Harkokin Tattaunawar Tattalin Arziki da Ta'addanci

Anti-War Advocate: Shin akwai karar da za a iya yi don yaki?

Pro-War Advocate: To, a. A cikin kalma: Hitler!

Anti-War Advocate: Shin "Hitler!" batun yakin yaƙe-yaƙe? Bari in kawo wasu dalilai da yasa nake ganin ba haka bane. Na farko, duniyar 1940s ta tafi, mulkin mallaka da mulkin mallaka ya maye gurbinsu da wasu nau'ikan, rashin makaman nukiliya da aka maye gurbinsu da barazanar su ta yanzu. Komai yawan mutanen da kuke kira "Hitler," babu ɗayansu wanda yake Hitler, babu ɗayansu da ke neman dunƙule tankokin yaƙi zuwa ƙasashe masu arziki. Kuma, a'a, Rasha ba ta mamaye Ukraine kowane ɗayan lokutan da kuka ji wanda aka ruwaito a cikin 'yan shekarun nan ba. A zahiri, gwamnatin Amurka ta sauƙaƙe juyin mulkin da ya ba Nazis ƙarfi a cikin Ukraine. Kuma har ma wadancan 'yan Nazi ba “Hitler!”

Lokacin da kuka koma shekaru 75 don neman hujja don kafa yaƙi, babban aikin jama'a na Amurka ga kowane ɗayan shekaru 75 da suka gabata, zaku koma wata duniyar daban - abin da ba za mu yi da wani ba sauran aikin. Idan da makarantu sun sanya mutane su zama masu zubewa tsawon shekaru 75 amma sun ilimantar da wani shekaru 75 da suka wuce, shin hakan zai ba da hujjar kashe kuɗin makarantu a shekara mai zuwa? Idan lokacin karshe na asibiti ya ceci rai ya kasance shekaru 75 da suka gabata, shin hakan zai ba da hujjar kashe kuɗin badi a asibitoci? Idan yaƙe-yaƙe ba su haifar da komai ba sai wahala na shekaru 75, menene darajar da'awar cewa akwai kyakkyawa a shekaru 75 da suka gabata?

Hakanan, Yaƙin Duniya na II ya kasance shekaru da yawa ana yinsa, kuma babu buƙatar ciyar da shekarun da suka gabata don ƙirƙirar kowane yaƙi. Ta hanyar guje wa Yaƙin Duniya na ɗaya - yaƙin da kusan babu wanda yake ƙoƙarin ba da hujja - duniya za ta guje wa Yaƙin Duniya na II. Yarjejeniyar Versailles ta ƙare Yaƙin Duniya na ɗaya a cikin wauta wanda mutane da yawa suka yi annabci nan take zai haifar da Yaƙin Duniya na II. Bayan haka Wall Street yayi shekaru gomman saka hannun jari a cikin Nazis. Duk da yake halin rashin kulawa wanda ke sa yaƙe-yaƙe ya ​​zama ruwan dare gama gari, muna iya fahimtar sa da kuma dakatar da shi.

Pro-War Advocate: Amma me ya sa kake tunanin za mu yi? Gaskiyar cewa a ka'ida zamu iya hana sabon Hitler bai sanya nutsuwa daidai ba.

Anti-War Advocate: Ba wani sabon “Hitler!” Hatta Hitler ba “Hitler bane!” Tunanin cewa Hitler yayi niyyar cinye duniya gami da Amurka ya kasance tare da takardu na yaudara ta FDR da Churchill gami da taswirar phony wacce ta sassaka Kudancin Amurka da kuma shirin kawo karshen duk wani addini. Babu wata barazanar Jamusawa ga Amurka, kuma jiragen ruwan da FDR ta yi ikirarin cewa ba a kai musu hari ba suna taimakawa jiragen yakin Burtaniya. Hitler na iya jin daɗin mamayar duniya, amma ba shi da wani shiri ko ikon yin hakan, kamar yadda waɗancan wurare da ya ci nasara ya ci gaba da turjiya.

Pro-War Advocate: Don haka kawai bari yahudawa su mutu? Abinda kuke fada kenan?

Anti-War Advocate: Yaƙi bai da dangantaka da ceton Yahudawa ko wasu wadanda aka kashe. {Asar Amirka da sauran} asashen sun ƙi 'yan gudun hijirar Yahudawa. Gwamnatin Amurka ta kori jirgin ruwa na 'yan gudun hijirar Yahudawa daga Miami. Jirgin Jamus da kuma yakin da aka yi a garuruwan Jamus sun kai ga mutuwar da za a iya tsai da shawarar sulhuntawa, kamar yadda masu neman zaman lafiya ke jayayya. {Asar Amirka ta yi hul] a da Jamus game da fursunonin yaki, amma ba game da kurkuku na sansanin kisan ba, kuma ba game da zaman lafiya ba. Yaƙin Duniya na II a cikin duka ya kashe sau goma yawan mutanen da aka kashe a sansanin Jamus. Hanyoyi na iya zama mummunan amma ba wuya ba. Yaƙin, ba da tsammanin shi ba, bayan bayanan gaskiya, shi ne mummunan abu da mutane suka taɓa yi wa kansu.

Shugaban Amurka ya so yaƙin, ya yi wa Churchill alkawarin, ya yi duk abin da zai iya tsokanar Japan, ya san cewa hari na zuwa, kuma a wannan daren an tsara sanarwar yaƙi da Japan da Jamus. Nasarar kan Jamus babbar nasara ce ta Soviet, tare da Amurka tana ɗan ɗan taka rawar gani. Don haka, gwargwadon yadda yaƙi na iya zama nasara ga wata akida (mai yiwuwa ba haka ba) zai zama mafi ma'ana a kira WWII nasara ga "kwaminisanci" fiye da "dimokiradiyya."

Pro-War Advocate: Me game da kare Ingila da Faransa?

Anti-War Advocate: Da China, da sauran Turai da Asiya? Bugu da ƙari, idan za ku koma shekaru 75, za ku iya komawa fiye da dozin kuma ku guji ƙirƙirar matsalar. Idan zakuyi amfani da ilimin da muke da shi shekaru 75 daga baya, zaku iya amfani da dabaru masu tsayayyar rashin ƙarfi don tasiri. Muna zaune ne a kan shekaru 75 na ƙarin ilimin yadda ƙarfin tashin hankali zai iya kasancewa, gami da ƙarfin lokacin da ake aiki da Nazi. Saboda rashin haɗin kai ba zai iya cin nasara ba, kuma wannan nasarar za ta iya wucewa, babu buƙatar yaƙi. Kuma ko da za ku iya ba da hujjar shiga cikin Yaƙin Duniya na II, har yanzu kuna da hujjar ci gaba da shi na tsawon shekaru da kuma faɗaɗa shi gaba ɗaya yaƙi a kan fararen hula da kayayyakin more rayuwa da nufin iyakar mutuwa da miƙa wuya ba tare da wani sharaɗi ba, hanyar da ba shakka ta kashe miliyoyin rayuka fiye da ceton su - kuma wanene ya ba mu gadon yaƙin gama gari wanda ya kashe dubun dubatan mutane tun.

Pro-War Advocate: Akwai bambanci tsakanin fada a bangaren dama da mara kyau.

Anti-War Advocate: Shin bambanci ne kuke gani daga ƙarƙashin bamabamai? Duk da yake gazawar 'yancin ɗan adam na wata al'ada ba ta ba da hujjar mutane masu fashewar bam (mafi munin irin wannan gazawar da ake yi ba!), Kuma kyautatawa al'adun mutum haka nan ba ya ba da dalilin kashe kowa (ta haka yana share duk wani abin kirki da ake tsammani). Amma yana da kyau a tuna ko a koya, wanda ya haifar, a lokacin, da kuma bayan yakin duniya na biyu, Amurka ta tsunduma cikin tunani, gwajin mutum, nuna wariyar launin fata ga Amurkawa Amurkawa, sansanoni ga Amurkawan Jafananci, da kuma yaduwar wariyar launin fata, adawa da Semitism, da mulkin mallaka. Bayan ƙarshen Yaƙin Duniya na II, bayan da Amurka, ba tare da wata hujja ba, ta jefa bama-bamai na nukiliya a kan biranen biyu, sojojin Amurkan sun yi hayar ɗari-ɗari da tsofaffin 'yan Nazi, ciki har da wasu manyan masu laifi, waɗanda suka sami gida sosai cikin kwanciyar hankali a cikin Masana'antar yaki ta Amurka.

Pro-War Advocate: Hakan yana da kyau kuma mai kyau, amma, Hitler. . .

