By Sam Husseini
Akwai wasu kyawawan lokuta masu motsa rai a cikin taron tunawa da Concepcion Picciotto a cocin Luther's Place ranar Asabar.
An san Concepcion - tare da William Thomas, wanda ya mutu 'yan shekaru da suka wuce - don jagorantar abin da a fili shine zanga-zangar mafi tsawo a tarihin Amurka: Aiki da makaman nukiliya a Lafayette Park, a cikin Lafayette Park. gaban fadar White House. Ta rasu a watan jiya.
Kamar yadda WTOP- gidan labarai na cikin gida - An lura a yau: "Fitowar makamin nukiliyar Picciotto ya zama wani taro na dindindin a fadar White House na shugabanni biyar a jere, ciki har da Shugaba Barack Obama, amma babu daya daga cikin shugabannin da ya taba magana da ita."
Tom Siemer, tare da rawar jiki yana riƙe da makirufo, ya yi kuka "Na kera makaman nukiliya tsawon shekaru 23" sannan Concepcion "ba ta da son kai sosai" - yayin da ta mutu a zahiri har zuwa ƙarshen zaman lafiya, tare da rashin lafiya, kusan rashin gida, ci gaba da faɗakarwa. . Ta kasance kamar mai zanga-zanga wanda immolates kai, amma a sannu a hankali.
A wurin taron tunawa, masu magana sun haɗa da tsohon mutumin CIA Ray McGovern wanda ya lura da Washington Postbayyananniyar sahihancinta don tambayar lafiyar Concepcion, kuma ya tambayi wanene mahaukaci anan PostRa'ayin da ya fito fili na cewa sha'awarta na hana yakin nukiliya ya yi kamari. Lauyanta, wanda ya yi magana da farko da dogon lokaci, ya yi wasu iri ɗaya, amma da alama a wani lokaci don tsara barazanar nukiliyar da ta samo asali daga koyarwar MAD, tabbatacciyar ɓarna tare da juna, a matsayin wani abu mai sauƙi na Yaƙin Cold. Ya kusan jiyo sautin jin daɗin da mutum zai ji daga wurin Post, yana nufin gardamarsa da ita, da kyar ya rikitar da ido.
An sami haske game da tsattsauran ra'ayi na Concepcion a lokacin hidimar - ba a haɗa ta kai tsaye a cikin alamar sassaucin ra'ayi ba kamar yadda Martin Luther King ya kasance sau da yawa, amma, mai mahimmanci, kalmar "Isra'ila" ba a furta ba a wurin tunawa a cikin coci. Wannan abu ne mai ban mamaki tun da yake da wuya a yi minti uku suna magana da Concepcion ba tare da ta yi magana game da Isra'ila ba - ko dai laifuffukan da ta aikata ko kuma mummunar barazanar da makaman nukiliya da ba a san su ba. Ayyukanta sun jaddada abubuwan da 'yan kaɗan ke yi: Isra'ila ita ce watakila babbar barazana saboda tana da manyan makaman nukiliya, ta ƙi sanya hannu kan yarjejeniyar hana yaduwar makaman nukiliya, tana amfani da tashin hankali ba tare da wani hukunci mai ban mamaki ba kuma wata ƙasa ce mai mulkin mallaka.
Kuma Concepcion ba - kamar yadda wasu, ciki har da Caitlin Gibson Washington Post sun yi mata nuni da cewa - mai fafutukar hana yaduwar makaman nukiliya. Ta kasance don disarmament. Concepcion ta fito fili: "Ku rayu da bam, ku mutu da bam." Maganarta ita ce Amurka da sauran masu karfin nukiliya suna rayuwa da bam kuma dole ne su daina. Ta kasance game da disarming makaman nukiliya na yanzu sun bayyana cewa; ba kawai hanawa ba haɓaka na makaman nukiliya zuwa wasu jihohi. Bayan haka, galibi manufofin gwamnatin Amurka ne cewa kasashen da ke da makaman nukiliya a halin yanzu su kula da su, wasu kuma a hana su. Gwamnatin Amurka lokaci-lokaci ta kan yi yaƙi ko barazanar yaƙe-yaƙe kan wannan batu.
Concepcion mai da hankali kan Isra'ila a wasu lokuta ma tana damun ni - Ba'amurke Ba'amurke - lokacin da zan yi magana da ita. Kar ka dauki maganata, duba wasu bidiyoyin ta. Ba ta daɗe ba ta ambaci Isra'ila. Kuma idan kun yi la'akari da shi, don kyakkyawan dalili.
A ƙarshe an furta kalmar "Isra'ila" daga makirufo - bayan ɗari ko fiye da haka mutane sun bar cocin kuma suka je wurin da ta daɗe tana zanga-zangar a gaban Fadar White House, saita wurin salon hoto na Medea Benjamin na CodePink. .
