#2 I-2013 Ground Attack eGhouta, eSiriya
I-Argumentum ad Hitlerum

Abapropagandists kunye nabalumbi badlala kwizinto zethu zokungazi kakuhle-ngokukhawuleza kwethu ukucinga okungenangqondo. Ukumelana nale nto kufuneka sikwenze ukucinga okulukhuni kokulinganisa ubungqina kwaye sizathu.

Jonga ividiyo engezansi kaJohn Kerry kwintlanganiso yaseParis ecela inkxaso ekuqhubheni i-Aram ngokuphendula kwi-2013 Ghouta-Ukuhlaselwa kweGasi-ucinga ntoni, ngaba siholwa ekuzalweni kobuxoki?

Ziziphi izinto eziqhelekileyo phakathi kwe-2013 Paris kunye neenkomfa ze-1938 Munich?

Gcina ukhumbule ukuba uHitler wayesebenzisa ingcamango yokuba ngumntu ongalungelelanisa umthetho wamazwe ngamazwe aze ahlasele isizwe esilawulayo.

Kwi-1938 eJamani, iBrithani, iFransi neItaly bamenywa kwiNgqungquthela yaseMunich ukuxubusha izimangalo zikaHitler zokutshutshiswa kwamaJamani aseJusseten eCzechoslovakia nesisombululo sakhe; ukunyusa iSudetenland. Amazwe amabini azimisele ukulwa nobukhosi beCzechoslovak ayengabandakanywa, iCzechoslovakia kunye ne-USSR.

Kwi-2013 iSiriya, i-Iran kunye neRashiya yayingabandakanywa kwinkomfa yaseParis. UHitler waqalisa iintetho ngokuthi:

"IJamani ayisakwazi ukuqhubeka ingakhathaleli ukuhlupheka kunye neentlupheko zamaJamani aseJusseten. Uluntu lugxininiswe lugxininiso oluthile ... Le meko ixakeke idinga isisombululo kwisithuba seentsuku. "

Intetho yakhe yamkelwe ngabo bonke abakhona. Inyaniso kukuba, nangona i-Sudetens ayengakhange inikezwe ukuzimela okuthembisiswa nguRhulumente waseCzech (ngenxa yokukhathazeka kwezokhuseleko) "ukunyanzeliswa" kwakuyimpendulo yaseCzech ekuxhaseni ngobundlobongela be-Sudeten obuxhaswa ngemali kunye noxhaswa nguHitler.

Ngokufanayo eSiriya US, Turkey kunye neGulf Monarchies baye baxhasa amandla ovukeli Ukulwa noRhulumente waseSiriya kunye njengoko uKerry athi kwi-audio, i-US icinga ukuba "ilawula" imeko kunye ne-ISIS ukuba iguqe uAassad. (inqaku likaKerry ufumana amagama adibeneyo kodwa ulungisa ngokwakhe)

Yiyiphi ubungqina bokuba i-Ghouta Attack nayo yayiyinto engamanga?

1. Ngaphandle kokujonga kuqala iifoto ezingezantsi kwi-BBC zibonakala zikhohlise.

• Ixhoba kufuneka libekwe kwindawo ethambekele kwimeko enqwenelekayo (umnqweno wamanzi omzimba uhlala ubulala).
• Amachiza omzimba amhlophe amhlophe ayabonakala engenakwenzeka (jonga uluvo lwezonyango olungezantsi).
• "… Akukho nanye (iividiyo) ebonisa abafundi abachongiweyo… oku kungabonisa ukubonakaliswa kwearhente ye-organophosphorus."
  -John Hart, intloko yeProjekthi yeMichiza kunye neBiological Security kwi-Extension International Peace Research Institute yaseStockholm.
• "I-foam ibonakala imhlophe kakhulu, ihlambulukile kwaye ayihambelani nolu hlobo lokulimala kwangaphakathi onokulindela ukuyibona, okuza kulindela ukuba yi-bloodier okanye i-yellower." - UStep Johnson, iCranfield University Forensic Institute
• "... abantu ababancedayo abanalo naliphi na impahla yokukhusela kwaye bengenawo uphefumlo, ngokwenene, baya kuhlambalaza kwaye babeya kuba neempawu." - UPaula Vanninen, umlawuli weVerifin, isiFinishi seNkxaso yokuQinisekisa INgqungquthela yeziTyhulwa zeMichiza
• Ezinye zevidiyo kwi-documentary ye-BBC, Ukugcina abantwana baseSiriya, ukusasaza ngomhla emva kokuba iPhalamende livotele ukungenelela kweSiriya kubonakala, xa kuhlolwe, ukuba yinto engathandabuzekiyo.

Abantwana abathiwa baphathwa ngokutsha kweekhemikhali kubonakala ngathi baphendule kwiinkomera kwaye uncedo lwezokwelapha luya kwangoko ukuphatha i-ankle ingahlolisanga abanye ababonakala bebuhlungu kakhulu. Ukuba iyakwenza oko akuyiyo kwimigangatho ye-BBC.

2. Bona ividiyo ephantsi kweCarla del Ponte, owayengumtshutshisi kwi-International Criminal Tribunal kwi-Yugoslavia yaseYugoslavia (i-ICTY) kunye ne-International Criminal Tribunal yeRwanda (i-TPIR) kunye nommeli jikelele kunye nommeli waseSwitzerland:

3. Ngaba i-US yayiyakhathalela ukuba izixhobo zamakhemikhali zisetyenziselwa ukulwa nabantu. I-US isebenzise i-uranium kunye ne-phosphorus egciniweyo kwaye xa i-Iraq isebenzisa ama-nerbia ama-Kurds (ngezantsi) kunye nama-Irani ase-US asekela uSaddam Hussein kwaye athi ama-Irani ahlaselwa. Kwakhona phawula umbala ogazini wamanzi ophuma emlonyeni nasempumlweni.

4. Isifundo se-Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) (qaphela ukuba omnye wabalobi ungumhloli weZixhobo ze-UN zangaphambili) wafumanisa ukuba imimandla yegesi ayifumanekanga kwiindawo ezigcinwe zikarhulumente kodwa kuphela kwiindawo ezivukelekileyo. Ingongoma yabo yokugqibela ibonakala iyasasa kakhulu namhlanje.

5. Amanqaku ngombhali wePulitzer umlobi we-Pulitzer u-Seymour Hersh ichaza indlela amagosa awaxelela ngayo ukuba abavukeli babenomdla wegesi kwaye:

"Uguquko luka-Obama lwengqondo (ukusuka ekuhlaseleni iSiriya) lwavela kwiPorton Down, i-laboratory yokukhusela eWiltshire. Ubulumko beBrithani bufumene isampuli ye-sarin esetyenziswe kuhlaselo lwe-21 ka-Agasti kunye nohlalutyo lubonise ukuba igesi esetyenzisiweyo ayizange ifane nama-batch ezaziwa ukuba zikhona kwi-arsenal yeArms. "U

6. Kwi-intanethi no-Obama ye-Atlantic:

"UJames Clapper, umlawuli wakhe weengcaphephe zesizwe, ophazamise uMongameli we-Daily Brief, ingxelo engozini uB Obama ufumana ekuseni ngokusuka kwabalandeli baClapper, ukuba acacise ukuba ingqiqo yaseSiriya yokusetyenziswa kwegesi ye-sarin, ngoxa yayinamandla, yayingekho" i-slam dunk " . "

7. Ukuhlaselwa kweGhouta kwenzeka emva nje kokuvavanya izixhobo ze-UN fikile eDamasko. U-Assad wayecele ukuba baze bahlole uphando lwegesi lovukelo kwimimandla yaseburhulumenteni yaseDamusus. Kubonakala kuyimangalisa ukuba u-Assad unokubeka umngcipheko ukusebenzisa izixhobo zamakhemikhali ngoko, ngokubhekiselele kwi-"Low Red Line "ka-Obama.

Ndiyibona njani:

Isakhelo sikaKerry sokuvelisa ukuba ngu-Assad noHitler bobabini abalawuli.
Sonke sivile ukuba loo maxesha aphindwe ngamanye amaqhinga (awachasene ne-US).
Ukuqhelanisa naloo mbono kwenza kube lula ukuvuma.

Kodwa ukuba sicinga ngoku ngakumbi; ingaba ukuba yindlela ebaluleke ngakumbi yokuyibeka kuyo ukubuza ngubani osongelayo ukungahoywa uMthetho wamazwe ngamazwe kwaye uhlasele isizwe esilawulayo usebenzisa uqikelelo lobuxoki?

“Ukuqala umlo wobundlobongela, ke, ayilolwaphulo-mthetho lwamazwe aphela; lolona lwaphulo-mthetho lubalaseleyo lwamazwe ngamazwe olwahlukileyo kuphela kolunye ulwaphulo-mthetho lwemfazwe kuba ngaphakathi luneengcinga ezibandakanyekileyo kubo bonke. ” ~ Ubulungisa uRobert Jackson, izilingo zaseNuremberg

Ngaba oku kuvelisa ngokuchanekileyo? Ucinga ntoni?

Amazwana: