Nhaurirano yazvino nezve kubviswa kwakarongwa kwemauto eUS neNATO kubva kuAfghanistan nzvimbo nekutenda kwakashata kwekuti aimbove muongorori weCIA Paul Pillar akaburitsa makore gumi nemaviri apfuura. Paul akaitumidza "kiyi inokosha yekuti Afghanistan haifanire kubvumidzwa kuvezve nzvimbo yemapoka emagandanga, kunyanya al-Qaeda".
ne Svondo Washington Post "Denga Iri Kudonha" -yambiro yetaipi, Uye NY Times'Maureen Dowd achidaro Kwete hazvisi, munhu anotendeukira kupi kune humwe hunyanzvi hune ruzivo ruzivo?
Hapana dambudziko: Ingo verengazve yaPaul Pillar Washington Post op-ed yaGunyana 16, 2009, iyo inogona kunge yakanzi naPaul: Ugandanga hweDummies. The Post rakasarudza musoro wenyaya: “Gandanga chairo Haiti Haisi Pasi, Iri Pamhepo. "
Zvinotevera ndezvinyorwa:
Zvakakosha sei kumapoka emagandanga pane chero nzvimbo yekugara? … Nzvimbo yakachengetedzwa nemagandanga inorwisa zvido zveUS zvakadii, kunyanya nyika yokumusha kweUS? Mhinduro kumubvunzo wechipiri ndeyekuti: kwete zvakatowanda sekufungidzira kusinga fungidzike. … Gadziriro dzakakoshesesa kusvika musi waGunyana 11, 2001, kurwiswa kwakaitika kwete mumisasa yekudzidzira muAfghanistan asi, asi, mumafurati eGerman, makamuri ehotera kuSpain uye zvikoro zvendiza muUnited States. Mumakumi emakore apfuura, mapoka emagandanga epasi rese akasimba nekushandisa kudyidzana kwenyika nehunyanzvi hweruzivo, izvo zvakadzora kuvimba kwavo nenzvimbo dzekugara.
Nyaya iripo nhasi ndeyekuti kudzivirira nzvimbo yakadaro kunodzikisira kutyisidzira kuUnited States zvakakwana kubva pane zvazvingava kubvisa mari inodikanwa yeropa nepfuma uye zvipingamupinyi zvekubudirira muAfghanistan, kusanganisira husina simba hutongi uye kutsigira kutsigira kubva huwandu hwevanhu. Kunokanganisa kugadzirwa kwenzvimbo yepanyama kunofanirwawo kugadzirisa chero hugandanga hunopokana neUS hunobva pamaonero ekuti United States yainge yava mugari kwete mutsigiri weAfghanistan.
Mbiru vs. Musoro-Vavhimi
Paul Pillar akabata nzvimbo dzakakwirira kwazvo paCIA, kusanganisira National Intelligence Officer kuMiddle East - chinzvimbo chepamusoro kwazvo munzvimbo iyoyo - uye anoziva zvakanaka nezvehugandanga, zvakare. Akave mukuru wekuongorora kuCounterterrorist Center mu1993 uye mutevedzeri wemukuru weCentre makore mana gare gare. Apo vatema-art-master Cofer Black vakatora iyo Center muna 1997, zvisinei, Mbiru yakasiya - nekuda kwe "kupesana kwemaitiro", sekureva kwa Steve Coll in Ghost Wars: Iyo Chakavanzika Nhoroondo yeCIA, Afghanistan neBin Laden (Penguin, 2005).
Hazvina kuoma kutsanangura kuti nei Mbiru inofungisisa uye Nhema isingaite ingave semafuta nemvura. Anopedzisa opareta, Mutema akapedzisira kutaurwa paBhodi yeanozivikanwa simba reUkraine simba femu Burisma. Asi izvo zvinongova zvirevo zvake zvekupedzisira zvisina musoro zvekurumbira.
Kutsiva ndekwangu, anodaro Mutema
Funga kumashure kune mazuva ekutsiva munguva pfupi yapfuura ya9 / 11, uye nzira yemaziso iri kuteedzerwa neMutungamiri Bush uye yakadzora mutsara neveCIA vashandi pamwe nevamiriri vavo vane simba munhau - neCofer Black ichirira kunge mubatanidzwa weShakespeare's Herodias, Lady Macbeth, naLewis Carroll Mambokadzi weMoyo.
Anoshanda neCIA, Gary Schroen akaudza National Public Radio kuti, kwasara mazuva mashoma 9/11, mukuru weCounterterrorist Cofer Black akamutumira kuAfghanistan achiraira kuti "Capture bin Laden, vamuuraye, vodzosa musoro wake mubhokisi paaizi yakaoma." Kana vari vamwe vatungamiriri veAl Qaeda, Mutema anonzi akati, "Ndinoda misoro yavo pamusoro pemapiki."
Iyi toni isinganzwisisike - uye mutauro - inodzokororwa pakati penjere-inoshamwaridzika mapundits, anogara achida kubatsira.
Spy-Pundit Kushamwaridzana Zvisungo
Mumwe anopedzisa mukati, Washington Post murwi muhondo Jim Hoagland akafamba zvishoma mukuburitsa tsamba yakashama kuna President Bush musi waGumiguru 31, 2001. Yakanga isiri Halloween prank. Asi, Hoagland akatsigira zvakasimba zvaakadana "chishuwo" che "musoro waOsama bin Laden pakiki," iyo yaakati ndiyo yaive chinangwa che "vakuru vemauto nemumiriri."
Hameno kuti Hoagland akaiwanepi chimedu cheropa.
Panguva imwecheteyo, kune njodzi mukugovana ruzivo rwakawandisa nechipfuwo mukati / kunze. Mutsamba yake yakavhurika kuna Bush, Hoagland akasimudza keteni pachirongwa chaicho, cheropa chemitambo yemwedzi iri kuuya nekupa Bush kurongeka kwekutanga kwezvakakosha. Iko kudiwa kwekutarisana nekuenderera mberi kweIraq kuunganidza zvoutachiona uye zvemakemikari zvombo uye tekinoroji yekuvaka bhomba renyukireya haigone kudzikisirwa nezvakadairwa nemushandirapamwe weAfghan. Iwe unofanirwa kuitisa mushandirapamwe uyu kuti iwe ugone kukasira kubva kwairi kupedza kutyisidzira kwaSaddam Hussein kwehutongi. Neimwe nzira, Hoagland yakanga yawana iyo "pivot" pfungwa mavhiki matatu pamberi peMunyori weDziviriro Donald Rumsfeld akafonera Gen. Tommy Franks kuti amuudze kuti Mutungamiri aida kuti achinje kutarisana neIraq. VaFranks nevabatsiri vake vakuru vanga vachishanda pakuronga kurwisa Tora Bora uko bin Laden vaitendwa vachihwanda asi kutarisisa, kuronga, uye zviwanikwa zvakangoerekana zvaendeswa kuIraq. Saka Osama bin Laden sezviri pachena akabuda muTora Bora achipfuura nemumakomo anopinda muPakistan.
Iyo poindi apa ndeyekuti njere dzinodiwa mune vezvenhau dzakanyatso kutaurwa neveCIA vanoparadzira - zvimwe nekuti ivo vanongwarira kuti vasarume maoko anovadyisa nekushoropodza CIA. Iwo mapundits ane kero kero yepamusoro-inorema nemazita evashandisi veCIA - ivo vakaudza avo Washington Post vakasimba muvhiki rino kuti denga richadonha kana Biden akaunza mauto kubva kuAfghanistan. Tarisa pasi pa "P" mumabhuku iwayo ekero; Handifunge kuti uchawana "Paul Mbiru".
Kune vamwe here vangatarisira nemufaro mamwe "zvachose hondo" muAfghanistan? Zvakanaka, zvakadii naJeff Bezos, uyo akatenga iyo Washington Post makore masere apfuura, achiri kuzvidzora, uye ane zvibvumirano zvakakura neCIA. Ndinovenga kurira kusanzwisisika, asi pasi pezvese izvi pane iyo MICIMATT (Yemauto-Industrial-DRM-Ungwaru-Midhiya-Academia-Funga-Tangi yakaoma. [Kusimbisa kunowedzerwa.]
Ray McGovern anoshanda naTiudze Shoko, ruoko rwekuburitsa rweChechi yemachechi yeMuponesi iri mukati meguta Washington. Basa rake ramakore makumi maviri neshanu semuongorori weCIA rinosanganisira kushanda saMambo weSoviet Kunze kwenyika Policy Bazi uye gadziriro / mupfupi weMutungamiri wezuva nezuva Brief. Iye ndiye mubatanidzwa-weVeteran Intelligence Vashandi veSanity (VIPS).