An bar wa Simin Royanian, Ba'amurke ɗan gwagwarmaya kuma manazarci ya furta kalmar lokacin da aka ba da mic. Ta yi nuni da yadda Concepcion ke adawa da sahyoniyancin Isra'ila, ta kuma ce a ko da yaushe tana goyon bayan Falasdinawa da sauran kungiyoyin 'yantar da yankin Gabas ta Tsakiya.
Watakila haka yake ga dukan annabawa - sa'ad da suka mutu, da yawa a kusa da su suna watsi da maganganunsu na tsakiya waɗanda suke da alama ba su dace ba amma a zahiri su ne jigon sadaukarwarsu da amincinsu.
Amma, a'a, an yi watsi da Concepcion a rayuwa. John Steinbach, wanda ya daɗe yana fafutukar yaƙi da makamin nukiliya kuma mai kula da kwamitin zaman lafiya na Hiroshima/Nagasaki ya gaya mani: “Kungiyoyi da yawa ba su ɗauki Concepion da muhimmanci ba. Ba zan iya gaya muku adadin lokutan da na yi ƙoƙarin samun ƙungiyoyin zaman lafiya na yau da kullun waɗanda suka yi zanga-zanga a dandalin Lafayette don haɗawa ko gayyata ko aƙalla amincewa da vigil ɗinta wanda ke nan. Hakan bai taba faruwa ba.” Akasin haka, Steinbach ya ce: “Waɗanda suka tsira daga Japan [bam ɗin nukiliya] suna ƙaunarta kuma suna daraja ta kuma koyaushe suna son yin lokaci tare da ita.”
Taron tunawa da taron ya nuna wakilin Japan yana karanta wata sanarwa daga kwamitin zaman lafiya na Hiroshima/Nagasaki. Abin baƙin cikin shine, ya kuma ba da adadi mai kyau na clichés - "Za Mu Ci Nasara" da kuma tsayin daka don yabon muryar annabci yayin da watsi da yawancin abubuwan da ke ciki, maimakon maimaita waƙar "Juya, Juya, Juya".
Amma babu wani abu da aka ce game da Concepcion.
Tana da madaidaicin murya, ƙaramar murya ta Sipaniya kuma tana faɗin maganganun siyasa gaba ɗaya. “Kada Ka Zama Lemming — Ceton Kanka — Ka Ƙarfafa Makaman Kisan Kisa” karanta alamarta. "Shiru laifi ne na yaki." Za ta yi kyau ta tsaya kan saƙo kamar yadda suke faɗa, tana maimaita abin da alamunta za su faɗi. "Bush mai laifin yaki ne" ta sake maimaitawa.
Kuma ta ɗauki alamu a kan Isra'ila sama kuma ba tare da neman gafara ba: "Yahudanci YES / Sihiyoniya NO" da "Kwasa Isra'ila Makamai - 200 Illegal Nucs - Ajiye Duniya - Save the Children" da "Dakatar da Tallafawa Ta'addancin Isra'ila."
Babban kaya.
Amma ta yi maganganun siyasa a kan Isra'ila waɗanda ba zan taɓa yin ba; kuma ban shiga cikin gwagwarmayar da ta yi da wasu masu fafutuka ba, wadanda da alama suna da rigima a wasu lokuta. Wata alamar da za ta riƙe ita ce “Ƙasa ɗaya ƙarƙashin Isra’ila” (wanda ke ɗauke da tutar Amurka mai tauraro daga tutar Isra’ila a kai) da kuma wata: “’Yan Ta’adda Mu Ne—’Holocaust:’ Kalma da Sahayoniyawan suka yi amfani da shi wajen aikata laifuka Against Humanity" (tare da swastika scrawled a) - wanda ke nuna gidan yanar gizon Neturei Karta - Yahudawan Orthodox sun Haɗu da Sihiyonanci.
“Holocaust” na Nazi ba “kalmar” ce kawai da aka yi amfani da ita don dalilai na kisa ba, har ma da ainihin gaskiyar tarihi. Amma ba ta rubuta cewa “kawai” ba ne, kodayake mutane da yawa sun karanta ta haka. Kuma ba na biyan kuɗi ga ra'ayin cewa Amurka tana "Karƙashin Isra'ila". A gaskiya, ba ni da yawa ganin al'ummai kuma. Na fi ganin sojoji: mulkin mallaka, mulkin mallaka, tsarin jari-hujja na kamfanoni, mulkin mallaka da rashin sanin yakamata da kuma yadda sauran dakarun ke bijirewa da kuma yin hadin gwiwa da su.
Amma ban sake ganin alamun Concepcion akan Isra'ila ba a wurin taron tunawa, wanda ke ci gaba kuma da alama yana tsaftace kansa. Kamar yadda na rubuta, vigil ɗin yana da alamar guda ɗaya game da zanga-zangar mai zuwa don nuna adawa da AIPAC - don haka a fili har yanzu yana da kyau a soki ƙungiyoyin sahyoniyawa masu haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙƙin haƙ? Wannan nau'i na keɓancewa ya raba tsakiyar cibiyar makaman nukiliyar Isra'ila, wanda gwamnatin Amurka ta hana ta yin magana, daga aikin yaƙi da makaman nukiliya a cikin shirin.
