By Ray McGovern, Antiwar.com, Satumba 19, 2021
Mako guda bayan Shugaba Harry Truman ya kori gwarzon yakin duniya na biyu Janar Douglas MacArthur a watan Afrilu 1951, MacArthur ya yi jawabi ga wani taron haɗin gwiwa na Majalisa tare da jin tausayin wanda Truman farar hula ya ci nasara: “Tsoffin sojoji ba sa mutuwa-suna kawai faduwa. "
MacArthur ya soki Truman a bainar jama'a saboda hana shi izinin nuke "Red China" bayan ta tura sojoji zuwa Koriya don yakar sojojin Amurka a can. Wato a watan Afrilu 1951, shekaru 70 da suka gabata. Truman ya bayyana cewa: "Na kore shi saboda ba zai girmama ikon Shugaban kasa ba ...
Idan aka ba, kwatancen na iya zama mai fa'ida, amma mafi kyawun bayanin sadaka don halayen Shugaban Hafsoshin Hafsoshi 4-star Janar Gen. Mark Milley-da bayanin da galibin waɗanda suka san shi ke kawowa-shine ya cancanci sobriquet Truman ya ba 5-star MacArthur. Na kasance kasa da sadaka, ganin Milley a matsayin mara biyayya da kwafi, kuma - mafi mahimmanci - ƙoƙarin shigar da kansa ba bisa ƙa'ida ba cikin sarkar umarni don ba da izinin amfani da makaman nukiliya.
Haƙiƙa “Hadari”
Milley bai musanta abubuwan ban mamaki ba a cikin littafin "Hadari" na Bob Woodward da Robert Costa. Baya ga kusan abin mamaki (amma an yi maraba da shi) wanda Milley ya ga ya dace ya gargaɗi takwaransa na China cewa zai ba shi jagora idan wani hari da makami a kan China zai zo, akwai kuma abin mamaki mai ban mamaki wanda Milley ya umarci manyan jami'an Pentagon. cewa dole ne ya kasance cikin kowane tattaunawa game da ƙaddamar da makaman nukiliya.
Me ke damun hakan, tambaya The Atlantic. Mutumin kirki Milley ya damu matuka game da mugun mutum Trump don haka ya cece mu duka:
Milley kuma an ba da rahoton cewa ya tara gungun manyan hafsoshin Amurka kuma ya tabbatar da su, ɗaya bayan ɗaya, cewa sun fahimci cewa hanyar sakin makaman nukiliya dole ne ya haɗa da shi. … Milley ta zauna cikin layin, da kyar."
A'a
Na nemi sharhi daga Kanar Douglas Macgregor don tabbatar da tuhumar da nake yi cewa Tekun Atlantika ne ke yin fure. Abin da Milley ya yi a ƙoƙarin shigar da kansa cikin ingantacciyar hanya don ba da izinin amfani da makaman nukiliya ya saba doka, mai yiwuwa ba bisa doka ba. Shugaban JCS ba shi da rawar aiki a cikin wannan sarkar. Ga abin da Macgregor ya gaya mani yau (POTUS, ba shakka, shine Shugaban ƙasa):
Sarkar nukiliya tana gudana daga POTUS zuwa SECDEF zuwa CDR STRATCOM. A bayyane yake, akwai wasu waɗanda POTUS na iya tuntuba, amma gwargwadon umarni abin da ke sama daidai ne. POTUS kuma dole ne ya ba da izini don amfani da kowane makamin dabara a cikin teku ko a cikin iska. Bugu da ƙari, Milley shine babban mai ba da shawara ga rundunar POTUS. Ana iya tuntubar sa, amma babu wani abu a cikin dokar da ke bukatar sa hannu. Mai yiyuwa ne, shi ya sa ya dage kan cewa ya shiga cikin lamarin.
Ba kamar Truman da ke fuskantar irin wannan rashin biyayya ba, Shugaba Biden a ranar Laraba ya bayyana "cikakken kwarin gwiwa" a cikin Janar Milley. Bugu da ƙari, kwatancen na iya zama mai ɓarna, amma Trump ya kira shi "aikin nut".
Ruminations na Farko
Yayin da nake ƙoƙarin daidaita duk wannan jiya, na rubuta wannan maƙarƙashiyar maƙarƙashiya:
Yi magana game da motsin zuciyarmu! Da motsin rai (kuma - ba dole ba ne a faɗi - duk wani mai sharhi yakamata yayi ƙoƙarin gujewa barin nazarin launi na motsin rai), yana da sauƙin sauƙaƙe numfashin numfashi da godiya ga abin da a fili Milley bai musanta ya aikata ba.
Saka kanku cikin takalmin Putin na Xi, duk da haka. Allah mai kyau! Idan manyan sojoji za su iya ɗaukar matakai don guje wa aiwatar da doka (duk da haka mai ban tsoro) kuma an yarda wannan ya tsaya a matsayin abin girmamawa, abin yabo, da kyau, wannan yana nuna cewa manyan sojoji na iya yiwuwa su ma su haifar da/kaddamar da yakin nukiliya ba tare da la'akari da babban kwamanda. Sojojin saman sun yi kokarin yin hakan a tsakiyar rikicin makami mai linzami na Cuba, amma jinin sanyi a Moscow ya hana mafi muni. Har yanzu akwai Curtis LeMays da yawa a kusa.
Idan ni ne Putin, ko Xi, da na ji dole ne in shirya don mafi munin - mafi muni. Tuni suna da isassun shaidu cewa sojojin Amurka-da mutane kamar Donald Rumsfeld da Robert Gates-sun mallaki yaƙe-yaƙe na bayan-9/11; cewa yarjejeniyar tsagaita wuta a Siriya, wacce Kerry da Lavrov suka tattauna cikin watanni 11, kuma Obama da Putin suka ba da izini, Amurka AF ta lalata shi mako guda bayan haka.
Yanzu Putin da XI suna da tabbataccen shaida cewa irin wannan rashin biyayya ya kai ga yuwuwar rikicin NUCLEAR - kuma ya kai har zuwa saman JCS. Kuma ana ganin Milley a matsayin mutumin kirki ga abin da ya yi. Tabbas, Putin da XI, ba su da garantin cewa tashin hankalin da ake ciki yanzu a cikin Amurka na iya haifar da mafi haɗari "Majalisar 'yan kasuwa-mai siyar da makamai" shekara guda daga yanzu DA Trump na wa'adi na biyu.
Menene sojojin da ba a san su ba za su yi don sauƙaƙe hakan? Shin Trump zai yi ƙoƙarin tabbatar da cewa rashin biyayya irin na Milley ba zai iya faruwa ba? Zai iya yin hakan? Mai shakka. An saita abin koyi. Na’am, rantsuwar tana kan Tsarin Mulki; amma Tsarin Mulki ya bayyana sarai cewa Shugaban kasa babban kwamanda ne; kujerar JCS ba. Ci gaba da tunanin irin darussan da XI da Putin za su iya samu daga duk wannan.
Menene Milley yakamata tayi? Ga wani ra'ayi. SAUKI DA KYAU kuma ya kafa misali ga DUK sojojin da ke ƙasa da shi kuma ku yi wa al'umma gargaɗi cikin takamaiman sharuɗɗa. Wanene ya sani, wataƙila misalinsa zai haifar da yin murabus na wasu a cikin sarkar umurnin nukiliya.
Yanzu ina tuna wannan kasuwancin game da Nancy Pelosi yana roƙon Milley da ya yi tsayayya da umarni daga Trump. Wannan, a ganina, ya haɗa matsalar tsarin mulki.
A ƙarshe, an nuna shi Milley da kansa - a gaban shafin NYTimes a ranar 9/11/2021 - zama maƙaryaci mara hankali. Ga kanun labarai: “Hujja ta Rarraba Amurka [Milley] Da'awar Bomb na ISIS a Kabul Drone Strike" - wanda ya kashe yara bakwai, ma'aikacin agaji, et al. Kuma na NYT ɗaukar hoto ya haɗa, sau biyu, isasshen bidiyo ga waɗanda suka fi son duba-da-gani maimakon karatu. (Wannan ga alama sabon abu ne, kuma mai mahimmanci, a gare ni. Akwai fashewa a cikin kayan NYT game da Milley, wanda ke buƙatar a bi kafin a manne shi kusa.)
A takaice dai, a cikin wannan mahallin MICIMATT yanzu yana da “M” na farko tare da ɗan tsarin garkuwar jiki, don yin magana. Ana iya fallasa "M" kuma a gyara shi a saman. Bari in ba da shawarar cewa, aƙalla tare da wancan labarin shafin farko a ranar 9/11/21, da NYT wataƙila yana ɗaukar matsayin Kayafa, babban firist yana kallon Masarautar da ta gabata. "Ya fi kyau mutum ɗaya ya mutu," in ji shi ya yi bayani: "Shin ba za ku iya ganin cewa amfaninmu ne mutum ɗaya ya mutu ba… (“Ƙasa” a cikin wannan mahallin yana nufin tsarin gatan da abokan haɗin gwiwa tare da Rome ke morewa - manyan firistoci, lauyoyi, da sauran MICIMATT na wannan ranar.)
Amma duk da haka, ina ganin cewa yadda sauran kafofin watsa labarai ke yin amfani da littafin Woodward/Costa na iya nufin MICIMATT yanzu tana rufe sahu don haɗa Milley da kansa a matsayin "yanayin nagarta."
Bari mu ga yadda kafofin watsa labarai yanzu ke ɗaukar labarin yau cewa Janar Milley ya ɓatar da mu duka a cikin iƙirarin cewa harin da jirgin saman Amurka ya kai a Kabul a ranar 29 ga Agusta ya kasance "na adalci", ya kashe wani ɗan ƙungiyar ISIS. Bayan ƙaddamar da irin binciken da yawanci ke ɗaukar watanni na Pentagon, ta ba da rahoton yau cewa, a'a, yara 7 ne ma'aikacin agaji daga wata ƙungiya mai zaman kanta ta Amurka, da wasu biyu da aka kashe. Sakamakon, wanda a bayyane yake ga masu karanta NY Times, ya zo da sauri. Idan Biden ba shi da ƙarfin gwiwa don korar Milley, bari mu tashi tsaye don cire shi - ko bebe, mara biyayya, kwafi - ko duka ukun.
Na yi hirar da aka yi a sama ran juma'a.
Ray McGovern yana aiki tare da gaya wa Kalmar, wani bangaren buga littattafai na cocin Ecumenical na Mai Ceto a cikin garin Washington na ciki. Aikinsa na shekaru 27 a matsayin mai nazarin CIA ya hada da yin aiki a matsayin Babban Jami'in Ofishin Siyasar Kasashen Waje na Soviet da mai shiryawa / mai ba da rahoto game da Takaitaccen Bayanin Shugaban Kasa. Shi ne wanda ya kirkiro Vwararrun Professionwararrun encewararrun forwararru don Sanity (VIPS).
