Mhinduro kuna: "Nyika Dzepasi Pose US Haikwanise Kudzivisa Kutarisana neChina neRussia"

Musi waChikunguru, 8, 2021 Balkin Insights yakaburitsa chinyorwa chakanyorwa naDavid L. Phillips chakanzi "A Global US Haikwanise Kudzivisa Kutarisana neRussia neChina" Musoro wenyaya: "Kanganwa kutaura nezve 'kumisazve' muhukama; iyo US iri munzira yekurovera pamwe nemhandu mbiri dzisingachinjike dzakatsunga kuyedza hutungamiriri hwayo uye kugadzirisa "

Icho chinyorwa chinogona kuwanikwa pa: https://balkaninsight.com/2021/07/08/a-global-us-cant-avoid-confronting-china-and-russia/

David L. Phillips ndiye Director, Chirongwa chekuvaka Runyararo uye Kodzero, muInstitute for the Study of Human Rights kuColumbia University. Ndiri kunetsekana nezvenyaya yechinyorwa chino, kunyanya ichibva kuchikoro chakazvipira kuvaka runyararo, ndakafunga kuti mhinduro yanga irimo. Pazasi pane mhinduro yangu kuchinyorwa chaVaPhillips. Mhinduro yakatumirwa muna Chikunguru 12, 2021 kuna David L. Phillips dp2366@columbia.edu

Anodiwa Mr. Phillips:

Yakanga iri nekuwedzera kunetsekana pandakaverenga chinyorwa chiri pamusoro chakanyorwa newe uye chakaburitswa muBalkinInsight, zvinonzi zvakamiririra nzvimbo pakati peColumbia University yakatsaurirwa ku "Runyararo Kuvaka uye Kodzero dzevanhu". Ndakakatyamadzwa kuona rhetoric yakawanda kwazvo ichitaura ichibva kunzvimbo yakatsaurirwa kuvaka rugare. Iwe unogona here kutsanangura chaizvo kuti iwe unofunga sei kuti US inofanirwa "kutarisana" neRussia neChina pasina kuisa njodzi kuhondo ingazotiparadza isu tese?

Panyaya yekusimudzira runyararo, sezvo iwe wakashanda mune akati wandei manejimendi, iwe unonyatso kuziva kuti iyo US ine zvivakwa zvese zvakagadzirirwa kukanganisa rugare uye "mhirizhonga" iyo yeNational Endowment yeDemocracy pamwe neRepublican neDemocratic Institutes. uye huwandu hwakazara hweNGOs uye vega vanozvipa donzvo rekukanganisa matunhu akanangwa neUS shanduko yehutongi. Kana iwe ukawedzera iwo ekuchengetedza masevhisi uye USAID, ingangove zvivakwa. Inzvimbo yako inotsigira here zvinokanganisa zviitiko zveiyi zvivakwa, zvinonzi nevamwe vanhu "simba rakapfava"? Panyaya yekodzero dzevanhu, ko iwe nzvimbo yako yaitei kurwisana nemaitiro akashandiswa panguva ye "Hondo yekutyisa" kusanganisira kupinda zvisiri pamutemo, kubhomba, kutamiswa kwevanhu, kuturika, kukwira mumvura, nedzimwe nzira dzekutambudza idzo dzakaburitswa pamusoro pemakore? Panzvimbo pekunongedzera chigunwe kune dzimwe nyika, nei isu tisingashande kugadzirisa yedu pachedu chikepe chehurumende?

Iwe zvakare unoita kunge usingazive zvachose nhoroondo yehukama hweRussia / Chinese uhwo hwave kazhinji huri hwehukasha nekukonana, zvirinani kusvika nguva pfupi yadarika apo mutemo weUS kuenda kuRussia wakamanikidza Russia kuita mubatanidzwa neChina. Panzvimbo pekuwongorora zvekare marongero akaguma nenjodzi dzakadai kune zvido zveUS, unoita kunge unofarira kutaura zvinhu zvinoita kunge zvisina chokwadi senge: "Russia isimba renyika riri kuderera." Rega ndikubvunze kuti uedze chirevo icho uchipesana nekucherechedza kushoma kubva pakuverenga kwangu uye kuenda kuRussia; 1) Russia zvizvarwa zviri kumberi mune tekinoroji yemasaini uye zvombo zvekudzivirira uye humwe hunyanzvi hwepamusoro wemauto matekinoroji nemitambo yakavakwa, yakadzidziswa zvemauto; 2) Rosatom yeRussia ikozvino inovaka huwandu hwenzvimbo dzenyukireya pasirese vachishandisa tekinoroji nyowani uye yakachengeteka, nepo makambani eUS asingaratidzi kuvaka imwe nyowani yazvino magetsi ekugadzira magetsi; 3) Russia inovaka ndege dzayo dzese, kusanganisira nendege dzevapfuuri - Russia inovakawo ngarava dzayo dzega dzegungwa dzinosanganisira ngarava dzepasi pegungwa uye tekinoroji dzinokwanisa kufamba zviuru zvemakiromita pasi pemvura 4) Russian iri pamberi kumberi mukutonhora kwakanyanya kwemamiriro ekunze arctic tekinoroji inosanganisira zvivakwa uye zvinopwanya aizi. 5) Chikwereti cheRussia i18% yeGDP, vane bhajeti yakawandisa uye yakasarudzika hupfumi homwe - chikwereti cheUS chinowedzera nemabhirioni gore rega uye US inofanirwa kupurinda mari kubhadhara zvikwereti zvazvino; 6) Russia painopindira, sezvaakaita muSyria muna2015 pakukokwa nehurumende yeSyria, Russia yakakwanisa kushandura mafashama eiyo inoparadza zvisiri pamutemo hondo yakatsigirwa neUS. Enzanisa iyi rekodhi ne "kubudirira" kweUS inodziya kubvira WW2; 7) Russia yakazvimiririra pachayo mukudya, simba, zvigadzirwa zvevatengi, uye tekinoroji. Chii chingaitika kuUS kana ngarava dzemidziyo dzikamira kusvika? Ini ndaigona kuenderera asi heino pfungwa yangu: uchifunga nezvekushomeka kweruzivo rwazvino, pamwe iwe unofanirwa kuenda kuRussia nekuzvionera wega mamiriro ariko pane kuramba uchidzokorora zvisingaperi zvinopesana neRussia? Nei ndichikurudzira izvi? Nekuti chero munhu anonzwisisa nyaya dzinobatanidzwa anozoziva kuti zviri mukuchengetedzeka kwenyika kweUSA kushamwaridzana neRussia - tichifunga kuti izvi zvichiri kugona kupihwa hunhu hweUS mumakore makumi matatu apfuura.

Ehezve Russia kana China havadi kusangana neUS nekuti vese vanoziva 1) yakapihwa marongero azvino, kuenderera kwemauto eUS / NATO hakugadzirike mune zvematongerwo enyika nehupfumi; uye 2) iyo US yaisazokwanisa kutsigira hondo yakajairwa chero nguva yakareba saka nyika ichave panjodzi huru yekuUS kutendeukira kuzvombo zvenyukireya pane kubvuma kukundwa kwakajairika. Ichi ndicho chikonzero nei Russia neChina vari kubhadharira nguva yavo pane kuisa njodzi kuhondo yenyika yenyukireya. Kana US / NATO ikasarudza kuendesa zvombo zvenyukireya kuRussia, maRussia vaburitsa pachena kuti hondo inotevera haizorwi chete paivhu reRussia, saka sezvo mutemo weUS unosanganisira kutanga kushandisa zvombo zvenyukireya sekushandisa kwekutanga kunoguma ne yakazara yakazara yenyukireya hondo kusanganisira nekuparadzwa kweUS. Tichifunga chokwadi - ndinofanira kubvunza kuti urikuvaka sei runyararo nekodzero dzevanhu nekuenderera mberi nekutaura kwakadai uye kutsigira marongero akadaro?

Ini ndinogona kunyora chirevo chizere pane zvese zvisirizvo, zvisirizvo uye disinformation iri murondedzero yako - asi rega nditaure mazwi mashoma nezveUkraine neyaimbova USSR. Iwe unotomboziva here kuti mushure mekuparadzwa kweSoviet Union iyo Russian Federation nevanhu veRussia vakatendeukira kuUS uye vakativimba kuti tivabatsire kugadzira musika hupfumi? Kuti makumi masere muzana yevanhu veRussia vaive nemaonero akanaka eUSA? Kuti izvi zvakadzoserwa neanopfuura makumi manomwe muzana ezviuru zvevagari vekuUS vane maonero akanaka evaRussia vanhu? Uyu mukana unoshamisa izvi zvakapa kuisa parutivi chiuto, kusimudzira rugare, uye kuponesa nyika yedu? Chii chaitika? Tarisa uone kumusoro !! Russia yakapambwa-vanhu varombo. Essays akanyorwa achiti "Russia yapera." Asi, sekutaura kwandataura pamusoro, Russia haina kupera. Isu takatotyora vimbiso yekusawedzera NATO "imwe inch kumabvazuva". Panzvimbo iyoyo, mauto eUS akaenderera uye NATO yakawedzerwa kusvika pasuwo reRussia. Nyika dzinoganhurana neRussia, kusanganisira Georgia neUkraine, dzakarohwa nekuchinja kwemavara kusanganisira Maidan coup ya80. Zvino, nekuda kweUS / NATO mutemo, Ukraine inyika yakundikana. Zvichakadaro, vazhinji veRussia vagari vemuCrimea vakasarudza kuchengetedza runyararo, chengetedzo, uye kodzero dzevanhu, nekuvhota kujoina Russian Federation. Neichi chiito chekuzvichengetedza-wega vanhu veCrimea vakatemerwa. Russia haina kuita izvi. Hapana anonzwisisa izvozvi angapa Russia mhosva iyi. Sangano reUS / NATO rakaita izvi. Ko nzvimbo yakapihwa basa rekusimudzira runyararo nekodzero dzevanhu inotsigira here izvi?

Ini handikwanise kuziva zvinokurudzira zvechokwadi izvi zvinopesana neRussia - asi ndinogona kutaura pachena kuti zvinopesana zvachose nekuchengetedza kwenguva refu kweUSA. Tarisa tarisa-tarisa uye zvibvunze wega- nei uchive vavengi neRussia - kunyanya kurwisa China? Mubvunzo iwoyo unogona kumutswa nezveIran-nezveVenezuela-nezveSyria-kunyangwe nezveChina chaicho. Chii chakaitika kune kudyidzana? Ndinoziva kuti pane kirabhu inomhanya neUSA, uye kuti uwane mabasa, mari, uye rubatsiro unofanira kuva chikamu cheichi "kirabhu" uye icho chinosanganisira kujoina nyaya yakakomba yeboka kufunga. Asi ko kana iyo kirabhu yaenda kubva kunjanji uye ikozvino iri kuita zvinokuvadza zvakanyanya kupfuura zvakanaka? Ko kana iyo kirabhu iri padivi risiri renhoroondo? Ko kana ichi kirabhu chiri kutyisidzira iro ramangwana chairo reUSA? Remangwana rebudiriro pacharo? Ini ndinotya kuti kana vanhu vakaringana muUS, semi, musafungisisa nezvenyaya idzi ramangwana redu riri munjodzi.

Ndinoona kuedza uku kuchizowira munzeve-asi ndakafunga kuti zvainge zvakakodzera kupfurwa.

Shuwiro yakanakisa

Sylvia Demarest