Okondedwa a Russia-Analibe Chosankha

Ndi David Swanson, World BEYOND War, May 24, 2023

Nayi "syllogism" yoyipa yochokera kwa munthu wodabwitsa, a Ray McGovern, wogwira ntchito kwa nthawi yayitali ku CIA, ndiye wolimbikitsa mtendere kwanthawi yayitali, ndipo tsopano wotsutsa wazaka zonse kuti Russia idasowa chochita koma kuukira Ukraine.

"Anthu aku Russia anali ndi njira zina zowukira Ukraine.
Anaukira Ukraine mu 'nkhondo yosankha'; kuopsezanso NATO.
Chifukwa chake, Kumadzulo kuyenera kulimbikitsa Ukraine, ndikuyika pachiwopsezo chankhondo. ”

Uku ndi kufotokozera kwa malingaliro a ife okhulupirira kuti Russia inali ndi chisankho china osati kuwukira Ukraine. M’chenicheni, likusonyeza mtunda womvetsa chisoni ndi waukulu kwambiri pakati pa maganizo a anthu amene poyamba ankavomereza kuti nkhondo inali yachisembwere, koma amene tsopano atha kwa chaka chathunthu akulephera konse kunyengererana pa chirichonse.

Zachidziwikire mawu omwe ali pamwambawa si syllogism konse. Ichi ndi syllogism:

Kuopseza nkhondo kumafuna nkhondo.
Russia ikuwopsezedwa ndi nkhondo.
Russia ikufuna nkhondo.

(Kapena lembani zomwezo m'malo mwa Ukraine ku Russia.)

Koma ndi izi:

Kuopseza nkhondo sikufuna nkhondo.
Russia ikuwopsezedwa ndi nkhondo.
Russia safuna nkhondo.

(Kapena lembani zomwezo m'malo mwa Ukraine ku Russia.)

Kusagwirizana kuli pachinthu chachikulu. The sylogism kwenikweni si chida chothandiza kwambiri poganiza; kungoganiza zachikale chabe. Dziko lapansi ndizovuta, ndipo wina atha kupanganso mlandu kwa uyu: "Kuwopseza nkhondo nthawi zina kumafuna nkhondo, kutengera." (Iwo akana kulakwitsa.)

Kuti chiwopsezo kapena nkhondo, ndipo ngakhale nkhondo yeniyeni, nthawi zambiri sinafune nkhondo poyankha koma yagonjetsedwa ndi njira zina ndi nkhani yolembedwa. Ndiye funso ndilakuti ngati nthawiyi inali yosiyana ndi nthawi zonsezo.

Pano pali kusagwirizana kwina. Ndi iti mwa izi yomwe ili yowona?

"Kutsutsa mbali imodzi ya nkhondo kumafuna kuteteza mbali inayo."

or

"Kutsutsana ndi mbali imodzi ya nkhondo kungakhale mbali imodzi yotsutsana ndi mbali zonse za nkhondo zonse."

Ili ndi funso loona, nalonso, nkhani yolembedwa. Ife omwe takhala miyezi yambiri tikutsutsa nkhondo zonse za mbali zonse za nkhondo ku Ukraine titha kuwonetsa mbali zonse zomwe tapeza zotsutsa mbali yawo ndi mbali inayo - ndi umboni wonse kuti onse akulakwitsa.

Koma mwina zilibe kanthu ngati wina akuganiza kuti ndikusangalala ndi NATO komanso mobisa pamalipiro a Lockheed Martin. Amangofuna yankho la funso lodabwitsa la "slam-dunk drop-the-mic win-the-whole-internet" la "Chabwino ndiye kuti Russia ikadachita chiyani?"

Ndisanafotokoze zomwe Russia ikanachita, panthawi yamavuto akulu komanso m'miyezi yapitayi ndi zaka ndi zaka makumi angapo, ndikofunikira kukumbanso Agiriki akale:

Russia idayenera kuteteza motsutsana ndi NATO.
Kuwukira ku Ukraine kunatsimikiziridwa kuti kumathandizira kwambiri NATO yomwe idawona m'moyo wonse.
Chifukwa chake Russia idayenera kuukira Ukraine.

Mwina syllogism ingakhale yothandiza pambuyo pa zonse? Mfundo ziwirizi ndi zoona. Kodi alipo amene angawone zopusazo? Zikuoneka kuti ayi, osachepera osati m'chaka choyamba ndi kotala. A US adayika msampha ndipo Russia idasowa chochita koma kutenga nyambo? Zoona? Ndichipongwe chotani nanga kwa Russia!

Chaka chapitacho ndinalemba nkhani yotchedwa “Zinthu 30 Zopanda Zachiwawa zomwe Russia Akadachita Ndi Zinthu 30 Zopanda Zachiwawa zomwe Ukraine Ikanachita.” Nawu mndandanda waku Russia:

Russia ikhoza kukhala ndi:

1. Kupitilira kunyoza zolosera zatsiku ndi tsiku za kuwukira ndikupangitsa chisangalalo chapadziko lonse lapansi, m'malo mowukira ndikupangitsa kulosera kwamasiku ochepa.
2. Anapitirizabe kusamutsa anthu a Kum’mawa kwa Ukraine amene ankaona kuti akuopsezedwa ndi boma la Ukraine, asilikali, ndiponso achiwembu a Nazi.
3. Anapereka othawa kwawo kuposa $29 kuti apulumuke; anawapatsadi nyumba, ntchito, ndi ndalama zotsimikizirika. (Kumbukirani, tikukamba za njira zina zankhondo, kotero kuti ndalama sizinthu ndipo palibe ndalama zowonongeka zomwe zingakhalepo kuposa kutsika kwa chidebe cha nkhondo.)
4. Adapempha voti ku UN Security Council kuti ikhazikitse demokalase ndi kuthetsa veto.
5. Anapempha UN kuti iyang'anire voti yatsopano ku Crimea ngati angalowenso ku Russia.
6. Analowa ku International Criminal Court.
7. Anapempha ICC kuti ifufuze zaumbanda ku Donbas.
8. Anatumizidwa ku Donbas zikwi zambiri za oteteza anthu wamba opanda zida.
9. Adatumiza ku Donbas ophunzitsa bwino kwambiri padziko lonse lapansi polimbana ndi ziwawa zopanda chiwawa.
10. Maphunziro operekedwa ndi ndalama padziko lonse lapansi pakufunika kwa kusiyana kwa chikhalidwe mu maubwenzi ndi madera, komanso kulephera kwakukulu kwa tsankho, utundu, ndi Nazism.
11. Anachotsa mamembala ambiri a fascist kunkhondo yaku Russia.
12. Kuperekedwa ngati mphatso kwa Ukraine dziko kutsogolera dzuwa, mphepo, ndi madzi mphamvu kupanga zipangizo.
13. Anatseka paipi ya gasi kupyola mu Ukraine ndi kudzipereka kuti asadzamangeponso kumpoto kwa kumeneko.
14. Adalengeza kudzipereka kusiya mafuta aku Russia pansi chifukwa cha Dziko Lapansi.
15. Kuperekedwa ngati mphatso ku Ukraine zomangamanga zamagetsi.
16. Kuperekedwa ngati mphatso yaubwenzi ku Ukraine njanji zomangamanga.
17. Adalengeza kuthandizira pazokambirana zapagulu zomwe Woodrow Wilson adanamizira kuti amathandizira.
18. Adalengezanso zofuna zisanu ndi zitatu zomwe zidayamba kupanga mu Disembala, ndipo adapempha mayankho agulu lililonse kuchokera ku boma la US.
19. Adafunsa anthu aku Russia aku America kuti akondwerere ubwenzi waku Russia ndi America pachipilala chogwetsa misozi chomwe chidaperekedwa ku United States ndi Russia kuchokera ku New York Harbor.
20. Analowa nawo mapangano akuluakulu a ufulu wachibadwidwe omwe sanavomerezedwe, ndipo adapempha kuti ena achite zomwezo.
21. Adalengeza kudzipereka kwake pakutsata mgwirizano wosagwirizana ndi zida zomwe United States idathetsa, ndikulimbikitsa kubwezerana.
22. Analengeza za ndondomeko ya nyukiliya yosagwiritsa ntchito koyamba, ndikulimbikitsanso zomwezo.
23. Adalengeza za mfundo zochotsa zida za nyukiliya ndikuzisunga kuti zisakhale tcheru kuti zilole kupitilira mphindi zochepa kuti ayambitse apocalypse, ndikulimbikitsanso chimodzimodzi.
24. Anati aletse kugulitsa zida padziko lonse lapansi.
25. Zokambirana zomwe zaperekedwa ndi maboma onse okhala ndi zida za nyukiliya, kuphatikiza omwe ali ndi zida zanyukiliya zaku US m'maiko awo, kuti achepetse ndi kuthetsa zida zanyukiliya.
26. Adadzipereka kuti asasunge zida kapena asitikali mkati mwa 100, 200, 300, 400 km kuchokera kumalire aliwonse, ndipo adapempha zomwezo kwa anansi ake.
27. Anakonza gulu lankhondo lopanda zida zankhondo kuti liyende ndikutsutsa zida zilizonse kapena asitikali omwe ali pafupi ndi malire.
28. Itanani kudziko lonse kuti anthu odzipereka alowe nawo ndikuchita ziwonetsero.
29. Adakondwerera kusiyanasiyana kwa omenyera ufulu wapadziko lonse lapansi ndikukonza zochitika zachikhalidwe monga gawo la ziwonetserozo.
30. Adafunsa mayiko a Baltic omwe adakonza zoyankha zopanda chiwawa pakuwukira kwa Russia kuti athandizire kuphunzitsa anthu aku Russia ndi Azungu ena chimodzimodzi.

Ndinakambirana izi wailesiyi.

Ndikutsimikiza kuti zapita pachabe, koma chonde yesetsani kukumbukira kuti izi zinalidi munkhani za zimene mbali iliyonse ingachite m’malo mochita misala yopha anthu ambiri, kuika pachiswe nyukiliya, kuchititsa njala padziko lonse, kulepheretsa mgwirizano wa nyengo, ndi kuwononga dziko. Chonde yesetsani kukumbukira kuti tonse takhala tikuzindikira mopweteka nkhanza zonse za US ku Russia. Chifukwa chake, yankho la "Ndingayerekeze bwanji kuti Russia izichita bwino kuposa boma loyipa kwambiri padziko lonse lapansi lomwe ndimakhala, United States?" ndi nthawi zonse: Ndimathera nthawi yanga yambiri ndikufuna kuti United States izichita bwino, koma ngati dziko lonse lapansi lingapeze kuti likuchita bwino kuti moyo Padziko Lapansi usungidwe ngakhale kuyesayesa kulikonse kwa Washington, ndine ndikhala othokoza chifukwa cha izi - ndipo sindidzakhumudwitsa.

Mwina omenyera mtendere aku Russia omwe amatsutsa molimba mtima kutenthetsa kwa dziko lawo, popeza tonsefe tiyenera kutsutsa zathu, ndi osokera kwambiri, koma sindikuganiza kuti ali.

Nanga n’cifukwa ciani n’zosatheka kuti timvetsetse kumene tikucokela, inu a Russia-Had-No-Choicers ndi ine? Mukukayikira kuti chovala chakale cha Ray chikundibweretsera ndalama kapena ndikuwopa kutchedwa "Putin Lover" - ngati kuti sindinakhalepo ndi ziwopsezo zambiri zakupha chifukwa chotsutsa nkhondo ya Iraq yomwe ndikadachita malonda. kugunda kwamtima kumangotchedwa "Iraq Lover."

Kukayikira kwanga pa inu kungakhale kopanda pake ngati kwanu kwa ine, koma sindikuganiza kuti kuli, ndipo ndikutanthauza mwaulemu wonse.

