholelwa ukuba imfazwe yaseRussia e-Ukraine isondele kakhulu njengoko bekuya kuba njalo ukuba ibikhatshwa yintetho egwenxa, kanye njengoko ndicinga ukuba ulwaphulo-mthetho oluncinci lusondele kakhulu ngaphambi kokuba lufumane isimo "sobugebenga bentiyo. ” Kodwa uMotyl uyazibuza ukuba angakwazi kusini na ukubanga ukuba urhulumente okude owanceda ukuvusa inkathazo eUkraine kwaye wathintela isisombululo soxolo semfazwe kwiintsuku zayo zokuqala, ngelixa elahla ubutyebi kwizixhobo zemfazwe - intywenka yemali eyafunyanwa nguPeter Singer. uyazi kakuhle ukuba ngebuguqule ubomi beebhiliyoni ukuba bube ngcono ukuba ibichithwe kwenye indawo - nokuba urhulumente ukude eWashington unetyala lokufudumeza iRussia njengeRussia, kwaye hayi ngokucaphukisa ngokuphandle "iMfazwe eNgaxhaswanga" kodwa ngokusilela. ukuphosa izixhobo ezingakumbi ukuyigcina iqhubeka, njengoko omabini amacala evuma ukuba akanathemba kwaye bekrwempa iintloko zabo bemangalisekile ukuba yintoni abanokuyenza ngaphandle kokusilela kuVavanyo lwePete Seeger, kwaye bathi ukutyhala esinqeni- nzulu kudaka olukhulu.
UMotyl uyaqhubeka:
"Intanda-bulumko uPeter Singer ucebise indlela enika umdla yokujongana nolu hlobo lombuzo kwilinge lakhe lokucinga "lomntwana otshonayo". Nantsi indlela uMvumi Yibeke: 'Ukuze ndicele umngeni kubafundi bam ukuba bacinge ngemilinganiselo yokuziphatha esiyityala abantu abasweleyo, ndibacela ukuba bacinge ukuba indlela yabo yokuya eyunivesithi ibadlula kwichibi elingekho nzulu. Ngenye intsasa, ndithi kubo, uphawula ukuba umntwana uwile kwaye ubonakala ngathi uyarhaxwa. Ukungena nokukhupha umntwana kuya kuba lula kodwa kuya kuthetha ukuba iimpahla zakho zimanzi kwaye zinodaka, kwaye xa ugoduka kwaye utshintshe uya kuba uphose iklasi yakho yokuqala. Emva koko ndibuza abafundi: ngaba unayo nayiphi na imbopheleleko yokuhlangula umntwana? Ngamxhelo mnye, abafundi bathi benza njalo. Ukubaluleka kokusindisa umntwana ukuza kuthi ga ngoku kuneendleko zokufumana iimpahla zikabani zibe nodaka nokuphoswa yiklasi, ukuba bayala ukuyiqwalasela nayiphi na isizathu sokungasindisi umntwana.’ Emuva ngoFebruwari 2022, xa uPutin waseRussia wasungula imfazwe yayo yonke, iUkraine yayingumntwana orhaxwayo kwaye sasingabahambi ngendlela. Ukubonelela ngoncedo lwasemkhosini oluxabisa iibhiliyoni zeedola akufani ncam nokungcolisa iimpahla zakho, kodwa kuluntu oluzityebi njengeMelika ibingeyondleko eyoyikekayo, ngakumbi njengoko uninzi, malunga neepesenti ezingama-90, zemali echithwe kwi. IUkraine yahlala e-United States, inegalelo kuqoqosho lwaseMelika, ibonelela ngemisebenzi kunye nokukhuthaza utyalo-mali. ”
Igama elithi "ngokuphikisayo" kuphela kwenyani ethembekileyo kulo mhlathi uphela. Masiyiphathe njengenjalo kwaye siphikisane nalo mgquba oqhumayo wesikweko. Ngamawaka ezigidi zeerandi ukuphelisa indlala eMhlabeni okanye ufezekise imimangaliso emininzi ENGAQHASHISANGA okanye ithelekise iimpahla zomntu ezinodaka kunye nokufika emva kwexesha eklasini. Ukulahla imali kubathengisi bezixhobo i drain yezoqoqosho, hayi inzuzo yezoqoqosho. Kwaye ngaphaya kobu buxoki busisiseko, umntu uya kuqaphela ukuba umbono osisiseko wokuba ukulwa imfazwe ukuyigcina iqhubeka kwaye kuthintelwe ukuxoxisana ekuxoxisaneni kuthathwa njengento enenzuzo, engazange iphikiswe nakancinci. Ukuba bekuya kuphikiswana ngayo, bekuya kuba ngcono ngaphandle kwezafobe. Kakade ke, uninzi lwethu luye lwenjenjalo wenze ityala ngokuchasene naloo mbono amawaka amaninzi amaxesha iminyaka.
