Cov tub hluas ntxhais hluas pom lawv tus kheej sai sai ntes tau nyob rau hauv kev txom nyem ntawm trench tsov rog nyob rau hauv no German-lus adaptation ntawm thawj lub ntiaj teb no tsov rog tshiab. Yees duab: Netflix
Los ntawm Peter Bradshaw, tus saib xyuas, Kaum Hlis 14, 2022
Enplua nuj Maria Remarque's anti-ua tsov ua rog classic tau txais nws thawj German-lus adaptation rau qhov screen, tom qab lub Hollywood versions ntawm 1930 thiab 1979; Nws yog ib zaj yeeb yaj kiab uas muaj zog, hais lus zoo, muaj kev ntseeg siab los ntawm tus thawj coj thiab tus kws sau ntawv Edward Berger. Tus tshiab Felix Kammerer ua si Paul, tus tub hluas German uas koom nrog nws cov phooj ywg hauv tsev kawm ntawv hauv kev npau taws ntawm kev ua siab ntev rau qhov kawg ntawm thawj lub ntiaj teb ua tsov ua rog, zoo siab tos ntsoov rau txoj kev yooj yim, swaggering mus rau Paris. Hloov chaw, nws pom nws tus kheej nyob rau hauv npau suav phem ntawm ntshav thiab chaos.
Rau ntau tiam neeg ntawm cov neeg nyeem ntawv Askiv, zaj dab neeg tau muab qhov sib xyaw ua ke rau qhov kev txom nyem zoo sib xws tom qab Allied kab, ib phau ntawv nyeem ua ke nrog, hais tias, Wilfred Owen cov paj huam. Nws yog qhov kev sib txuas lus, daim iav-duab sib xyaw ua ke uas nyob rau hauv qee txoj kev tau tsim qhov loj me ntawm absurdist insanity uas tom qab tawm tsam kev ua tsov ua rog xws li Catch-22 yuav tsim. Thawj lub npe German, Im Westen Nichts Neues ("Nyob rau sab hnub poob tsis muaj dab tsi tshiab"), brilliantly rendered li "tag nrho nyob ntsiag to rau sab hnub poob pem hauv ntej" nyob rau hauv 1929 los ntawm Australian neeg txhais lus Arthur Wheen, yog ib lo lus los ntawm ib tug tseeb tub rog daim ntawv qhia endowed nrog ib tug phem phem. irony. Sab hnub poob pem hauv ntej tsuas yog ntsiag to rau cov neeg tuag.
Young Paul yog zaj yeeb yaj kiab no Tus Tub Rog Paub, lub cim ntawm kev tsis ncaj ncees raug rhuav tshem, nws lub ntsej muag tshiab qhib rau hauv lub ntsej muag ntshav thiab av nkos ntawm kev ntshai heev. Nws yog marooned nyob rau hauv lub ordeal ntawm static trench ua tsov ua rog, tag nrho cov ntau wrenchingly futile raws li qhov no yog tshwm sim rau thaum xaus ntawm tsov rog, thiab cowed German cov neeg sawv cev tuaj txog kos npe rau lub capitulation nyob rau hauv Fabkis railway carriage ntawm Compiègne. Daniel Brühl ua si rau pej xeem nom tswv Magnus Erzberger uas yog tus thawj coj German delegation; Thibault de Montalembert muaj ib tug cameo li Marshal Foch, contemptuously tsis kam lees txais lub ntsej muag-saving concessions rau Germans. Zaj dab neeg yog kom ncav cuag qhov kawg ntawm xeev siab tom qab kos npe, thaum ib tus neeg German npau taws tshaj tawm rau nws cov tub rog uas qaug zog thiab raug mob tias lawv muaj sij hawm rau ib qho kev sib ntaus sib tua kawg los cawm lub meej mom ntawm leej txiv. ua ntej 11 teev, lub teev ntawm kev sib ntaus sib tua.
Paul cov comrades yog Müller (Moritz Klaus), Kropp (Aaron Hilmer), Tjaden (Edin Hasanović) thiab tseem ceeb tshaj plaws yog cov laus thiab cov tub rog kws tshaj lij Katczinsky, lossis "Kat" - qhov ua tau zoo heev los ntawm Albrecht Schuch. Kat yog los ua tus tub hluas tus tij laug daim duab, lossis tej zaum txawm tias leej txiv daim duab, lossis txawm tias tus duab ntawm lawv tus kheej, nrog kev tiv thaiv ntau dua. Paul thiab Kat qhov kev tua ntawm Fabkis lub tsev ua liaj ua teb rau zaub mov tau dhau los ua qhov tsis txaus ntseeg; Tom qab ntawd, lawv tau zaum ua ke ntawm lub cav hla lub kwj deg (ib qho ntawm thawj lub ntiaj teb ua tsov ua rog uas tseem tshwm sim hauv Peter Jackson's Lawv Yuav Tsis Loj Hlob) thiab tsis paub ntawv Kat thov kom Povlauj nyeem kom nrov rau nws ib tsab ntawv los ntawm nws tus poj niam, uas excruciatingly qhia ib tug private tsev neeg kev txom nyem.
Tag nrho Quiet ntawm Sab Hnub Pem Hauv Ntej yog qhov tseem ceeb, ua haujlwm hnyav, ua haujlwm nrawm thiab tsom mus thiab nrog kev sib ntaus sib tua scenes uas nws cov ntaub ntawv digital yog cov kws tshaj lij hauv kev nqis tes ua. Nws yeej tsis ua tsis ncaj ncees rau nws cov ntsiab lus, tab sis tej zaum yuav nco qab txog nws tus kheej cov xwm txheej classic. Tej zaum tsis muaj dab tsi nyob rau hauv nws zoo nkaus li lub shudder ntawm lub siab phem qhib ib ntus ntawm lub tshuab ua tsov ua rog: ib tug tub rog raug tua thiab nws cov khaub ncaws raug tshem tawm ntawm nws lub cev tuag, ntxuav thiab kho nrog tag nrho cov lwm tus thiab ces ntxuav tawm mus rau raw recruit Paul nrog cov neeg tuag. lub npe tag ntawd cia li tso rau ntawm dab tshos, mus rau Paul lub bewilderment. ("Tsuas yog me me rau cov phooj ywg - nws tshwm sim txhua lub sijhawm!" piav qhia lub quartermaster maj nrawm, snapping tawm daim ntawv lo.) Tag nrho cov yeeb yam yog flavored nrog no grim premonition ntawm kev tuag.
Tag nrho Quiet ntawm Sab Hnub Pem Sab Hnub Tuaj yog tso tawm rau 14 Lub Kaum Hli hauv cov yeeb yaj kiab, thiab 28 Lub Kaum Hli ntawm Netflix.
