Tattaunawar yanzu game da shirin ficewar sojojin Amurka da na NATO daga cibiyoyin Afghanistan a kan kyakkyawar akida cewa tsohon mai nazarin CIA-abokin aikina Paul Pillar ya fallasa shekaru 12 da suka gabata. Paul ya kira shi "mabuɗin da ba za a sake barin Afghanistan ta zama mafakar kungiyoyin 'yan ta'adda ba, musamman al-Qaeda".
tare da Lahadi Washington Post "Sky Yana Falling" -type gargadi, Da NY TimesMaureen Dowd ke cewa A'a ba haka bane, a ina mutum zai juya don samun ƙwarewar wayewa?
Babu matsala: Kawai sake karanta Paul Pillar's Washington Post ed na Satumba 16, 2009, wanda Bulus zai iya yi masa taken: Ta'addanci Ga Dummies. Post din ya zabi kanun labarai: “Haƙƙin Haƙiƙanin roan ta'adda ba ya ƙasa, Yana kan layi. "
Wadannan bayanan ne:
Yaya mahimmancin kungiyoyin ta'adda yake da wata mafaka ta zahiri? Much Ta yaya mafaka ke shafar haɗarin hare-haren ta'addanci game da bukatun Amurka, musamman ma asalin ƙasar Amurka? Amsar tambaya ta biyu ita ce: ba kusan yadda tunanin da ba a bayyana ba yake tsammani. Shirye-shiryen da suka fi mahimmanci ga harin Satumba 11, 2001, ba a sansanonin horo a Afghanistan ba, a'a, a cikin gidaje a Jamus, dakunan otal a Spain da makarantun jirgin sama a Amurka. A cikin 'yan shekarun da suka gabata, kungiyoyin' yan ta'adda na duniya sun sami ci gaba ta hanyar amfani da dunkulewar duniya da fasahar sadarwa, wanda hakan ya rage dogaro da mafaka ta zahiri.
Batun a yau shine ko hana irin wannan mafakar zai rage barazanar ta'addancin da Amurka ke fuskanta daga abin da zai iya zama don daidaita kashewar jini da dukiya da ake bukata da kuma abubuwan da ke hana cin nasara a Afghanistan, gami da rashin ingantaccen tsarin mulki da kuma fadada goyon baya daga yawan jama'a. Dakatar da kirkirar wani waje na zahiri ya zama dole ya daidaita duk wani ci gaba ga ta'addanci ga Amurka wanda ya samo asali daga tunanin cewa Amurka ta zama 'yar mamaya maimakon kare Afghanistan.
Pillar da Shugaban-Mafarauta
Paul Pillar ya rike manyan mukamai a CIA, gami da Jami'in Leken Asiri na Gabas ta Tsakiya - babban mukami a wannan yankin - kuma ya san kadan game da ta'addanci, haka nan. Ya zama shugaban bincike a Cibiyar Ta'addanci ta ta'addanci a 1993 kuma mataimakin darektan Cibiyar shekaru hudu bayan haka. Lokacin da babban mai zane-zane mai suna Cofer Black ya karbi Cibiyar a 1997, sai dai Pillar ya bar - saboda "rikicin arangama", a cewar Steve Coll a Fatalwar Fatalwa: Tarihin Sirrin CIA, Afghanistan da Bin Laden (Penguin, 2005).
Ba shi da wuya a bayyana abin da ya sa Maɗaukaki Maɗaukaki da mai jan hankali zai zama kamar mai da ruwa. Babban mai ba da cikakken aiki, Black ya kasance na ƙarshe a cikin Hukumar mashahurin kamfanin makamashi na Yukren Burisma. Amma wannan shine kawai da'awar da ya yi kwanan nan game da sananne.
Geaukar fansa tawa ce, Inji Black
Yi tunani a kan kwanakin ramuwar gayya nan da nan bayan 9/11, da kuma tsarin macho wanda Shugaba Bush ya tsara kuma ya sa layin layin ta hanyar jami'an CIA da wakilansu masu tasiri a cikin kafofin watsa labarai - tare da Cofer Black kamar sauti na Shakespeare Herodias, Lady Macbeth, da Lewis Carroll Sarauniyar Zuciya.
Jami'in CIA din Gary Schroen ya fadawa Rediyon Jama'a na kasa cewa, 'yan kwanaki bayan 9/11, shugaban' yan ta'addan Cofer Black ya aike shi zuwa Afghanistan tare da umarnin "Kama kama bin Laden, a kashe shi, kuma a dawo da kansa cikin akwati a kan busassun kankara." Game da sauran shugabannin al Qaeda, rahotanni sun ce Black, "Ina son kawunansu kan pikes."
Wannan sautin mara kyau - da yare - ya sake bayyana tsakanin masanan-abokantaka na sirri, koyaushe suna ɗokin taimako.
Spyididdigar Pan leƙen asiri na Spy-Pundit
Consaya daga cikin masu bincike, Washington Post tsohon soja Jim Hoagland ya dan wuce gona da iri wajen buga budaddiyar wasika zuwa ga Shugaba Bush a ranar 31 ga Oktoba, 2001. Ba wani abin alfahari ba ne na Halloween. Maimakon haka, Hoagland ya goyi bayan abin da ya kira "fata" don "kan Osama bin Laden a kan jirgin ruwa," wanda ya yi ikirarin cewa shi ne manufar "janar-janar da jami'an diflomasiyya" na Bush.
Yi al'ajabin inda Hoagland ta sami wannan ɗan azaba.
A lokaci guda, akwai haɗari cikin raba bayanai da yawa tare da dabbobin gida / na waje. A cikin budaddiyar wasikar da ya aika wa Bush, Hoagland ya daga labule a kan ainihin, mafi shirin wasan jini na watanni masu zuwa ta hanyar bai wa Bush wannan umarni na fifiko. Bukatar ma'amala da ci gaba da tarin Iraki da makamai masu guba da fasahar kere-kere da kera bam din nukiliya ba ta yadda za a rage ta da bukatun yakin Afghanistan. Dole ne ku gudanar da wannan kamfen din domin ku samu sauki daga gare shi da sauri don kawo karshen barazanar da gwamnatin Saddam Hussein ke yi. Ko ta yaya, Hoagland ta sami ra'ayin "madogara" makonni uku kafin Sakataren Tsaro Donald Rumsfeld ya kira Janar Tommy Franks ya gaya masa cewa Shugaban kasar yana so ya karkata akalarsa zuwa Iraki. Franks da manyan mataimakansa na aiki kan shirye-shiryen kai hari a kan Tora Bora inda aka yi amannar bin Laden ya buya amma sai aka karkatar da hankali, tsarawa, da kayan aiki zuwa Iraki. Don haka kamar yadda Osama bin Laden ya fito daga Tora Bora ya bi ta cikin dutsen ya wuce zuwa Pakistan.
Abin lura a nan shi ne cewa masu son ba da bayanan sirri a cikin kafofin watsa labaru masu ba da labarin na CIA sun yi musu cikakken bayani - wani bangare saboda suna taka-tsantsan da cizon hannayen da ke ciyar da su ta hanyar sukar CIA. Waɗannan masanan suna da littafin adireshi mafi nauyi tare da sunayen jami'an ayyukan CIA - waɗanda suka gaya wa waɗannan Washington Post jiga-jigan wannan karshen mako cewa sama za ta fadi idan Biden ya kawo sojojin daga Afghanistan. Duba karkashin “P” a cikin waɗancan littattafan adireshin; Ba na tsammanin za ku sami “Paul Pillar”.
Shin akwai waɗanda za su yi farin ciki don neman ƙarin “yaƙi na har abada” a Afghanistan? To, yaya game da Jeff Bezos, wanda ya sayi Washington Post shekaru takwas da suka gabata, har yanzu yana sarrafa shi, kuma yana da manyan kwangila tare da CIA. Na ƙi jin sauti ba tare da komai ba, amma a ƙarƙashin wannan duk akwai MICIMATT (Sojan-Masana'antu-Majalisa-Mai hankali-Media-Academia-Think-Tank hadadden. [Kara jaddadawa.]
Ray McGovern yana aiki tare da gaya wa Kalmar, wani bangaren buga littattafai na cocin Ecumenical na Mai Ceto a cikin garin Washington na ciki. Aikinsa na shekaru 27 a matsayin mai nazarin CIA ya hada da yin aiki a matsayin Babban Jami'in Ofishin Siyasar Kasashen Waje na Soviet da mai shiryawa / mai ba da rahoto game da Takaitaccen Bayanin Shugaban Kasa. Shi ne wanda ya kirkiro Vwararrun Professionwararrun encewararrun forwararru don Sanity (VIPS).