UMotyl uyaqhubeka:
"Ukunceda iUkraine ngoko ibikukuzicingela kunye nokuziphatha kakuhle."
Intwana yokuzingca isekelwe kubuxoki, kwaye intwana elungileyo, kwakhona, icingelwe nje, ayizange iphikiswe ngesivakalisi esinye.
UMotyl uyaqhubeka:
"Into yokuba iRussia yophule imithetho yezizwe ngezizwe ekusunguleni imfazwe yayo yenza ukunceda iUkraine kube lula, njengoko ibonelele i-US inani elikhulu lamaqabane anqwenela ukusindisa umntwana orhaxwayo."
Ngokulinganayo? Hayi ngeedola ezilinganayo zezixhobo zasimahla, oko kuqinisekileyo, hayi ngokupheleleyo okanye nge-capita nganye okanye nge-GDP nganye. Kwaye ukhuthazwa kukwaphulwa kwemithetho yamazwe ngamazwe? Ngokwenene? Ngokunyanisekileyo? I-United States inikwe umceli mngeni olungileyo yiRussia, njengoko nguSirayeli, njengoozwilakhe abakhohlakeleyo urhulumente wase-US axhasa iingalo kunye nenkxaso, kodwa akukho nto ikhuphisanayo malunga nokuba nguwuphi na urhulumente ongumxhaphazi ophezulu we-veto ye-UNSC, ephezulu. ukubamba amalungelo abantu asisiseko kunye nezivumelwano zokuchithwa kwezixhobo, umaphuli-mthetho ophezulu wezivumelwano zemfazwe kunye nezixhobo, umthengisi wezixhobo eziphezulu kwihlabathi, umthengisi wezixhobo eziphezulu kwizinto ezibona ngathi ngoorhulumente abacinezelayo, umchasi ophezulu kunye nokutshatyalaliswa kwe-ICC. kunye ne-ICJ, izizwe ezohlwayayo ezixhasa umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, zivumela abasebenzi benkundla ukuba bathintele umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe. Ukusebenzisa i-Ethics 101 Ukufa kweNgcinga yeFantasy Iimvavanyo kwiintsomi eziguqula ubunyani azibutshintshi ubunyani.
UMotyl uyaqhubeka:
“Nanku uMvumi: ‘Ngaba kuyawenza umahluko, ndiyabuza, ukuba kukho abanye abantu abadlula echibini abanokuthi ngokufanayo bahlangule umntwana kodwa bangakwenzi oko? Akunjalo, abafundi baphendula bathi, isibakala sokuba abanye bengenzi oko bafanele bakwenze akusosizathu sokuba ndingenzi oko ndifanele ndikwenze.' Ngokungafaniyo nabanye abantu ababedlula echibini, uninzi lwabemi bamazwe ngamazwe bazibandakanya kumzamo wokusindisa iUkraine.”
Ngokwenyani iinzame zokuxhobisa imfazwe ziye zachaswa luninzi lwehlabathi kunye noninzi loorhulumente behlabathi, abathi-uMvumisi uchanekile-alutshintshi uxanduva lwakhe lokuziphatha, kodwa uphakamisa iflegi ebomvu malunga nokuswela kwakhe ukuthobeka, ukuswela. lokukwazi ukuqwalasela iingxoxo zabanye, nohanahaniso oluhlasimlis’ umzimba ngalo lonke ixesha igama elithi “idemokhrasi” okanye amagama athi “Umyalelo Osekelwe Kwimigaqo” okanye “Uluntu Lwezizwe Ngezizwe” lidlula emilebeni kabani.
