Mkparịta ụka a na-enwe ugbu a banyere iwepụ atụmatụ nke ndị agha US na NATO site na Afghanistan na nkwenkwe na-enweghị atụ na onye bụbu onye nyocha CIA-ibe m Paul Pillar kpughere afọ 12 gara aga. Paul kpọrọ ya "isi okwu nke ekwesighi ka Afghanistan kwere ka ọ ghọkwa ebe ọzọ maka ndị na-eyi ọha egwu, ọkachasị al-Qaeda".
na Ụbọchị Sọnde Washington Post “Igwe na-ada” ụdị ịdọ aka na ntị, Na NY Times'' Maureen Dowd na-ekwu Mba obughi ya, kedu ebe mmadu gha esi choro ezigbo uche?
Enweghị nsogbu: Naanị gụghachi Paul Pillar's Washington Post oputara na Septemba 16, nke puru idenye na Paul: Iyi ọha egwu maka mmadụ. Akwụkwọ akụkọ ahụ họọrọ isiokwu bụ: “Ezigbo ebe ndị na-eyi ọha egwu adịghị anọ, ọ dị n'ịntanetị. "
Ihe ndia bu ihe edere:
Olee otu ihe dị mkpa nye otu ndị na-eyi ọha egwu? … Ego ole ka ebe mgbaba na-emetụta ihe egwu nke mwakpo ndị na-eyi ọha egwu megide ọdịmma US, ọkachasị ala nna US? Azịza nye ajụjụ nke abụọ bụ: ọ fọrọ nke nta ka ọ bụrụ na echiche ndị ahụ akwadoghị. Preparations Nkwadebe ndị kachasị mkpa na Septemba 11, 2001, mwakpo emereghị na ogige ọzụzụ na Afghanistan mana, kama, na ụlọ ndị dị na Germany, ime ụlọ nkwari akụ na Spain na ụlọ akwụkwọ ụgbọ elu na United States. N'ime afọ iri gara aga, otu ndị na-eyi ọha egwu mba dị iche iche enweela ọganiihu site n'iji ijikọ ụwa ọnụ na teknụzụ ihe ọmụma eme ihe, nke belatara ndabere ha na ebe obibi.
Okwu a taa bụ ma igbochi ụdị ogige ahụ ga-ebelata ihe iyi egwu nke ndị na-eyi ọha egwu na United States zuru oke site na ihe ọ ga - abụ iji belata mmefu nke ọbara na akụ na ihe mgbochi ịga nke ọma na Afghanistan, gụnyere ọchịchị na-adịghị arụ ọrụ na ịda mba nkwado onu ogugu mmadu. Imebi oghere nke anụ ahụ ga-ewepụkwa mmụba ọ bụla na iyi ọha egwu na-emegide US na-esite n'echiche bụ na United States abụrụla onye ọrụ karịa onye na-agbachitere Afghanistan.
Ogidi vs. Ndi isi-dinta
Paul Pillar nwere ọkwá dị elu na CIA, gụnyere National Intelligence Officer maka Middle East - ọkwá kachasị elu na mpaghara ahụ - ma mara ezigbo mma banyere iyi ọha egwu, yana. Ọ ghọrọ onye isi nyocha na Counterterrorist Center na 1993 na osote onye isi nke Center afọ anọ ka e mesịrị. Mgbe onye isi ojii-master Cofer Black weghaara Center na 1997, agbanyeghị, Pillar hapụrụ - n'ihi "nsogbu nke ụdị", ka Steve Coll si kwuo Agha Ghost: Akụkọ Nzuzo nke CIA, Afghanistan na Bin Laden (Penguin, 2005).
O siri ike ịkọwa ihe kpatara ogidi na Black na-eche echiche ga-adị ka mmanụ na mmiri. Onye oru zuru oke, Black mechara bụrụ onye ikpeazụ na Board nke aha ọjọọ ike ike Ukraine Burisma. Ma nke ahụ bụ nanị nzọrọ ọ na-adịbeghị anya ọ na-azọrọ maka ama.
Bọ ọbọ bụ nke m, ka Black kwuru
Chee echiche maka ụbọchị ịbọ ọbọ ozugbo nke 9/11 gachara, yana ụzọ mbido nke Onye isi ala Bush gosipụtara wee mee ka ndị ọrụ CIA na ndị ọrụ ha nwere mmetụta na mgbasa ozi gbadaa - na Cofer Black na-ada ka njikọta nke Shakespeare's Herodias, Lady Macbeth, na Lewis Carroll Queen nke Obi.