Ndikukayikira kuti mukuganiza kuti ngati mbali imodzi yankhondo ndi yolakwika, inayo mwina ndi yolondola - komanso yolondola mwatsatanetsatane. Ndikukayikira kuti mumatsutsa mbali ya US yankhondo ku Iraq koma osati mbali ya Iraq. Ndikukayikira kuti mumatsutsa mbali ya US yankhondo ku Ukraine, ndikuti mukuganiza kuti zimangotsatira kuti chilichonse chomwe mbali yaku Russia imachita ndichosangalatsa. Ndikuganiza kuti awirife tikubwerera kuzaka zakumenyana. Ndikanati ndikukuwa “Lekani nkhanza zopusazi, awirinu!” ndipo mumafunsa mwachangu kuti mudziwe kuti ndi chitsiru chiti chomwe chinali chabwino komanso choyipa. Kapena mungatero?

Ndikukayikira kuti simukufuna kuganizira zaka zomwe mbali ziwirizi zidakhala zikulephera kukonzekera chitetezo chopanda zida, ndipo mukuganiza kuti ziribe kanthu zomwe Russia idachita pofuna kukopa makhalidwe abwino ndi chilungamo cha dziko lapansi, adalavulira ku Russia ndikugwira ma popcorn kuti awonere kutukuka kwa US / NATO. Komabe, ngakhale dziko la Russia likuchita zankhanza zopha anthu, taonabe zambiri zapadziko lapansi - komanso maboma ambiri padziko lapansi! - kukana kukhala kumbali ya NATO, ngakhale kukakamizidwa kwakukulu, komanso ngakhale manyazi owopsa akuwoneka kuti akuteteza, kapena kuimbidwa mlandu woteteza, kutentha kwa Russia. Sitidzadziwa momwe dziko likanayankhira ngati dziko la Russia lidagwiritsa ntchito zida zazikulu komanso zopanda chiwawa, dziko la Russia likanakhala kuti lidalowa m'mabungwe azamalamulo padziko lonse lapansi, dziko la Russia likanakhala kuti lidasaina mapangano a ufulu wachibadwidwe, dziko la Russia likadafuna kukhazikitsa demokalase padziko lonse lapansi, dziko la Russia likadapempha dziko lapansi. kukana ma imperialism aku US m'malo mwa dziko loyendetsedwa ndi dziko lonse lapansi.

Mwina boma la Russia silikufuna kugwa pansi pa malamulo monga momwe boma la US limachitira. Mwina likufuna kulinganiza mphamvu, osati chilungamo. Kapena mwina akuganiza ngati anthu ambiri aku Western - ngakhale ambiri omwe akhala akuchita zolimbikitsa mtendere kwa zaka zambiri - kuti nkhondo ndiyo yankho lokha pamapeto pake. Ndipo mwina kuchita zinthu zopanda chiwawa zikanalephera. Koma pali zofooka ziwiri m'malingaliro amenewo zomwe ndikuganiza kuti ndizosatsutsika.

Chimodzi ndichoti tsopano tili pafupi kwambiri ndi apocalypse ya nyukiliya, ndipo tikapita sitingatsutse kuti ndani anali wolondola kuposa yemwe.

Zina ndikuti kumanga kwa US / NATO kunali kwazaka zambiri ndi miyezi. Russia ikanatha kuyembekezera tsiku lina kapena 10 kapena 200, ndipo panthawiyo ikanayamba kuyesa china chake. Palibe amene adasankha nthawi yomwe Russia ikukwera kupatula Russia. Ndipo mukasankha nthawi ya chinthu, mumasankha kuyesa chinthu china kaye.

Chofunikira kwambiri, pokhapokha ngati mbali zonse zivomereza zolakwika ndikuvomereza kulolerana, nkhondo siitha ndipo moyo padziko lapansi ukhoza. Zingakhale zamanyazi kwambiri ngati sitingagwirizane pa nkhani imeneyi.