UMotyl uyaqhubeka:
“Khawuleza ukuya kuDisemba ka-2023 kwaye ukuba kunokwenzeka ukuba isoyikiso saseRiphabhlikhi sokunciphisa uncedo eUkraine sinokuba yinyani. Imeko namhlanje iya kufana nale meko ilandelayo. Njengomhambi olungileyo, iUnited States yamsindisa umntwana ngo-2022. Phantse kwiminyaka emibini kamva, iMelika ibambe umntwana eyamsindisa kwaye ihamba ngaphaya kwechibi. Iqhubeke ithwele umntwana? Ngapha koko, umntwana ubeke ubunzima, uyakhala, uyasiphazamisa emsebenzini wethu. Okanye ngaba ifanele ithomalalise umthwalo ngokubuyisela umntwana echibini, mhlawumbi ejonge phezulu, ngethemba lokuba akayi kuphethuka aze arhaxwe?”
Ezi zinto ziyafana ngengqiqo yokuba impuku iyafana nomntu. Mhlawumbi yile ndlela uMculi uye wayichaza ngayo kuMotyl; Andaz. Kodwa ukugcina imfazwe iqhubeka kuya kubabulala abantwana abanyanisekileyo kuthixo, kanti ukungayigcini iqhubeka kuya kuba “fana” nokurhaxwa umntwana kuphela ngengqiqo yokuba unjingalwazi uvumelekile ukuba achwetheze nawaphi na amagama avakalelwa kukuba logama nje engazange atsho. 'Ukuvuma ixabiso labantu basePalestina, enokuthi ibe sisizathu esihle sokuphelisa umsebenzi wakhe.
UMotyl uyaqhubeka:
"AmaRiphabhlikhi e-MAGA, njengomcebisi wabo uDonald Trump, bathi, ewe, uxolo, e-Ukraine, ube ngumthwalo omkhulu kwaye, uthanda okanye awuthandi, kufuneka sikususe. Kwiminyaka emibini edlulileyo, sakusindisa. Kodwa asinakukugcina uphila ngonaphakade. Asiyi kukubulala, kodwa, njengamaGrike amandulo, siya kukushiya apho sikufumene khona kwaye sivumele oothixo banqume ukuba uya kuphila okanye ufe. Ukungakhathali kwikamva lomntwana bekuya kuba yinto engekho mthethweni kwiminyaka emibini edlulileyo. Namhlanje lulwaphulo-mthetho olungakumbi, njengoko lubandakanya isigqibo esisengqondweni sokulahla umntwana osempilweni.”
Andizukucamngca ixesha elide ukuba yintoni le ifanele ukuba sempilweni kule meko, okanye kutheni urhulumente wase-US wayengekho zingqondweni kwiminyaka emibini eyadlulayo.
Akukho ndlela yokuphepha isigqibo esilusizi sokuba iiRiphabhlikhi ze-MAGA zisebenza ngokufanelekileyo, mhlawumbi ngesazela nangengqondo, zixhasa ukutshatyalaliswa kwe-Ukraine ngenjongo yokukhupha ingxaki encinci. Kwaye ekubeni i-ajenda kaPutin e-Ukraine yi-genocide kwaye ekubeni i-US ibe ngumqobo ophambili ekukwazini ukufezekisa loo njongo, isikhundla se-GOP sisebenza ngokufanelekileyo, kwaye ngokubuhlungu, sixhasa ukubulawa kwabantu. Yeha, loo nto yenza ukuba i-MAGA Republicans ibe netyala kwaye inoxanduva lolwaphulo-mthetho lukaPutin njengolugqithisayo. inani elikhulu yabantu baseRashiya abakhetha ukutshabalalisa iUkraine kunokusinda eUkraine.”
UMotyl ke uqukumbela ngokuzenza ngathi uyachasa ukubulawa kwabantu ngexesha leNakba yesiBini, kwaye elinganisa abemi baseRussia kunye nobubi borhulumente waseRussia, olona hlobo lobudenge obunokukhokelela ekubulaweni kwabantu.
Kutheni le nto iiyunivesithi zinikwa isihogo esinjalo xa abongameli bazo bevela njengezidenge phambi kweCongress, kwaye hayi xa oonjingalwazi babo bepapasha ezi ntlobo zamanqaku, beguqula ngokufanelekileyo imicimbi yobomi nokufa ibe yimidlalo yobudenge?
