I-Russia ethandekayo-Yayingena-Choice Bahlobo

NguDavid Swanson, World BEYOND War, NgoMeyi 24, 2023

Nantsi "i-syllogism" eyoyikisayo evela kumntu omangalisayo, uRay McGovern, umqeshwa weCIA ixesha elide, emva koko umlweli woxolo ixesha elide, kwaye ngoku ubambene unyaka wonke ukuba iRussia yayingenandlela yimbi ngaphandle kokuhlasela iUkraine.

“AmaRashiya ayenezinye iindlela zokuhlasela iUkraine.
Bahlasela iUkraine 'ngemfazwe yokuzikhethela'; iphinde igrogrise iNATO.
Ke, iNtshona kufuneka ixhobise iUkraine ngamazinyo, ibeka emngciphekweni imfazwe ebanzi. ”

Oku kucingelwa ukuba yinkcazo yengcinga yethu makholwa yokuba iRussia yayinokhetho ngaphandle kokuhlasela iUkraine. Enyanisweni, ibonisa umgama olusizi nomkhulu kakhulu phakathi kweengcinga zabantu ababekhe bavuma ukuba imfazwe yayiziintloni, kodwa ngoku abaye bachitha ixesha elingaphezu konyaka bengakwazi ukweyiselana nantoni na.

Ngokuqinisekileyo esi sicatshulwa singasentla asiyo-sylogism kwaphela. Le yi-sylogism:

Isisongelo semfazwe sifuna imfazwe.
IRashiya isongelwa ngemfazwe.
IRashiya ifuna imfazwe.

(Okanye bhala into enye endaweni yaseUkraine eRashiya.)

Kodwa kunjalo oku:

Isisongelo semfazwe asifuni mfazwe.
IRashiya isongelwa ngemfazwe.
IRashiya ayifuni imfazwe.

(Okanye bhala into enye endaweni yaseUkraine eRashiya.)

Ukungavisisani kuphezu kwesiseko esikhulu. I-syllogism ayisosixhobo esiluncedo kakhulu sokucinga; nje ukucinga ngendlela yakudala yokucinga. Umhlaba ngokwenene untsonkothile, kwaye umntu unokwakhela eli, naye: "Isoyikiso semfazwe ngamanye amaxesha sifuna imfazwe, kuxhomekeke." (Baye yiba nempazamo.)

Ukuba isoyikiso okanye imfazwe, kunye nemfazwe yokwenyani, kwiimeko ezininzi ayifuni mfazwe ekuphenduleni kodwa yoyiswe ngezinye iindlela ngumba werekhodi. Umbuzo ke ngowokuba ingaba eli xesha lalahlukile na kuwo onke loo maxesha.

Naku okunye ukungavisisani. Yiyiphi kwezi eyinyaniso?

"Ukuchasa elinye icala lemfazwe kufuna ukukhusela elinye icala."

or

"Ukuchasana nelinye icala lemfazwe kunokuba yinxalenye kunye nenxalenye yokuchasana nawo onke amacala azo zonke iimfazwe."

Lo ngumbuzo oyinyaniso, kwakhona, ngumba orekhodiweyo. Abo bethu bachithe zonke ezi nyanga zininzi begxeka zonke izenzo zemfazwe macala omabini emfazwe e-Ukraine banokubonisa icala ngalinye zonke izityholo esizifumeneyo zokuxhasa zombini icala kunye nelinye icala-kwaye. bonke ubungqina ukuba bonke bayaphazama.

Kodwa mhlawumbi akunamsebenzi nokuba umntu uphupha ukuba ndivuyisa i-NATO kwaye ngokufihlakeleyo kumvuzo we-Lockheed Martin. Bafuna nje impendulo kumbuzo omangalisayo we-slam-dunk drop-the-mic win-yonke-intanethi yombuzo othi "Ewe, yintoni i-eff eyayinokwenziwa yiRussia, inokwenzeka?"

Ngaphambi kokuba ndichaze into eyayinokwenziwa yiRussia, ngexesha lobunzima obukhulu kwaye kwiinyanga ezidlulileyo kunye neminyaka kunye namashumi eminyaka, kufanelekile ukumba amanye amaGrike amandulo elinye ixesha elingakumbi:

IRashiya kwafuneka ikhusele i-NATO.
Ukuhlaselwa kwe-Ukraine kwaqinisekiswa ukuba iza kubonelela ngeyona nto inkulu i-NATO yakha yabonwa ebomini.
Ngoko ke iRashiya kwafuneka ihlasele iUkraine.