Onye ọrụ CIA bụ Gary Schroen gwara National Public Radio na, ụbọchị ole na ole gachara 9/11, Coter Black onye isi Counterterrorist zigara ya Afghanistan na iwu "Wegide bin Laden, gbuo ya, ma weghachite isi ya na igbe dị na ice akọrọ." Banyere ndị isi al Qaeda ọzọ, Black kwuru, sị, "Achọrọ m isi ha n'elu pikes."
Quda a dị ụtọ - na asụsụ - tụgharịrị n'etiti ndị ọkachamara nwere ọgụgụ isi, na-achọkarị inye aka.
Nledo-Pundit Incestuous Ties
Otu onye nyocha, Washington Post Jim Hoagland nke ochie amala n'iyi na-ebipụta akwụkwọ ozi na-emeghe nye Onye isi ala Bush na Ọkt. 31, 2001. Ọ bụghị nkwanye ugwu Halloween. Kama nke ahụ, Hoagland kwadosiri ike ihe ọ kpọrọ “ọchịchọ” maka “isi Osama bin Laden n'ụgbọ mmiri,” nke o kwuru na ebumnobi nke ndị ọchịagha na ndị nnọchi anya Bush.
Na-eche ebe Hoagland nwetara obere achịcha ọbara a.
N'otu oge ahụ, enwere nsogbu dị na ịkekọrịta ọtụtụ ozi na ndị na-ahụ maka anụ ụlọ / ndị nọ n'èzí. N’akwụkwọ ozi mepere emepe nye Bush, Hoagland weliri ákwà mgbochi n’ezie, atụmatụ egwuregwu ọbara karịa maka ọnwa ndị na-abịanụ site n’inye Bush iwu ndị a dị mkpa. Mkpa ọ dị ịnagide nchịkọta Iraq na-aga n'ihu nke ngwa agha na ngwa agha yana teknụzụ iji wuo bọmbụ nuklia enweghị ike ibelata ihe ndị mgbasa ozi Afghanistan chọrọ. Ga-agharịrị mkpọsa ahụ ka ị nwee ike isi na ya pụọ na ngwa ngwa iji kwụsị iyi egwu ọchịchị Saddam Hussein na-eweta. N'ụzọ ụfọdụ, Hoagland enwetala echiche ahụ "izu" izu atọ tupu onye ode akwụkwọ nchekwa Donald Rumsfeld kpọrọ Gen. Tommy Franks ka ọ gwa ya na Onye isi ala chọrọ ka ọ gbanwee Iraq. Franks na ndị na-enyere ya aka na-arụ ọrụ na atụmatụ maka ọgụ na Tora Bora ebe ekwenyere na bin Laden na-ezobe mana nlebara anya, atụmatụ, na akụrụngwa tụgharịrị na Iraq na mberede. Yabụ Osama bin Laden pụtara na Tora Bora gafere ugwu ahụ wee banye Pakistan.
Isi okwu ebe a bụ na ọkacha mmasị ndị ọgụgụ isi na mgbasa ozi bụ ndị ndị na-agbasa ozi CIA na-akọwa nke ọma - n'otu aka n'ihi na ha na-akpachapụ anya ịghara ịtinye aka na-enye ha nri site n'ịkatọ CIA. Ndị pundits ndị ahụ nwere akwụkwọ adreesị kachasị elu na aha ndị ọrụ CIA ọrụ - ndị gwara ndị ahụ Washington Post stalwarts na ngwụsị izu a na mbara igwe ga-ada ma ọ bụrụ na Biden wetara ndị agha si Afghanistan. Lee n'okpuru “P” n’akwụkwọ adres ndị ahụ; Echeghị m na ị ga-ahụ “Paul Pillar”.
Enwere ndị ga-eji obi ụtọ na-ele anya maka "agha ebighi ebi" na Afghanistan? Lee, olee maka Jeff Bezos, onye zụtara ya Washington Post afọ asatọ gara aga, ka na-achịkwa ya, ma nwee nnukwu nkwekọrịta na CIA. Akpọrọ m ụda ụda, mana n'okpuru ihe ndị a niile bụ MICIMATT (Military-Industrial-Congressional-Ọgụgụ isi-Media-Academia-Chee-tank mgbagwoju. [Imesikwara ya ike.]
Ray McGovern na-agwa Okwu ahụ, ngalaba na-ebipụta akwụkwọ nke nzukọ ụka nke Onye Nzọpụta na obodo Washington. Ọrụ ya dị afọ 27 dị ka onye nyocha CIA gụnyere ije ozi dị ka Chief of the Soviet Foreign Policy Branch na onye na-akwadebe / briefer nke President's Daily Brief. Ọ bụ ngalaba-onye guzobere Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS).