Da gaske, kun kama hakan? Ba bisa ka'ida ba jami'an Amurka su yi magana game da makamin nukiliyar Isra'ila. Kamar yadda Grant Smith ya samo: "A karkashin wasu sanannun umarnin gag guda biyu - hukuncin daurin kurkuku - Ma'aikatan hukumar gwamnati da 'yan kwangila da tsaron Amurka ba zai iya bayyana cewa Isra'ila na da shirin kera makaman nukiliya ba." Don haka wataƙila ya ci ɗaya don sansanin “Al’umma ɗaya ƙarƙashin Isra’ila”.
Amma yin watsi da makaman nukiliya na Isra'ila yana da tasirin ban mamaki na mai kallon butulci yana mamakin "me yasa Isra'ila ta zaba?" - tun da makaman nukiliya na Isra'ila - wanda ya kasance ƙwararrun 'yan sahayoniya masu sassaucin ra'ayi Ben Gurion da Shimon Peres - ya kasance a gefe maimakon kasancewa gaba da tsakiya.
Tabbas Concepcion ya kasance da wahala, aƙalla a gare ni, in yi magana da. Na yi ƙoƙarin taimaka mata ta sami matsuguni a lokaci ɗaya, wanda zai iya haifar da haɗin gwiwa wanda zai iya taimaka, yana da wuya a faɗi a wasu lokuta, amma ba shakka ta kasance kaɗan - kawai gidaje a kusa da Fadar White House za su yi ba shakka. Kamar abin son kai ne nata. Ina karasa fatan na kara hakuri da kokarin taimaka mata; Allah yasa ta hakura mana.
Duk da haka, na yi fatan cewa zanga-zangar za ta kasance mafi fahimta, hakika ta zo a matsayin mai ban mamaki a wasu lokuta. Amma ina tsammanin za a iya gyara hakan ba tare da an tsabtace shi yadda ya kamata ba, wanda da alama inda aka dosa.
Gaba da tsakiya yanzu sune alamun banal na yau da kullun, waɗanda sune kayan benci na baya don Concepcion: "Yaƙi Ba Amsar ba". Da gaske? Ina da labari a gare ku: Yaƙi sau da yawa shine amsar. Yaƙi na iya zama ainihin amsar idan tambayar ita ce yadda za a iya mamaye duniyar ta yadda ya kamata, wanda sau da yawa yake ga mutane da yawa.
Sabis ɗin tunawa da aka sanya don Concepcion ya fito da fassarar "Ba Za a Yi Nazarin Yaƙi Ba." Ban yarda ba. A gaskiya ba mu yi karatun yaƙi kusan isa ba. "Ƙungiyar zaman lafiya" tana buƙatar shawo kan kanta kuma ta yi magana game da yaƙi: mutuwa, halaka, ƙafafu masu tashi da ƙamshi a cikin madaidaicin sharuddan idan yana da sha'awar canza abubuwa a zahiri kuma ba wai kawai jin fifikon waɗanda 'yan Republican masu tsoro ba.
Saurin ɓacewa daga faɗakarwa shine abin da ke tsakiyar Concepcion: ta hanyar rungumar ɗan adam mai tsattsauran ra'ayi, fahimtar haramtattun kafuwar, ta yi fushi da su daidai. A halin yanzu, ina tsammanin alamun "Tibet Kyauta" za su tashi a cikin faɗuwar rana.
A cikin hira da na yi da ita lokaci-lokaci tsawon shekaru, ina tsammanin Concepcion ta yi nuni ga gaskiya ta tsakiya - cewa mulkin mallaka da Sihiyoniya sune manyan sojojin da ke barazana ga duniya. Kuma wannan gaskiyar ta tsakiya tana ci gaba da ɓoyewa ta hanyar mutane suna magana game da masu ra'ayin mazan jiya ko masu sassaucin ra'ayi maimakon ganin duk wani aikin mulkin mallaka a wurin aiki, ko watakila ba haka "neo" ba a wasu lokuta - kawai mulkin mallaka. Kuma ya kamata a bayyana a fili: Ba ta ware Isra'ila da gaske ba kamar yadda wasu suke yi - za ta yi magana game da "ta'addanci" na Amurka da ba a ambata ba cikin sauki kamar Isra'ila.
Idan ta yi kama da ta dage sosai kan mulkin mallaka da Sihiyoniya da kuma barazanar da Isra'ila ta yi wa bil'adama da ba a san ta ba, ina tsammanin wannan martani ne ba kawai ga waɗancan barazanar da hukuma ba kuma ba wai kawai ga kafofin watsa labarai na kamfanoni ba - har ma da shuruwar “ci gaba” masu fafutuka kan tambayoyin tsakiya. Sihiyoniya mai makamin nukiliya.
Abin takaici, hidimar tunawa da kanta ta zama abin tunawa ga wannan shiru. 