Anti-War Advocate: Ka ce haka.

Pro-War Advocate: To, to, manta da Hitler. Shin kuna tallafa wa bauta ko yakin basasar Amurka?

Anti-War Advocate: Haka ne, da kyau, bari muyi tunanin cewa muna son kawo karshen tsare mutane da yawa ko kuma amfani da burbushin dabbobi ko kisan dabbobi. Shin zai zama mafi ma'ana a fara nemo wasu manyan filaye da za'a kashe junan su da adadi mai yawa sannan kuma a canza manufar da ake so, ko kuwa zai zama mafi ma'ana a tsallake kisan kuma kawai a tsallaka gaba don yin abin da muke ana so ayi? Wannan shine abin da sauran ƙasashe da Washington DC (Gundumar Columbia) suka yi tare da kawo ƙarshen bautar. Yakin yaƙi bai ba da komai ba, kuma a zahiri ya kasa kawo ƙarshen bautar, wanda ya ci gaba a ƙarƙashin wasu sunaye na kusan ƙarni ɗaya a Kudancin Amurka, yayin da baƙin ciki da tashin hankali na yaƙin har yanzu ba su ja da baya ba. Rigimar da ke tsakanin Arewa da Kudu ita ce kan bautar ko 'yancin sabbin yankuna da za a sata a kashe su a yamma. Lokacin da Kudu ta bar waccan rigimar, bukatar Arewa ita ce ta ci gaba da mulkin ta.

Pro-War Advocate: Menene Arewa za ta yi?

Anti-War Advocate: Maimakon yaƙi? Amsar wannan koyaushe iri ɗaya ce: ba yaƙi ba. Idan Kudu ta tafi, to bar ta. Yi farin ciki tare da ƙarami, ƙasa mai mulkin kai. A daina dawo da duk wanda ya tsere daga bauta. Dakatar da tallafawa bautar tattalin arziki. Sanya kowane kayan aiki marasa amfani don amfani da su don tura dalilin ƙaura a Kudu. Kawai kada ku kashe kashi uku cikin huɗu na mutane miliyan kuna ƙone birane kuma ku haifar da ƙiyayya na har abada.

Pro-War Advocate: Ina tsammanin za ku faɗi irin na Juyin Juya Halin Amurka?

Anti-War Advocate: Zan iya cewa dole ne ku yi laushi sosai don ganin abin da Kanada ya ɓace ta rashin samun ɗaya, ban da matattu da halakarwa, al'adar ɗaukaka yaƙi, da kuma irin tarihin nan na faɗaɗa yammacin tashin hankali da yaƙin ya ɓarke.

Pro-War Advocate: Sauki a gare ka ka ce waiwaye. Ta yaya zaka san yadda abin yake a wancan lokacin da can, idan ka fi George Washington wayo sosai?

Anti-War Advocate: Ina ganin zai yi sauƙi ga kowa ya ce waiwaye. Mun kasance masu jagorancin mayaƙan yaƙi suna duban baya suna nadamar yaƙe-yaƙe da suke yi daga kujerunsu masu duwatsu na ƙarni da yawa. Muna da yawancin jama'a suna cewa kowane yakin da ya goyi baya ba daidai ba ne a fara, shekara ɗaya ko biyu sun yi latti, na ɗan lokaci yanzu. Abinda nake sha'awa shine na ƙi ra'ayin cewa za'a iya yin yaƙi mai kyau a nan gaba, kar a manta da baya.

Pro-War Advocate: Kamar yadda kowa ya fahimci wannan batu, akwai magunguna masu kyau, kamar su Rwanda, wanda aka rasa, wannan ya kamata.

Anti-War Advocate: Me yasa kuke amfani da kalmar "ko da"? Shin ba yaƙe-yaƙe ne kawai ba waɗanda ba su faru ba aka riƙe su da kyau a kwanakin nan? Shin ba duk yaƙe-yaƙe ne na ɗan adam da ke faruwa a zahiri ake sanin duniya da masifa ba? Na tuna an ce min in goyi bayan jefa bam a Libya saboda “Ruwanda!” amma yanzu babu wanda ya taba ce min in jefa bam a Syria saboda “Libya!” - har yanzu koyaushe saboda "Ruwanda!" Amma kisan da aka yi a Ruwanda ya kasance shekaru masu yawa na goyon bayan Amurka a Uganda, da kashe-kashen da Amurka ta ayyana a gaba mai mulkin Ruwanda, wanda Amurka ta yi wa hanya, ciki har da shekarun da suka biyo baya yayin yakin Congo. miliyoyin rayuka. Amma ba a taɓa samun rikicin da zai iya sauƙaƙawa ta hanyar ruwan bama-bamai a Ruwanda ba. Akwai wani lokacin da ba za a iya gujewa ba, wanda aka kirkira ta hanyar yin yaƙi, a lokacin da masu aikin zaman lafiya da masu ba da agaji da 'yan sanda masu ɗauke da makamai na iya taimakawa, amma ba bamabamai ba.

