Doodda hadda socota ee ku saabsan ka bixitaanka qorshaysan ee ciidamada Mareykanka iyo NATO ee xarumaha Afghanistan iyadoo la aaminsan yahay fikrad wanaagsan oo ah in falanqeeyihii hore ee CIA-iyo saaxiibkey Paul Pillar kashifay 12 sano ka hor. Paul wuxuu ugu yeeray "caqiidada muhiimka ah ee ah in Afghanistan aan loo ogolaan inay markale hoy u noqoto kooxaha argagixisada, gaar ahaan al-Qaacida".
Iyadoo Axadda Washington Post "Sky Is Falling" - nooc digniin ah, Iyo NY Times'Maureen Dowd ayaa leh Maya maahan, halkee ayuu qofku uga jeedaa khibrad macquul ah oo macquul ah?
Dhib malahan: Kaliya dib u aqri Paul Pillar's Washington Post la sii daayey Sebtember 16, 2009, oo uu Bawlos xaq u lahaan lahaa: Argagixisanimo Oo Loogu Talo Galay Dad. Post wuxuu doortay cinwaanka: “Xerada Dhabta ah ee Argagixisadu Kuma Jirto Dhulka, Waa Online. "
Kuwa soo socda ayaa ah qaybo ka mid ah:
Muhiimad intee le'eg ayey u leedahay kooxaha argagixisada meel kasta oo hoy ah? … Intee in le'eg ayey gabaad saameyn ku yeelataa halista weerarrada argagixiso ee ka dhanka ah danaha Mareykanka, gaar ahaan waddanka Mareykanka? Jawaabta su'aasha labaad ayaa ah: ugu badnaan inta ay la tahay fikradaha aan la caddeyn. … Diyaargarowgii ugu muhiimsanaa ee Sept. 11, 2001, weeraradu kama dhicin xeryaha tababarka ee Afqanistaan laakiin, waxay ahaayeen, guryaha Jarmalka, qolalka hudheelada ee Spain iyo iskuulada duulimaadyada ee Mareykanka. Labadii sano ee la soo dhaafey, kooxaha argagixisada caalamiga ahi waxay ku najaxeen isticmaalka dhiig-miirashada adduunka iyo teknolojiyadda macluumaadka, taas oo yareysay ku tiirsanaantoodii goobaha jireed.
Arrinta maanta ayaa ah in ka hortagga gabbaad noocaas ah ay yareynayso khatarta argagixisanimo ee Mareykanka oo ku filnaan doonta waxa ay haddii kale noqon lahayd si loo dheellitiro kharashka loo baahan yahay ee dhiigga iyo maalka iyo caqabadaha hortaagan guusha Afgaanistaan, oo ay ku jiraan talis aan waxtar lahayn iyo taageerada sii xumaaneysa dadka. Joojinta abuuritaanka goob jireed sidoo kale waa inay dib u dhigtaa xoojin kasta oo loo qaado argagixisada Mareykanka ee ka soo horjeeda fikradaha ah in Mareykanku noqday qabsade halkii uu difaaci lahaa Afghanistan.
Tiirka iyo Madaxa-ugaarsadayaasha
Paul Pillar wuxuu xilal sar sare ka soo qabtay CIA, oo uu ku jiro Sarkaalka Sirdoonka Qaranka ee Bariga Dhexe - jagada ugu sareysa ee aagaas - wax badana wuu ka ogyahay argagixisada, sidoo kale. Wuxuu noqday madaxa falanqaynta ee Xarunta ladagaalanka argagixisada 1993 iyo kuxigeenka agaasimaha xarunta afar sano kadib. Markii uu sayidkii-farshaxan-weyne Cofer Black la wareegay Xarunta 1997, si kastaba ha noqotee, Tiirka wuu ka tegey - "isku dhaca qaababka" awgeed, sida uu sheegay Steve Coll Dagaalada cirfiidka: Taariikhda Sirta ah ee CIA, Afghanistan iyo Bin Laden (Penguin, 2005).
Ma aha wax adag in la sharraxo sababta Tiirka fekerka ah iyo Madowga hyperactive u noqon doono sida saliidda iyo biyaha oo kale. Hawlwadeenka dhammeystiran, Black waxaa markii ugu dambeysay lagu xusay Guddiga sare ee sumcadda shirkadda tamarta Yukreeniyaan ee Burisma. Laakiin taasi waa uun sheegashadiisii ugu dambaysay ee shakiga ahayd ee caan ka ahayd.
Aargudashadu waa tayda, ayuu yidhi Black
Dib uga fikir maalmihii aargudashada ee ugu dambeeyay wixii ka dambeeyay 9/11, iyo habka macho ee uu u qaabeeyey Madaxweyne Bush oo uu khadka ka dhigo hawl wadeennada CIA iyo wakiilladooda saameynta ku leh warbaahinta - iyadoo Cofer Black uu u eg yahay isku darka Shakespeare's Herodias, Lady Macbeth, iyo Lewis Carroll Boqoradda Qalbiga.
Sarkaalka CIA-da ah ee Gary Schroen ayaa u sheegay Raadiyaha Dadweynaha ee Qaranka in maalmo uun ka dib 9/11, madaxa la dagaalanka argagixisada Cofer Black uu u diray Afghanistan isagoo ku amraya “Qabashada bin Laden, dil, oo madaxiisa ku soo celi sanduuq baraf qallalan ah”. Marka laga hadlayo hoggaamiyeyaasha kale ee al-Qaacida, Black ayaa la sheegay inuu yiri, "Waxaan rabaa inay madaxooda kor saaraan dusha sare."
Codkan dhawaqan - iyo luqadda - wuxuu ku dhexcaalay khubarada ku xeel dheer sirdoonka, had iyo jeerna doonaya inay caawiyaan.
Xirmooyinka Basaasnimada-Baadida
Mid ka mid ah dhammaystirka gudaha, Washington Post halyeey Jim Hoagland xoogaa ayuu dul maray markii uu daabacay warqad furan oo uu u diray Madaxweyne Bush Oktoobar 31, 2001. Ma aheyn wax kaftan Halloween ah. Hase yeeshe, Hoagland waxay si adag u taageertay waxa uu ugu yeeray "hamiga" madaxa Osama bin Laden oo fuushan baaskiil, taasoo uu ku andacooday inay ahayd ujeeddada Bush "jeneraallada iyo diblomaasiyiinta".
Layaab meesha ay Hoagland ka heshay quudkaas dhiigga badan.
Isla mar ahaantaana, waxaa jira khataro in lala wadaago macluumaad aad u tiro badan xayawaanka gudaha / dibedda. Waraaqda furan ee uu u diray Bush, Hoagland waxay kor u qaadday daaha dhabta ah, qorshaha ciyaarta dhiiga badan leh bilaha soo socda iyadoo la siinayo Bush amarka soo socda ee ahmiyadaha. Baahida loo qabo wax ka qabashada sii socoshada Ciraaq ee hubka bayoolojiga iyo kiimikada iyo tikniyoolajiyadda lagu dhisayo bam nukliyeer sinnaba ugama yaraan karto dalabaadka ololaha Afqaanistaan. Waa inaad sameysaa ololahaas si aad si dhakhso leh uga dhex muuqato si aad u joojiso khatarta uu leeyahay nidaamka Saddam Hussein. Si uun, Hoagland waxay heshay fikirka “udub dhexaadka” seddex isbuuc ka hor xoghayaha gaashaandhiga Donald Rumsfeld oo u yeeray Gen. Tommy Franks si uu ugu sheego in madaxweynuhu doonayo inuu diirada u saaro ciraaq. Franks iyo kaaliyayaashiisa sare waxay ka shaqeynayeen qorshayaal lagu weerarayo Tora Bora halkaas oo la aaminsan yahay in bin Laden uu ku dhuumaaleysanayo laakiin fiiro gaar ah, qorsheyn, iyo ilo si kadis ah loogu weeciyay dhanka Ciraaq. Sidaa darteed Osama Bin Laden wuxuu sida muuqata ka baxay Tora Bora isagoo sii dhex maray buurta loo maro Pakistan.
Ujeeddada halkan ka jirtaa waxay tahay in sirdoonka ugu cadcad warbaahinta ay si aad ah ugu wanaagsan yihiin dacaayadeeyayaasha CIA - qayb ahaan maxaa yeelay waxay ka taxaddarayaan inay qaniinto gacmaha iyaga quudiya iyagoo dhaleeceeya CIA. Khubaradaas waxay leeyihiin buug cinwaan ah oo culus oo ay ku qoran yihiin magacyada saraakiisha howlaha CIA-da - kuwa u sheegay kuwa Washington Post xoogag isbuucaan dhamaanaya in cirka uu dhici doono hadii Biden uu ka keeno ciidamada Afghanistan. Ka eeg hoosta "P" buugaagta cinwaankaas; Uma maleynayo inaad heli doontid “Paul Pillar”.
Ma jiraan kuwa si farxad leh u rajeyn lahaa in "dagaal weligiis ah" uu ka dhaco Afgaanistaan? Hagaag, ka waran Jeff Bezos, oo iibsaday Washington Post sideed sano ka hor, wali iyadaa gacanta ku haysa, qandaraasyo badana la leh CIA. Waan necbahay inaan ka dhawaajiyo wax aan badnayn, laakiin waxaas oo dhan hoosta waxaa ku jira MICIMATT (Milatariga-Warshadaha-Kongresska-Sirdoonka-Warbaahinta-Dhismaha Caddemia-Think-Tank. [Culeyska ayaa la raaciyay.]
Ray McGovern wuxuu la shaqeeyaa Tell the Word, oo ah qayb daabacan oo ka tirsan Kaniisadda Ecumenical ee Badbaadiyaha ee ku taal gudaha magaalada Washington. Xirfadiisii 27-sano ee uu ahaa falanqeeyaha CIA-da waxaa ka mid ah u adeegida Madaxa Madaxa Laanta Siyaasadda Dibadda ee Soofiyeedka iyo diyaarinta / soo-koobiyaha Warbixinta Kooban ee Madaxweynaha. Isagu waa aasaasaha Xirfadleyda Sirdoonka Veteran for Sanity (VIPS).
