#2 The 2013 Gas Attack muGhouta, Syria
Argumentum ad Hitlerum

Propagandists uye vanoita zvemashiripiti vanotamba pane zvatisingazivi-zvatinotsanya kushingaira kusingafungi kufunga. Kuti tidzivirire izvi tinoda kuita zvakaoma kufunga kufunga kwekuyera umboo uye Chikonzero.

Tarisa vhidhiyo iri pasi apa yaJohn Kerry pamusangano muParis vachikumbira rubatsiro rwekurova bhoria kuSiria mukurwisa kweHNCX Ghouta Gasiuta-iwe unofungei, tiri kutungamirirwa mune zvinyorwa zvenhema?

Ndezvipi zvinowanikwa pakati pe2013 Paris uye 1938 Munich Conferences?

Ramba uchiyeuka kuti Hitler aishandura kunyengedza kwevanhu kusazvidza mitemo yenyika uye kurwisa nyika inotonga.

Muna 1938 Germany, Britain, France neItaly vakakokwa kuMunich Conference kuti vataure nezvekutonga kwaHitler kwekutambudzwa kweSudeten Germans muCzechoslovakia uye mhinduro yake; kuti iwedzere Sudetenland. Nyika mbiri idzi dzinoda kurwira uchangamire hweCzechoslovakia dzakanga dzisingabvumirwi, Czechoslovakia uye USSR.

Mu 2013 Siria, Iran neRussia zvakange zvisingabvumirwi kubva kumusangano weParis. Hitler akatanga hurukuro achiti:

"Germany haigoni kuramba isina hanya nehurombo uye urombo hwevaJudeten. Vanhu vanogara vachitambudzwa zvisina utsinye ... Iyi mamiriro akaoma inoda kusarudzwa mukati memazuva. "

Kutaura kwake kwakagamuchirwa nevose varipo. Chokwadi ndechekuti, kunyange zvazvo Sudetens asina kupiwa hurumende yakavimbiswa nehurumende yeCzech (nemhaka yezvokuchengetedza zvinodhaka) "kudzvinyirira" yaiva yekupindura kweCzech pakutsamwiswa nemagandanga ehurumende eSudeten aibhadhara mari uye akatsigirwa naHitler.

Saizvozvowo muSiriya the US, Turkey neGulf Monarchies vave vachitsigira rebel proxy forces kurwisana neHurumende yeSyria uye sezvakataurwa naKerry mumutauro, sangano reUnited States rakati vaigona "kutonga" mamiriro ezvinhu ne ISIS kuti aparadze Assad. (chinyorwa Kerry anowana mamwe mazita akavhengana asi anozvigadzirisa)

Ndeipi humwe uchapupu hwokuti Ghouta Attack zvakare yakanga isina kunyengera?

1. Kunyangwe pakutarisa mapepa ari pasi apa kubva kuBBC anoita seanofungidzirwa.

• Wemunhu akabatwa anofanirwa kuiswa munzvimbo yakatetepa (kushuvira kwemvura yemuviri kunowanzo kuuraya).
• Mvura yakachena yakachena yomuviri inoita seisingaitiki (ona maonero ekurapa pasi apa).
• "… Hapana (chemavhidhiyo) anoratidza vadzidzi vanonongedza… izvi zvinoratidza kusvibiswa neanophophophorus nerve vamiririri."
  -John Hart, mukuru weChimic and Biological Security Project kuColholm International Peace Research Inst.
• "Iyo mhutu inoita seyakachena kwazvo, yakachena, uye isingagumi nemhando yekukuvadzwa mukati mumungatarisira kuona, iyo yaungatarisira kuva bloodier kana kuti yellower." --Stephen Johnson, Cranfield University Forensic Institute
• "... vanhu vari kuvabatsira havana zvipfeko zvekudzivirira uye vasina mhepo inoputika, Mukati chaiye, vangangosvibiswa uye vangave vane zviratidzo." - VaPaula Vanninen, mutungamiriri weVerifin, Finnish Institute for Verification of the Chemical Weapons Convention
• Mimwe yemavhidhiyo muBhuku reBBC, Kuchengetedza Siria yevana, kuparidzira zuva rakapera Paramende rakasarudza kupindira muSiria sezvinoonekwa, pakuongorora, kushamisika.

