Vanodiwa Ukraine-Had-No-Sarudzo Shamwari

NaDavid Swanson, World BEYOND War, May 25, 2023

Nezuro ndakaburitsa Vanodiwa Russia-Vasina-Sarudzo Shamwari, kuedza kugadzirisa zvandinoona sepfungwa isina kururama yokuti hurumende yeRussia yakanga isina imwe sarudzo kunze kwekupinda muUkraine.

Ehe, zvakangokanganisawo kuti Ukraine yakanga isina sarudzo kunze kwekurwa iyi hondo. Ndinoti "chokwadi" chete nekuti ini nevamwe vazhinji tave tiri kudzokorora isu ad nauseum kwerinopfuura gore, kwete nokuti munobvumirana. Uye ini ndinoshambadza izvi kwete kuti ndione kana zvichiburitsa kushoropodzwa kwakawanda kana kushoma uye kubviswa kwemaemail kunyoreswa uye zvipo kubva kuvanhu vanosaina zvinyorwa zvavo zvakashata "Ex-Shamwari" pane zvakaitwa nezuro. Kana ini handizvishambadzire pasi pekunyengera kuti ichayambuka zvakakwana-kudzokorora-chipingamupinyi uye kunyengetedza munhu wese. Asi, itarisiro yangu kuti ingangoita nhamba shoma yevanhu ichapa pfungwa yekupikisa hondo yese pfungwa yakawedzera kana vakaona mbiri yezvinyorwa zvinopikisa mativi ese ezvazvino zve-kana-kupokana, izvo-divi-ari. -iwe-iwe, teerera-kana-muvengi-anokunda kupenga.

Asi chii muzita remureza mutsvene wehondo Ukraine ingangove yakaita?

Sezvo nemubvunzo mumwechete pamusoro peRussia, mubvunzo uyu unofungidzirwa kuva une simba zvokuti hapana mhinduro inofanira kutomboedzwa.

Sezvakaita rutivi rwuri rwose rwehondo dzose, kuvapo kwenhau yose yomunhu pamberi pokumwe kubhomba kunofanira kubviswa mukufunga. Isu tinofanirwa kudzoka kumashure mumashini edu enguva yemashiripiti kuti titarise izvo Ukraine ingangogona - ndinoreva, nekuda kwegodsake, zvichida - takaita mabhomba achidonha, asi kwete kunanga muchina wedu wezuva kana vhiki kana makore gumi apfuura, sezvo zvaizopusa.

Sezvo ini ndichifunga uku kudzikisira kwemubvunzo kuve kwakarasika zvine njodzi, ini ndichasarudza kupindura izvo Ukraine yaigona kunge yakaita mukutungamira kune iyo nguva uye panguva iyoyo.

Kutanga, tinofanira kuyeuka kuti US uye zvimwe madokero vamiriri, vasori, uye theorists akafanotaura kwemakore makumi matatu kuti kutyora chivimbiso uye kuwedzera NATO kwaizotungamira kuhondo neRussia, uye kuti Mutungamiriri Barack Obama vakaramba kurwa neUkraine, vachifanotaura kuti kuita izvi kunotungamira kwatave ikozvino - saObama. achiri kuzviona muna Kubvumbi 2022. “Hondo Isina Kudenhwa” isati yatanga, pane zvakataurwa neveruzhinji nevakuru vakuru veUnited States vachipokana kuti kudenhwa kwacho kwaisazomutsa chero chinhu. ("Ini handitengi nharo iyi kuti, munoziva, isu kupa vanhu vekuUkraine zvombo zvekudzivirira kuchatsamwisa Putin," akadaro Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) Mumwe anogona kuverenga RAND ripoti Kukurudzira kugadzira hondo yakaita seiyi kuburikidza nemhando dzekutsamwisa dzainzi nemaseneta hapana chaizomutsa.

Ukraine ingadai yakangozvipira kusajoinha NATO. Izvi zvinogona kunge zvisiri nyore. Zelensky angangodaro aifanira kuchengeta zvivimbiso zvemushandirapamwe pane kutsvoda kune mamwe maNazi. Pfungwa ndeyokuti kana tikatora Ukraine yose uye kubvunza kana yaigona kuita chero chinhu, mhinduro iri pachena hongu.

IU.S. facilitated a kubvuta masimba muUkraine muna 2014. Hondo yakatanga makore prio kuti Kukadzi 2022. US ine kubvaruka zvibvumirano neRussia. IUS akaisa missile base kuEastern Europe. IUS rinoramba zvombo zvenyukireya munyika nhanhatu dzeEurope. Kennedy vakatora zvombo zvinokandwa kubva kuTurkey kugadzirisa dambudziko rakafanana pane kuriwedzera. Arkhipov akaramba kushandisa nukes kana isu tingave tisiri pano. IUS ingadai yakazvibata zvakasiyana muEastern Europe mumakore achangopfuura. Ukraine ingadai isina kutora chikamu mairi, ingadai yakaramba kushandiswa kwehurumende yayo uye yakazvipira kusarerekera.

Zvinonzwisisika chibvumirano yakasvika kuMinsk muna 2015. Ukraine ingadai yakateerera nayo. Iye zvino mutungamiri weUkraine akasarudzwa muna 2019 achivimbisa nhaurirano dzerunyararo. Angadai akachengeta vimbiso iyoyo, kunyangwe iyo US (nemapoka ekurudyi muUkraine) kusundira shure pamusoro pazvo. yeRussia inoda isati yapinda muUkraine zvaive zvine musoro, uye chibvumirano chiri nani kubva pamaonero eUkraine pane chero chinhu chakakurukurwa kubva ipapo. Ukraine ingadai yakataurirana ipapo.

IUS nevatsigiri vayo veNATO vanga vachidzivirira kupera kwehondo, kwete nekupa zvombo zvedivi rayo, asi nekuvharisa nhaurirano. Handisi kureva chete kupunzika panhengo dzeCongress dzinoshinga kutaura izwi rekuti "taurirana." Handirevi kungoburitsa chamupupuri chemashoko ekunyepa vachiti rimwe divi mamonya asingagoni kutaura nawo, kunyangwe achitaurirana navo nezvekuchinjana kwevasungwa uye kutengesa zviyo kunze kwenyika. Uye handireve kungohwanda kuseri kweUkraine, kudai kuti iUkraine isingade kutaurirana uye kuti saka US, semuranda akatendeka kuUkraine, inofanirwa kuenderera mberi ichiwedzera njodzi yenyukireya apocalypse. Ndinoreva zvakare kuvharwa kwekugona kumiswa kwehondo uye negotiated settlements. Medea Benjamin naNicolas JS Davies akanyora munaGunyana:

"Kune avo vanoti nhaurirano hazvigoneke, isu tinofanira kungotarisa hurukuro dzakaitika mumwedzi wekutanga mushure mekurwisa kweRussia, apo Russia neUkraine zvakabvumirana kuti chibvumirano chiitwe. chirongwa cherunyararo chegumi neshanu muhurukuro dzakarevererwa neTurkey. Zvakanga zvichiri kufanirwa kugadziriswa, asi hurongwa uye chido chezvematongerwo enyika zvaivepo. Russia yakanga yakagadzirira kubuda muUkraine yese, kunze kweCrimea uye marepublic anozvizivisa muDonbas. Ukraine yakanga yakagadzirira kuramba nhengo yeramangwana muNATO uye kutora chinzvimbo chekusarerekera pakati peRussia neNATO. Hurongwa hwakabvumiranwa hwakapa shanduko yezvematongerwo enyika muCrimea neDonbas kuti mativi ese ari maviri agamuchire nekuziva, zvichibva mukuzvisarudzira kwevanhu vematunhu iwayo. Kuchengetedzeka kweramangwana kweUkraine kwaifanira kuvimbiswa neboka redzimwe nyika, asi Ukraine yaisazogamuchira zvigaro zvemauto ekunze munharaunda yayo.

"Musi waKurume 27, Mutungamiri Zelenskyy akaudza nyika Vateereri veTV, 'Chinangwa chedu chiri pachena—rugare uye kudzorerwa kwoupenyu hwenguva dzose munyika yedu yatakaberekerwa nokukurumidza sezvinobvira.' Akaisa 'mitsetse mitsvuku' yenhaurirano paTV kuti avimbise vanhu vake kuti aisazobvuma zvakawanda, uye akavavimbisa referendamu yechibvumirano chekusatora rutivi chisati chatanga kushanda. . . . Zvitubu zveUkraine neTurkey zvakaratidza kuti hurumende dzeUK neUS dzakatamba nhanho mukupeta tarisiro dzekutanga dzerunyararo. Munguva yeMutungamiriri weUK Boris Johnson 'kushanya kwekushamisika' kuKyiv musi waKubvumbi 9, anonzi akaudza Mutungamiri Zelenskyy kuti UK yaive 'mairi kwenguva refu,' kuti yaisazove muchibvumirano pakati peRussia neUkraine, uye kuti 'yakabatana West' yakaona mukana 'wekudzvanya' Russia uye yakatsunga kuita. zvizhinji zvacho. Mharidzo imwecheteyo yakadzokororwa neMunyori weDziviriro weUS, Austin, uyo akatevera Johnson kuKyiv muna Kubvumbi 25 uye akajekesa kuti US neNATO dzakanga dzisisiri kuyedza kubatsira Ukraine kuzvidzivirira, asi vaive vazvipira kushandisa hondo kuti 'ipere simba'. Rashiya. Vamiriri veTurkey akaudza mumiriri weBritain akasiya basa, Craig Murray kuti mameseji aya kubva kuUS neUK akauraya kuyedza kwavo kumisa mhirizhonga uye kugadzirisa.

Rashiya anga achifunga nhaurirano. Nyika zhinji vanga vachifunga nhaurirano kwemwedzi, uye makumi emarudzi akaita chirevo ichocho kuUnited Nations. Chero nguva, Ukraine ingadai yakataurirana. Sezvo zvakanaka chaizvo munhu wese peace proposal ane zvakawanda zvakafanana nevamwe vese, tese tinoziva zvakanyanya kana zvishoma kuti chibvumirano chakaitwa. Mubvunzo ndewokuti ungasarudza here pamusoro pekufa kusingaperi nekuparadzwa.

Pfungwa yekuti kutaurirana runyararo kwaizongoburitsa manyepo kubva kune rimwe divi kuchiteverwa nehondo yakawanda iyo neimwe nzira ingave yakaipa kupfuura iyi hondo, ichokwadi pfungwa iri kutamba mupfungwa dzemativi ese. Asi pane zvikonzero zvekuti mativi ose ari maviri arambe. Kana nhaurirano ikabudirira, ichasanganisira matanho ekutanga anogona kutorwa pachena nedivi rega rega uye kusimbiswa nerimwe. Uye zvichatungamira kune kuvimbana kukuru uye kubatana. Nemamwe mashoko, “kurukurirano” harisi rimwewo shoko rinoreva “kugumisa kurwa.” Asi paizove pasina zvachose yakaderera kune yekukurumidza nhanho yekutanga yekumisa kurwa.

Ukraine yaigona kugara yakaisa mari mukugadzira zvirongwa zve kupikisa kukuru kusina pfuti kupinda nechisimba. Zvaigona kudaro.

Ukraine yaigona kugara yakabatana uye ichitsigira zvibvumirano zvepasi rose nezvekodzero dzevanhu uye kusabvisa zvombo. Zvaigona kudaro.

Ukraine yaigona kugara yakazvipira kusarerekera uye hushamwari nemativi ese, iyo US neRussia. Zvaigona kudaro.

Kwapera gore rapfuura Ndakacherekedza zvimwe zvinhu Ukraine yakanga ichiita uye yaigona kunge ichiita:

1. Shandura zvikwangwani zvemumugwagwa.
2. Vhara migwagwa nezvinhu.
3. Vhara migwagwa nevanhu.
4. Isa zvikwangwani.
5. Taura nemauto eRussia.
6. Pemberera varwiri verunyararo veRussia.
7. Kuratidzira kudziya kweRussia nekudziya kweUkraine.
8. Kumbira nhaurirano dzakakomba uye dzakazvimirira neRussia nehurumende yeUkraine - yakasununguka kubva kuUS neNATO inoraira, uye yakasununguka kubva kuUkraine-bapiro rekurudyi kutyisidzira.
9. Ratidza pachena kuti Hapana Russia, Hapana NATO, Hapana Hondo.
10. Shandisa mashoma e aya 198 mazano.
11. Nyora uye ratidza nyika kukanganisa kwehondo.
12. Nyora uye ratidza pasirese simba rekusapikisa kuramba.
13. Koka vatorwa vakashinga kuti vauye kuzobatana neuto rerunyararo risina pfuti.
14. Zivisa kuzvipira kusazomboenderana neuto neNATO, Russia, kana chero ani zvake.
15. Koka hurumende dzeSwitzerland, Austria, Finland, neIreland kumusangano wekusapindira mune zvematongerwo enyika muKyiv.
16. Zivisa kuzvipira kuchibvumirano cheMinsk 2 kusanganisira kuzvitonga kumatunhu maviri ekumabvazuva.
17. Zivisai chisungo chekupemberera kusiyana kwemarudzi nemitauro.
18. Zivisai kuferefetwa kwemhirizhonga yerudyi muUkraine.
19. Zivisa vamiriri vevaUkraine nenyaya dzinobaya mwoyo dzakafukidzwa nenhau kuti vashanyire Yemen, Afghanistan, Ethiopia, nedzimwe nyika gumi nembiri kuti vatarise kune vese vakawirwa nehondo.
20. Ita munhaurirano dzakakomba uye dzeruzhinji neRussia.
21. Zvipire kusachengeta zvombo kana mauto mukati me100, 200, 300, 400 km kubva kune chero miganhu, uye kumbira zvakafanana nevavakidzani.
22. Ronga neRussia mauto asina mhirizhonga anofamba achienda uye kuratidzira chero zvombo kana mauto ari pedyo nemiganhu.
23. Danidzira nyika kune vanozvipira kuti vabatane nekufamba uye kuratidzira.
24. Pemberera kusiyanisa kwenharaunda yepasi rose yevaratidziri uye kuronga zviitiko zvetsika sechikamu chekuratidzira.
25. Bvunza nyika dzeBaltic dzakaronga mhinduro dzisiri dzemhirizhonga kukurwisa kweRussia kubatsira kudzidzisa maUkraine, maRussia, uye vamwe vekuEurope zvakafanana.
26. Batanidza uye tsigira zvibvumirano zvikuru zvekodzero dzevanhu.
27. Join uye tsigira International Criminal Court.
28. Joinha uye tsigira Chibvumirano cheKurambidzwa kweNuclear Weapons.
29. Ipa kuitisa nhaurirano dzekubvisa zvombo nehurumende dzepasi rose dzine zvombo zvenyukireya.
30. Bvunza zvose Russia neWest kune rubatsiro rusiri rwemauto nekushandira pamwe.

Ukraine inogona kutsigira avo vadziviriri vasina zvombo vachida kubvumidzwa kuti vadzivirire maplants emagetsi enyukireya.

Ukraine inogona kuzivisa kubudirira - sezvanga ichiita kwerinopfuura gore, uye yosiya zvakadaro, ichitendeukira iko zvino kutafura yenhaurirano.

Asi Ukraine neRussia vese vachafanira kubvuma kukanganisa uye kubvumirana kana hondo ichizopera. Kunyange kana vachida kuramba vachivaraidzwa nokunyengera kwokusava nechavanopomerwa, vachatofanira kuita izvi. Vachafanirwa kubvumira vanhu veCrimea neDonbas kuti vazvisarudzire mafambiro avo. Uye ipapo Ukraine neNATO naRaytheon vaigona kuzivisa kukunda kwedemocracy neimwe hwaro chaiyo yekuita kudaro.