Mhlawumbi i-syllogism ingaba luncedo emva kwayo yonke into? Ezi ndawo zimbini ziyinyani ngokugqibeleleyo. Ngaba ukho umntu onokuyibona into engekhoyo? Kubonakala ngathi akunjalo, ubuncinane kungekhona kunyaka wokuqala kunye nekota. I-US yabeka umgibe kwaye iRashiya yayingenayo enye into ngaphandle kokuthatha i-bait? Ngokwenene? Esinjani sona isithuko kwiRashiya!

Kwisithuba sonyaka odlulileyo ndibhale inqaku elithi “Izinto ezingama-30 ezingenabugorha ezazinokuthi zenziwe yiRussia kunye nezinto ezingama-30 ezingezizo ezinokuthi zenziwe yiUkraine.” Nalu uluhlu lwesiRashiya:

IRashiya inokuba:

1. Qhubeka nokuhlekisa uqikelelo lwemihla ngemihla lohlaselo kwaye udale umdla kwihlabathi liphela, endaweni yokuhlasela kwaye wenze uqikelelo luphele nje ngeentsuku.
2. Kuqhutyekwe nokufuduswa kwabantu eMpuma Ukraine ababeziva besongelwa ngurhulumente waseUkraine, umkhosi, nezihange zamaNazi.
3. Unikeze abafuduki ngaphezulu kwe-29 yeedola ukuba baphile; wabanika izindlu, imisebenzi, kunye nengeniso eqinisekisiweyo. (Khumbula, sithetha ngezinye iindlela zokulwa impi, ke imali ayisiyonto kwaye akukho ndleko igqithisayo iya kuba ngaphezulu kokuhla kwibhakethi yenkcitho yemfazwe.)
4. Yenza isiphakamiso sokuvota kwiBhunga lezoKhuseleko le-UN ukuba ledemokhrasi umzimba kunye nokuphelisa i-veto.
5. Ucele i-UN ukuba yongamele ivoti entsha eCrimea malunga nokujoyina kwakhona iRussia.
6. Wajoyina iNkundla yoLwaphulo-mthetho yamazwe ngamazwe.
7. Ucele i-ICC ukuba iphande ulwaphulo-mthetho eDonbas.
8. Kuthunyelwe eDonbas amawaka amaninzi abakhuseli abangaxhobanga.
9. Kuthunyelwe eDonbas abona baqeqeshi babalaseleyo behlabathi kuxhathiso olungenabundlobongela.
10. Iinkqubo zemfundo ezixhaswa ngemali kwihlabathi liphela ngexabiso leyantlukwano yenkcubeko kubuhlobo kunye noluntu, kunye nokusilela okugqithisileyo kobuhlanga, ubuzwe, kunye nobuNazi.
11. Kususwe awona malungu e-fascist kumkhosi waseRussia.
12. Inikezelwa njengezipho kwi-Ukraine eyona ndawo iphambili ehlabathini kwizixhobo zokuvelisa amandla elanga, umoya, kunye namanzi.
13. Uvale umbhobho werhasi onqumla eUkraine kwaye uzibophelele ukuba ungaze wakhe omnye emantla apho.
14. Ubhengeze ukuzibophelela ekushiyeni amafutha efosili yaseRashiya emhlabeni ngenxa yoMhlaba.
15. Inikezelwa njengesipho kwiziseko zombane zaseUkraine.
16. Inikezelwa njengesipho sobuhlobo kwiziseko zikaloliwe zaseUkraine.
17. Ubhengeze inkxaso kwidiplomacy yoluntu ukuba uWoodrow Wilson wenza ngathi uyayixhasa.
18. Yazisa kwakhona iimfuno ezisibhozo eqale ukuyenza ngoDisemba, kwaye yacela iimpendulo zoluntu kurhulumente ngamnye wase-US.
19. Ucele abantu baseRussia-baseMelika ukuba babhiyozele ubuhlobo baseRussia naseMelika kwindawo yesikhumbuzo ye-teardrop eyanikwa iUnited States yiRussia ngaphandle kweZibuko laseNew York.
20. Ujoyine izivumelwano ezinkulu zamalungelo oluntu engekaqinisekiswa, kwaye wacela ukuba nabanye benze okufanayo.
21. Ibhengeze ukuzinikela kwayo ekuxhaseni ngokuzimeleyo izivumelwano zokuthotywa kwezixhobo ezahlulwe yi-United States, kwaye ikhuthaze ukubuyisela.
22. Ubhengeze umgaqo-nkqubo wenyukliya ongasetyenziswanga kuqala, kwaye ukhuthaze okufanayo.
23. Ubhengeze umgaqo-nkqubo wokukhulula imijukujelwa yenyukliya kunye nokuzigcina zikwimeko ephaphileyo ukuvumela ngaphezu kwemizuzu nje ngaphambi kokuqalisa i-apocalypse, kwaye kwakhuthazwa okufanayo.
24. Kucetywe ukuvalwa kokuthengiswa kwezixhobo kumazwe ngamazwe.
25. Uthethathethwano olucetywayo ngabo bonke oorhulumente abaxhobe ngenyukliya, kuquka nabo banezixhobo zenyukliya zase-US kumazwe abo, ukunciphisa nokuphelisa izixhobo zenyukliya.
26. Uzibophelele ngokungagcini izixhobo okanye imikhosi ngaphakathi kwe-100, 200, 300, 400 km yayo nayiphi na imida, kwaye yacela okufanayo kubamelwane bayo.
27. Ulungelelanise umkhosi ongenabundlobongela ukuba uhambe kwaye uqhankqalaze naziphi na izixhobo okanye imikhosi ekufutshane nemida.
28. Yenza umnxeba kwihlabathi ukuba amavolontiya ajoyine uhambo kunye noqhanqalazo.
29. Kubhiyozelwe iyantlukwano yoluntu lwamatsha ntliziyo kwihlabathi jikelele kwaye kwaququzelelwa imisitho yenkcubeko njengenxalenye yoqhanqalazo.
30. Ubuzwe amazwe aseBaltic acebe iimpendulo ezingenabugorha kuhlaselo lwaseRussia ukunceda ukuqeqesha abantu baseRussia kunye nabanye abantu baseYurophu ngokufanayo.