Vana vanofungidzirwa kuti vari kurapwa pamakemikari anopisa vanoita sevari kuita kuti vadzivise kamera uye rubatsiro rwezvechiremba runoenda pakarepo kunobata chikwama chisingaverengeki kune vamwe vanoita sevari kuipa kwazvo. Kana iri kuita izvi hazvisi kukwira kuBBC mitemo.

2. Ona vhidhiyo pasi peCarla del Ponte, uyo aimbova muchengeti weInternational Tribunal Tribunal yekare yeYugoslavia (ICTY) uye International Criminal Tribunal yeRwanda (ICTR) uyewo gweta rezvemitemo uye mumiriri weSwitzerland:

3. Dai USA inofarira chaizvo kuti zvombo zvemakemikari zvakashandiswa kurwisana nevanhu. IAmerica yakashandisa uranium yakasviba nechena phosphorus uye apo Iraq yakanga iri kushandisa nerve yevarwi kurwisana neKurds (iri pasi) neIranani US yakatsigira Saddam Hussein uye yakapa mhosva Iranians nokuda kwekurwiswa. Uyewo cherechedza mararamiro eropa remvura inobva mumuromo nemhino.

4. A Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) yekudzidza (cherechedza kuti mumwe wevanyori ndiye aimbova mumiriri weUnited Weapons) akawana kuti mapurisa emagetsi aisagona kuuya kubva kune hurumende dzakachengetwa nzvimbo asi kubva kumapanduki akachengetwa. Pfungwa yavo yekupedzisira inoita seinoziva zvikuru nhasi.

5. Nyaya dzePulitzer Mutsva mutori wenhau munyori Seymour Hersh rinorondedzera kuti vakuru vakuru vakamuudza sei kuti vapanduki vacho vaivawo nemhepo ine utsi uye kuti:

"Kuchinja kwepfungwa dzaB Obama (kubva pakurwisa Siria) kwakabva kuPorton Down, laboratory laboratory muWiltshire. Chirongwa cheBritish chakanga chawana shanduro ye sarin yakashandiswa muChnumX August kushaniswa uye kuongororwa kwakaratidza kuti gasi raishandiswa harina kufanana nematche anozivikanwa kuti aripo muSyria mauto emakemikari arsenal. "

6. Mune hurukuro naB Obama kuAtlantic:

"James Clapper, mutungamiri wehurumende yenyika, uyo akavhiringidza Mutungamiri weNyika Brief, iyo mhirizhonga Obama inogamuchirwa mangwanani oga oga kubva kuVaClapper's analysts, kuti ijekese kuti huchenjeri hweSiria kushandisa sarin gas, panguva yakasimba, harina" slam dunk " . "

7. VaGhouta vakarwisa kwakaitika nguva pfupi mushure mekuongorora kwezvombo zveUN vakasvika kuDhamasiko. Assad akanga avabvunza kuti vauye kuzotsvaga kupandukira kwegasi kuhondo kune hurumende dzakachengetwa nzvimbo dzeDhamus. Zvinoratidzika kushamisa kuti Assad angangotadza kushandisa zvombo zvemakemikari ipapo, kunyanya kufunga nezve Obama "Red Line.

Ndiri kuona sei:

Chimiro chaKerry chokugadzira chaiva chokuti Assad naHitler vose vari vaviri vadzvinyiriri.
Tose tangove takanzwa pfungwa iyo kakawanda kune vamwe vatongi (vanopesana neUnited States).
Kuzivikanwa nemafungiro iwayo kunoita kuti zvinyatsojeka kugamuchira.

Asi kana tikafunga pamusoro payo zvakanyanya; zvinogona kuva iyo nzira inonyanya kukosha yekukumbira kuti ndiani ari kutyisidzira kusazvidza Mutemo Wenyika Yose uye kurwisa rudzi rwenyika unoshandisa kunyengera kwenhema?

“Kutanga hondo yechisimba, saka, haisi mhosva yepasi rose chete; imhosva huru pasi rose yakasiyana nedzimwe mhosva dzehondo chete nekuti mukati mayo mune uipi hwakazara uhwo. ” ~ Mutongi Robert Jackson, Miedzo yeNuremberg

Icho ichi chakarurama here? Unofungei?

Comments: