Kodwa ummisa njani uPutin kunye neTaliban?

NguDavid Swanson, World BEYOND War, Februwari 12, 2022

Xa ndicebisa ukuba ungebi iibhiliyoni zeedola e-Afghanistan, kwaye ke ayibangeli indlala enkulu kunye nokufa, kungenjalo abantu abakrelekrele nabanolwazi bandixelela ukuba amalungelo oluntu afuna ubusela. Abantu abalamba de bafe yindlela yokukhusela “amalungelo abo oluntu,” enyanisweni. Yiyiphi enye indlela onokuthi (okanye urhulumente wase-US) ayeke ukubulawa kweTaliban?

Xa ndiphendula ukuba wena (urhulumente wase-US) unokusivala isohlwayo senkunzi, uyeke ukuxhobisa kunye nokuxhasa ngemali ababulali abaphezulu behlabathi ukusuka eSaudi Arabia ukuya phantsi, ujoyine izivumelwano ezinkulu zamalungelo oluntu, usayine kwaye uxhase iNkundla yoLwaphulo-mthetho lwamazwe ngamazwe, emva koko - ukusuka isikhundla esithembekileyo-funa ukunyanzelisa umthetho e-Afghanistan, ngamanye amaxesha abantu bacinga ukuba akukho nanye into eyakha yenzeka kubo, ngokungathi amanyathelo asisiseko anengqondo ayengenakucingelwa ngokoqobo, ngelixa izigidi zabantwana abancinci bebulawa yindlala ngenxa yabo. amalungelo oluntu ayenengqiqo ngandlel’ ithile.

Kukwafuneka ndibaleke umntu omnye e-United States engazibandakanyi kwiphulo loxolo ongakholelwayo ukuba i-United States kufuneka iyeke “ubundlongondlongo” ngo “Putin” eUkraine. Mhlawumbi andinxibelelani ngokwaneleyo nababukeli beFox News abafuna imfazwe neTshayina okanye iMexico kwaye bacinge ukuba iRussia yimfazwe enganqweneleki kangako, kodwa akucaci kum ukuba umntu onjalo angaphikisa iyelenqe elingenangqondo likaPuinesque elichasene neUkraine kakhulu. andikhathali ngayo.

Xa ndiphendula ngelithi ukuba iRussia ibibeke iCanada kunye neMexico kumfelandawonye wasemkhosini, imijukujelwa yancamathela eTijuana naseMontreal, yaqhuba umlo omkhulu e-Ontario, kwaye yalumkisa ilizwe lonke ngohlaselo lwase-US oluzayo lweSiqithi iPrince Edward, kwaye ukuba urhulumente wase-US. wayefuna ukuba imikhosi kunye nemijukujelwa kunye nezivumelwano zemfazwe zomkhosi zisuswe, oomabonwakude bethu baya kusixelela ukuba ezo ziyimfuneko ezifanelekileyo (ezingazukuyicima into yokuba iUnited States inomkhosi omkhulu kwaye ithanda ukoyikisa imfazwe, okanye okubi ngakumbi. -Than-inrelevant fact that iUnited States ineempazamo zorhulumente wasekhaya) - xa ndithetha yonke loo nto, ngamanye amaxesha abantu benza ngathi ndiveze imfihlo egoba ingqondo.

Kodwa kunokwenzeka njani oko? Ngaba abantu abakrelekrele ngokugqibeleleyo abanalo nofifi lokuba i-NATO ithembise ukuba ayizukwandisa ngasempuma xa iRussia yavuma ukudityaniswa kweJamani, ingazi ukuba i-NATO iye yanda ngqo kwi-USSR yangaphambili, akukho mbono yokuba i-US inemijukujelwa eRomania nasePoland, akukho mbono. ukuba i-Ukraine kunye ne-NATO baye bakha amandla amakhulu kwelinye icala le-Donbas (njengeRashiya emva koko kwelinye), kungekho mbono yokuba iRashiya yayingathanda ukuba ngumhlobo okanye ilungu le-NATO kodwa yayixabiseke kakhulu njengotshaba, kungekho mbono yokuba. Kuthatha ezimbini ukuya kwi-tango, akukho mbono wokuba uxolo kufuneka luthintelwe ngononophelo kodwa imfazwe yenziwe ngenkuthalo-kwaye uninzi lweengcinga ezinzulu kakhulu zokukuxelela malunga nendlela yokumisa ukuhlasela kukaPutin?

Impendulo ayikho mnandi, kodwa ndicinga ukuba ayinakuphepheka. Amawakawaka abantu abachithe kule nyanga idlulileyo benza udliwano-ndlebe kwaye benza iiwebinars kunye nokubhala amanqaku kunye nezithuba zeblogi kunye nezikhalazo kunye neebhanile kunye nokufundisana iinyani ezicacileyo malunga ne-Ukraine kunye ne-NATO zikhona kwihlabathi elahlukileyo ukusuka kwi-99 yepesenti yabamelwane babo abakhoyo. ihlabathi elidalwe ngamaphephandaba kunye nomabonwakude. Kwaye oku kulishwa kakhulu kuba akukho mntu - nditsho nabathengisi bezixhobo esele bevuthela ingeniso eyenziwe kule mfazwe - bafuna imfazwe kakhulu kunamaphephandaba kunye neendawo zethelevishini.

Ngaba iIraq inazo iiWMDs? yayingengombuzo nje abawunike impendulo engalunganga kuwo. Yayiyipropaganda engekho ngqiqweni phambi kokuba nabani na ayiphendule. Awunako ukuhlasela kwaye ubhombe ilizwe nokuba urhulumente walo unezixhobo okanye akanazo. Ukuba ubukwenzile, umhlaba ubunokuba nelungelo lokuhlasela kwaye ubhombuze i-United States ebinazo zonke izixhobo ezityhola i-Iraq ngokuba inazo.

"Uyeka njani ukuhlasela kukaPutin?" ayingombuzo nje abawunika impendulo engeyiyo. Yipropaganda engenangqondo ngaphambi kokuba nabani na ayiphendule. Ukuyibuza yinxalenye yephulo lokuxhokonxa nje uhlaselo lo mbuzo uzenza ngathi unomdla wokuthintela. Ngaphandle kokusongela naluphi na uhlaselo, iRussia yabeka iinyanga ezimbini ezidlulileyo into eyifunayo. Umbuzo wepropaganda "Uluyeka njani ukuhlasela kukaPutin?" okanye "Awufuni ukuyeka ukuhlasela kukaPutin?" okanye "Awukuthandi ukuhlasela kukaPutin, akunjalo?" isekelwe ekuphepheni naluphi na ulwazi lwe iimfuno ezifanelekileyo ngokupheleleyo ezenziwe eRashiya Ngelixa usenza ngathi umlawuli wase-Asiya “ongenakuqondwa” usoyikisa ngendlela engaqondakaliyo namanyathelo angalindelekanga anokuthi nangona kunjalo athintelwe ngokumoyikisa, ukumoyika, ukumcaphukisa kunye nokumthuka. Kuba ukuba ngenene ubufuna ukuthintela imfazwe eDonbas endaweni yokudala enye, ungavuma ngokulula kumabango afanelekileyo awenziwe yiRussia ngoDisemba, uphelise obu bugeza, kwaye utshintshele ekujonganeni neemeko ezingezizo ezokuzikhethela ezifana ne-ecosystems kunye nenyukliya. ukuthotywa kwezixhobo.