Ndixoxe ngale nto le nkqubo kanomathotholo.

Ndiqinisekile ukuba kulilize, kodwa nceda wenze umgudu wokwenene wokukhumbula ukuba oku kwakunjalo kwinqaku ngento enokwenziwa liqela ngalinye endaweni yokuphambana kokubulawa kwabantu abaninzi, ukubeka esichengeni i<em>apocalypse yenyukliya, ukulamba kwehlabathi, ukuthintela intsebenziswano kwimozulu, nokonakalisa ilizwe. Nceda wenze umgudu wokwenene wokukhumbula ukuba sonke besisoloko sikuqaphela kabuhlungu lonke ubundlobongela base-US malunga neRashiya. Ke, impendulo ethi "Ndingacebisa njani ukuba iRussia iziphathe ngcono kunorhulumente ombi welizwe apho ndihlala khona, eUnited States?" yinto eqhelekileyo: Ndichitha ixesha lam elininzi ndifuna ukuba iUnited States iziphathe ngcono, kodwa ukuba ihlabathi lonke lingayifumana ngaphakathi kwalo ukuba liziphathe kakuhle kangangokuba ubomi eMhlabeni bugcinwe ngaphandle kwayo yonke imizamo yaseWashington, Ndiza kuba nombulelo ngaloo nto - kwaye ngokuqinisekileyo andizukuyidimaza.

Mhlawumbi abaphembeleli boxolo baseRussia bachasa ngenkalipho ukufudumala kwesizwe sabo, njengoko sonke kufuneka sichase ezethu, balahlekisiwe kakhulu, kodwa andiqondi ukuba banjalo.

Ke, kutheni kungenakwenzeka ukwenza omnye nomnye aqonde apho sivela khona, wena Russia-Had-No-Choicers kunye nam? Uyakrokrela ukuba isinxibo sakudala sikaRay sindityibela imali okanye ndiyoyika ukubizwa ngokuba “nguPutin Lover” - ngokungathi andikhange ndibe nazo izoyikiso zokufa ngenxa yokuchasa imfazwe yase-Iraq ngendiyithengise ngayo. Ukubetha kwentliziyo ukubizwa nje ngokuba “ngumthandi wase-Iraq.”

Ukukukrokrela kwam ngawe kusenokuba kubi njengawe kum, kodwa andiqondi ukuba kunjalo, kwaye ndithetha ngentlonipho epheleleyo.

Ndiyakrokrela ukuba ucinga ukuba icala elinye lemfazwe alilunganga, elinye lilungile-kwaye lilungile kuzo zonke iinkcukacha. Ndiyakrokrela ukuba ulichasile icala lase-US lemfazwe e-Iraq kodwa hayi icala laseIraq. Ndiyakrokrela ukuba uyalichasa icala lase-US lemfazwe e-Ukraine, kwaye ucinga ukuba ilandela nje ukuba nantoni na eyenziwa licala laseRashiya iyancomeka. Ndicinga ukuba sobabini sibuyela emva kwiminyaka yokulwa. Ndabe ndiyakhala “Yekani obu bubhanxa bubhanxayo, nina nobabini!” kwaye ubuya kungxama ukubuza ujonge ukuba yeyiphi isidenge ebesilungile kwaye esona sibi. Okanye ubuya kwenjenjalo?

Ndiyakrokrela ukuba awufuni kunika ingcinga kule minyaka la macala mabini ayichithayo engakwazi ukulungiselela ukhuselo olungaxhomekanga, kwaye ucinga ukuba nokuba iRussia yenza ntoni ukubhenela ekuziphatheni nasekulungeni kwehlabathi, ihlabathi liya kuba nako. batshice eRussia kwaye babambe iipopcorn ukuze babukele i-US / NATO buildup. Nangona kunjalo, kunye neRussia yenza izenzo zokubulala ezoyikekayo, nangona kunjalo sibone uninzi lwehlabathi-kunye noorhulumente abaninzi behlabathi! Ukwala ukuma kwicala le-NATO, ngaphandle koxinzelelo olukhulu, kwaye ngaphandle kwehlazo elibi lokubonakala likhusela, okanye lityholwa ngokukhusela, ukufudumala kweRussia. Asinakuze siyazi ukuba ihlabathi laliza kuphendula njani ukuba iRashiya isebenzise isenzo esikhulu kunye nobuchule obungenalo ubundlobongela, ukuba iRashiya ijoyine imibutho yomthetho wamazwe ngamazwe, ukuba iRashiya isayinwe kwizivumelwano zamalungelo oluntu, ukuba iRashiya yayifuna ukwenza idemokhrasi amaziko ehlabathi, ukuba iRashiya yabhenela ihlabathi. ukwala i-impiriyalizim yase-US ngokukhetha ihlabathi elilawulwa lihlabathi liphela.

Mhlawumbi urhulumente waseRashiya akafuni ukuwela phantsi kolawulo lomthetho njengoko urhulumente wase-US esenza. Mhlawumbi ifuna ulungelelwaniso lwamandla, hayi ukulingana kobulungisa. Okanye mhlawumbi icinga njengabantu abaninzi kuluntu lwaseNtshona - kwanabaninzi abaye benza njengabalweli boxolo iminyaka - ukuba imfazwe kuphela kwempendulo ekugqibeleni. Kwaye mhlawumbi isenzo esingenabundlobongela besiya kusilela. Kodwa kukho ubuthathaka obubini kuloo ngcinga endicinga ukuba ayinakuphikiswa.

Enye yeyokuba ngoku sikufutshane kunangaphambili kwi-apocalypse yenyukliya, kwaye xa sihambile asiyi kukwazi ukuxoxa ukuba ngubani owayelungile kunobani.

Enye into yokuba ukwakhiwa kwe-US / NATO kwakungaphaya kwamashumi eminyaka kunye neminyaka kunye neenyanga. IRashiya yayinokulinda olunye usuku okanye i-10 okanye i-200, kwaye ngelo xesha yayinokuqalisa ukuzama enye into. Akukho mntu wakhetha ixesha lokunyuka kweRashiya ngaphandle kweRashiya. Kwaye xa ukhetha ixesha lento, ubunokukhetha ukuzama enye into kuqala.

Okubaluleke ngakumbi, ngaphandle kokuba omabini amacala avuma impazamo kwaye avumelane nokulalanisa okuthile, imfazwe ayizukuphela kwaye ubomi emhlabeni bunokubakho. Bekuya kuba lihlazo ngokwenene ukuba besingenakuvumelana ngaloo nto ingako.