Russia, Israel thiab Media

Lub ntiaj teb yog, tsim nyog, txaus ntshai ntawm qhov tshwm sim hauv Ukraine. Russia tau pom meej tias ua txhaum kev ua tsov ua rog thiab kev ua phem rau tib neeg thaum nws foob pob chaw nyob, tsev kho mob thiab lwm qhov chaw uas nws cov dav hlau tau ntsib.

Cov headlines yog jarring:

"Russia foob pob tsib qhov chaw tsheb ciav hlau" (Tus Saib Xyuas).
"Russia foob pob Ukraine Steel Cog" (Txhua Hnub Sabah).
"Russia siv cov foob pob tawg" (Tus Saib Xyuas).
"Russia rov pib foob pob" (iNews).

Cov no tsuas yog qee qhov piv txwv xwb.

Cia peb saib tam sim no ntawm qee qhov xov xwm tseem ceeb:

"Israel Airstrikes Ntaus Gaza Tom Qab Hluav Taws Xob" (Wall Street Journal).
"Israel Airstrikes Target Gaza" (Sky News).
"IDF hais tias nws ntaus Hamas Riam phom Depot" (Lub Sijhawm ntawm Ixayees).
"Israel Tub Rog Launches Airstrikes" (New York Post).

Puas yog tus kws sau ntawv no xwb, lossis nws puas tshwm sim tias 'airstrikes' zoo li ntau yam zoo uas 'pob zeb'? Vim li cas ho tsis hais tias 'Israel Bombs Gaza' es tsis yog qab zib-txhim lub foob pob tuag ntawm cov txiv neej, poj niam thiab menyuam yaus? Puas muaj leej twg pom nws lees paub hais tias 'Lavxias Airstrikes tsoo Ukraine Steel Cog Tom Qab Ua Haujlwm'?

Peb nyob hauv lub ntiaj teb uas cov pej xeem tau hais rau leej twg thiab yuav tsum txhawj xeeb txog lawv tus kheej nrog dab tsi thiab, feem ntau hais lus, uas yog cov neeg dawb. Qee qhov piv txwv yog piav qhia:

• CBS xov xwm tus neeg sau xov xwm Charlie D'Agata: Ukraine "tsis yog qhov chaw, nrog rau kev hwm, zoo li Iraq lossis Afghanistan, uas tau pom kev tsis sib haum xeeb rau ntau xyoo lawm. Qhov no yog ib qho kev vam meej, kuj yog European - Kuv yuav tsum xaiv cov lus ua tib zoo, ib yam nkaus - lub nroog, ib qho uas koj yuav tsis xav txog qhov ntawd, lossis cia siab tias nws yuav tshwm sim ".^[1]
• Ib tug qub tub ceev xwm ntawm Ukraine, tau hais cov hauv qab no: "'Nws zoo siab rau kuv vim kuv pom cov neeg European nrog lub qhov muag xiav thiab cov plaub hau daj ... raug tua txhua hnub.' Tsis yog nug lossis tawm tsam cov lus, BBC tus tswv tsev teb ncaj nraim, 'Kuv nkag siab thiab hwm txoj kev xav.'”^[2]
• Ntawm Fabkis BFM TV, tus neeg sau xov xwm Phillipe Corbé tau hais txog qhov no hais txog Ukraine: "Peb tsis tau tham ntawm no txog Syrians khiav tawm ntawm kev foob pob ntawm Syrian tsoomfwv txhawb nqa los ntawm Putin. Peb tab tom tham txog cov neeg European tawm hauv lub tsheb uas zoo li peb los cawm lawv txoj sia. "^[3]
• Ib tug neeg tsis paub ITV tus neeg sau xov xwm uas yog ceeb toom los ntawm Poland tau hais raws li hauv qab no: “Tam sim no qhov kev xav tsis tau tshwm sim rau lawv. Thiab qhov no tsis yog ib qho kev txhim kho, lub ntiaj teb thib peb. Qhov no yog Europe!”^[4]
• Peter Dobbie, tus kws tshaj xov xwm los ntawm Al Jazeera tau hais li no: “Saib lawv, hnav khaub ncaws zoo li no, cov no muaj kev vam meej… Kuv tsis txaus siab siv cov lus qhia… cov neeg nruab nrab. Cov no tsis yog cov neeg tawg rog tab tom nrhiav kom tau deb ntawm thaj chaw hauv Middle East uas tseem nyob hauv lub xeev loj ntawm kev ua tsov ua rog. Cov no tsis yog cov neeg sim khiav tawm ntawm thaj chaw hauv North Africa. Lawv zoo li txhua tsev neeg nyob sab Europe uas koj yuav nyob ib sab ntawm qhov rooj. "^[5]
• Sau rau Telegraph, Daniel Hannan piav qhia: “Lawv zoo li peb. Qhov ntawd yog qhov ua rau nws poob siab heev. Ukraine yog ib lub tebchaws nyob sab Europe. Nws cov neeg saib Netflix thiab muaj Instagram account, pov npav dawb hauv kev xaiv tsa thiab nyeem cov ntawv xov xwm tsis raug kaw. Kev ua tsov ua rog tsis yog ib yam dab tsi uas tau mus ntsib cov neeg txom nyem thiab cov neeg nyob deb. "^[6]

Pom tau tias, cov foob pob raug muab tso rau ntawm cov neeg dawb, Christian Europeans, tab sis 'airstrikes' tau pib rau Middle-Eastern Muslims.

Ib qho ntawm cov khoom hais saum toj no, los ntawm iNews, tham txog kev foob pob ntawm Azovstal steelworks cog hauv Mariupol, qhov twg, raws li tsab xov xwm, ntau txhiab tus neeg nyob hauv Ukrainian tau nyob. Qhov no tau, muaj tseeb, ua rau muaj kev npau taws thoob ntiaj teb. Hauv xyoo 2014, Lub BBC tau tshaj tawm txog Israeli kev foob pob ntawm lub chaw kom pom tseeb ntawm United Nations cov neeg tawg rog. "Qhov kev tawm tsam ntawm lub tsev kawm ntawv hauv Jabaliya cov neeg tawg rog, uas tau nyob ntau dua 3,000 tus pej xeem, tau tshwm sim rau hnub Wednesday sawv ntxov (Lub Xya Hli 29, 2014).^[7] Qhov twg yog qhov kev tawm tsam thoob ntiaj teb thaum ntawd?

Thaum Lub Peb Hlis Ntuj xyoo 2019, United Nations tau rau txim rau qhov kev tawm tsam ntawm lub chaw tawg rog hauv Gaza uas tau tua tsawg kawg yog xya tus neeg, suav nrog tus ntxhais 4 xyoos. ^[8] Ntxiv dua thiab, vim li cas lub ntiaj teb tsis quav ntsej qhov no?

Thaum lub Tsib Hlis 2021, kaum tus tswv cuab ntawm ib tsev neeg, suav nrog ob tus poj niam thiab yim tus menyuam, raug tua los ntawm Israeli foob pob - huag! Thov txim kuv! Ib tug Israeli 'airstrike' - nyob rau hauv ib tug neeg tawg rog camp nyob rau hauv Gaza. Ib tug yuav tsum xav tias, txij li thaum lawv tsis saib Netflix thiab tsav 'tsheb uas zoo li peb', ib tug yuav tsum tsis txhob txhawj txog lawv. Thiab nws tsis zoo li tias ib qho ntawm lawv muaj lub qhov muag xiav thiab cov plaub hau daj uas tau qhuas los ntawm yav dhau los tus kws lij choj Ukrainian.

Tsoomfwv Meskas tau hu xovtooj rau kev tshawb nrhiav los ntawm International Criminal Court (ICC) rau hauv kev ua tsov rog ua txhaum cai los ntawm Russia tawm tsam cov neeg Ukrainian (me ntsis ironic, xav tias US tau tsis kam kos npe rau Rome Statute uas tsim lub ICC, tsis yog. xav kom US raug tshawb xyuas txog nws ntau yam ua tsov ua rog). Txawm li cas los xij, tsoomfwv Meskas tseem tau rau txim rau ICC kev tshawb nrhiav txog kev ua tsov rog ua txhaum cai los ntawm Israel tawm tsam cov neeg ntawm Palestine. Nco ntsoov, thov, hais tias US thiab Israel tsis tawm tsam cov kev foob rau cov neeg Ixayees, tsuas yog kev tshawb nrhiav cov nqi no xwb.

Nws tsis muaj qhov zais cia tias kev ntxub ntxaug tseem muaj sia nyob thiab zoo thiab vam meej hauv Tebchaws Meskas. Nws kuj tsis yog qhov xav tsis thoob tias nws rears nws lub taub hau dab tuag thoob ntiaj teb, raws li tau pom meej meej tshaj plaws los ntawm cov lus hais saum toj no.

Lwm lub tswv yim uas tsis xav tsis thoob yog US siab phem; tus kws sau ntawv no, nrog rau ntau tus neeg, tau tawm tswv yim rau nws ntau zaus ua ntej. Nco ntsoov tias thaum Asmeskas 'tus yeeb ncuab' (Russia) ua txhaum kev ua tsov ua rog tawm tsam cov neeg dawb, feem ntau yog cov ntseeg, cov tebchaws nyob sab Europe, Asmeskas yuav txhawb nqa cov neeg raug tsim txom ntawd nrog caj npab thiab nyiaj, thiab yuav pom zoo rau ICC kev tshawb nrhiav tag nrho. Tab sis thaum Asmeskas 'tus phooj ywg' (Israel) ua txhaum kev ua tsov ua rog tawm tsam cov Muslim feem ntau, Middle Eastern lub teb chaws, zoo, qhov ntawd yog ib zaj dab neeg sib txawv tag nrho. Tsis dawb huv Ixayees muaj cai tiv thaiv nws tus kheej, US cov tub ceev xwm yuav nug, disingenuously. Raws li Palestinian activist Hanan Ashrawi tau hais tias, "Cov Palestinians tsuas yog tib neeg hauv ntiaj teb xav tau los lav kev nyab xeeb ntawm tus neeg nyob, thaum Israel yog tib lub tebchaws uas xav tau kev tiv thaiv los ntawm nws cov neeg raug tsim txom." Nws yog qhov tsis zoo rau tus neeg ua txhaum cai 'tiv thaiv' nws tus kheej tawm tsam nws tus neeg raug tsim txom. Nws zoo li thuam ib tug poj niam uas sim tawm tsam nws tus neeg raug tsim txom.

Yog li ntawd lub ntiaj teb yuav tau hnov ​​​​txog kev ua phem hauv Ukraine, raws li nws yuav tsum tau ua. Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, xov xwm xov xwm feem ntau yuav tsis quav ntsej lossis qab zib-coj tib yam kev ua phem uas cov neeg Ixayees tau ua rau cov neeg Palestine.

Cov neeg hauv ntiaj teb no muaj ob lub luag haujlwm hauv cov ntsiab lus no:

1) Tsis txhob poob rau nws. Tsis txhob xav tias vim hais tias ib tug neeg raug tsim txom tsis 'zoo li ib tsev neeg nyob sab Europe uas koj yuav nyob ib sab ntawm lub qhov rooj', tias lawv tsis tshua tseem ceeb, lossis lawv qhov kev txom nyem tuaj yeem raug saib xyuas. Lawv raug kev txom nyem, tu siab, los ntshav, ntshai thiab ntshai, kev hlub thiab kev nyuaj siab, ib yam li peb txhua tus ua.

2) Xav tau zoo dua. Sau ntawv mus rau cov kws kho cov ntawv xov xwm, cov ntawv xov xwm thiab cov ntawv xov xwm, thiab rau cov thawj coj xaiv tsa. Nug lawv vim li cas lawv tsom rau ib tus neeg txom nyem, tsis yog lwm tus. Nyeem cov ntawv xov xwm ywj pheej uas tau tshaj tawm xov xwm, cov xwm txheej uas tshwm sim thoob ntiaj teb, yam tsis tau xaiv thiab xaiv yam lawv yuav tshaj tawm raws li haiv neeg thiab / lossis haiv neeg.

Nws tau hais tias yog cov neeg tsuas paub txog lub zog uas lawv muaj, yuav muaj kev hloov pauv loj hauv ntiaj teb. Siv koj lub zog; sau ntawv, pov ntawv tawm suab, taug kev, ua qauv qhia, tawm tsam, kev tawm tsam, thiab lwm yam kom thov kom muaj kev hloov pauv uas yuav tsum tshwm sim. Nws yog lub luag haujlwm ntawm peb txhua tus thiab txhua tus.

1. Bayoumi, Moustafa. “Lawv Yog 'Civilised' thiab 'Zoo li Peb': Kev ntxub ntxaug ntawm Ukraine | Moustafa Bayoumi | Tus Saib Xyuas." tus saib xyuas, Tus Saib Xyuas, 2 Lub Peb Hlis 2022, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/mar/02/civilised-european-look-like-us-racist-coverage-ukraine. ↑
2. Ib↑
3. Ib ↑
4. Ib ↑
5. Ritman, Alex. "Ukraine: CBS, Al Jazeera thuam rau kev ntxub ntxaug, Kev Tshaj Tawm Orientalist - The Hollywood Reporter." Lub Hollywood Reporter, The Hollywood Reporter, 28 Feb. 2022, https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-news/ukraine-war-reporting-racist-middle-east-1235100951/. ↑
6. Bayoom. ↑
7. https://www.calendar-365.com/2014-calendar.html ↑
8. https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-213680/ ↑