Pro-War Advocate: Don haka ba ku goyi bayan yaƙe-yaƙe ba?

Anti-War Advocate: Bai wuce bautar mutane ba. Yaƙe-yaƙe na Amurka sun kashe kusan gaba ɗaya a gefe ɗaya kuma kusan kusan mazauna, fararen hula. Wadannan yaƙe-yaƙe na kisan kare dangi ne. A halin yanzu ta'addancin da aka gaya mana mu kira kisan kare dangi saboda baƙi ne ke haifar da yaƙi. Yaƙi ba kayan aiki bane don hana wani abu mafi muni. Babu wani abu mafi muni. Yaƙe-yaƙe na farko da farko ta hanyar yawan karkatar da kuɗi ga masana'antar yaƙi, kuɗin da zai iya ceton rayuka. Yaƙi shine babban mai ɓata yanayi. Yakin nukiliya ko haɗari shine, tare da lalata muhalli, babbar barazana ga rayuwar ɗan adam. Yaƙe-yaƙe shine babban abin da ke haifar da 'yancin jama'a. Babu wani abin taimako game da shi.

Pro-War Advocate: Saboda haka ya kamata mu bari Ísis ya tafi tare da shi?

Anti-War Advocate: Wannan zai zama mafi hikima fiye da cigaba da yin rikici ta hanyar yaki da ta'addanci da ke haifar da karin ta'addanci. Me ya sa ba kokarin gwagwarmaya, taimako, diplomacy, da tsabtace tsabta?

Pro-War Advocate: Ka sani, babu wata matsala da abin da ka fada, yaƙi yana kula da rayuwarmu, kuma ba za mu ƙare shi kawai ba.

Anti-War Advocate: Cinikin makamai, wanda Amurka ke jagoranta a duniya, hanya ce ta mutuwa, ba hanyar rayuwa ba. Yana wadatar da fewan kaɗan ta hanyar amfani da yawancin tattalin arziki da kuma na waɗanda suka mutu a sakamakon hakan. Masana'antar yaƙi kanta ƙazamar ruwa ce, ba mahaliccin aiki ba. Zamu iya samun wadatattun ayyuka fiye da wanzu a masana'antar mutuwa daga ƙaramin saka hannun jari a masana'antar rayuwa. Kuma sauran masana'antu ba sa iya cin zarafin matalautan duniya saboda yaƙi - amma idan sun kasance, zan yi farin cikin ganin wannan ya ƙare yayin da yaƙi ya ƙare.

Pro-War Advocate: Kuna iya yin mafarki, amma yaƙi ba makawa ne kuma na dabi'a ne; yana daga cikin halayen mutum.

Anti-War Advocate: A zahiri aƙalla aƙalla 90% na gwamnatocin bil'adama ba sa hannun jari sosai a yaƙi fiye da gwamnatin Amurka, kuma aƙalla 99% na mutane a Amurka ba sa shiga soja. A halin yanzu akwai shari'o'in 0 na PTSD daga ƙin yaƙi, kuma babban wanda ya kashe sojojin Amurka ya kashe kansa. Na halitta, ka ce?!

Pro-War Advocate: Ba za ku iya ɗaukar baƙi ba a matsayin misalai lokacin da muke magana game da ɗabi'ar ɗan adam. Bayan haka, yanzu mun ci gaba da yaƙe-yaƙe waɗanda ke kawar da damuwa da sauran yaƙe-yaƙe, tun da yake a cikin yaƙe-yaƙe babu wanda ake kashewa.

Anti-War Advocate: Lalle kai ne ainihin jin kai.

Pro-War Advocate: Um, na gode. Yana daukan ɗaukar nauyi sosai don fuskantar matsaloli masu wuya.