John Rees ya ce ‘yaki da ta’addanci’ ne ke haifar da ta’addanci kuma gwamnati ta wuce gona da iri kan barazanar tare da jajanta wa Musulman Birtaniya samun karbuwa ga manufofinta na yaki.
An kai harin bam a cikin mota a Baghdad 7 ga Oktoba, 2013.
An kawo karshen taron wayar da kan jama'a kan yaki da ta'addanci na gwamnatin Burtaniya. An ba da sanarwar wasu tarin sabbin dokoki da aka ce za su kare mu daga hare-haren ta'addanci tare da karfafa cibiyoyi da daidaikun mutane su kai rahoto ga 'yan sanda duk wanda suke tunanin yana da hannu a ta'addanci.
Wannan dai shi ne karo na baya bayan nan na irin wadannan matakan, wani bangare na yunkurin da ake yi na jan hankalin al'ummar duniya wajen ganin yadda gwamnati ta kasance a duniya.
Duk da haka akwai matsala ta tsakiya guda ɗaya. Labarin gwamnati bai dace da gaskiya ba. Ga dalilin:
Gaskiya ta 1: Me ke kawo ta'addanci? Siyasar waje ce, wawa
Hoto na farko: Mutanen da 'yan ta'adda suka kashe a duk duniya
Abin da wannan jadawali ya nuna (hoto na 1) shi ne karuwar ta'addanci a duniya bayan mamayewar Afganistan a 2002 da Iraki a 2003. Kamar yadda Dame Eliza Manningham Buller, tsohon shugaban MI5, ya shaida wa binciken Iraki. Hukumar tsaro ta gargadi Tony Blair kaddamar da yaki da ta'addanci zai kara barazanar ta'addanci. Kuma yana da. Ba za a iya kawar da barazanar ta'addanci ba har sai an kawar da dalilansa na asali. Babu wani mataki na doka da zai iya kawar da abubuwan da ke haifar da ta'addanci a tarihin gabas ta tsakiya. Canjin siyasa ne kawai zai iya yin hakan.
Gaskiya ta biyu: Galibin ta'addanci ba ya faruwa a kasashen Yamma
Hoto 2: Taswirar kasada ta duniya
Mutanen da suka fi fuskantar barazanar ta'addanci ba a kasashen yammacin duniya suke ba amma galibi a yankunan da kasashen yamma ke fada da yake-yakensu da yakin neman zabe. Arewacin Amurka da kusan dukkanin Turai suna cikin ƙananan haɗari (Fig. 2). Faransa kawai, ƙasar da ke da dogon lokaci da mulkin mallaka (kuma ɗaya daga cikin mafi yawan aiki a cikin rikice-rikice na yanzu) yana cikin haɗari mai matsakaici. Shida daga cikin kasashen da suka fi fuskantar hadarin - Somalia, Pakistan, Iraq, Afghanistan, Sudan, Yemen - wuraren yakin yammacin duniya ne, yakin basasa ko yakin basasa.
Gaskiya ta 3: 'Yaƙin ta'addanci' ya fi kashe mutane fiye da ta'addanci
Maganin ya fi cutar mutuwa. Tunani na ɗan lokaci zai gaya mana dalilin. Ƙaddamar da ƙarfin wuta na soja na yammacin duniya, mafi fasaha da fasaha a duniya, koyaushe zai ƙare ya kashe fiye da fararen hula fiye da dan kunar bakin wake tare da jakar baya - ko ma harin 9/11 a cikin jiragen da aka sace.
Kamar yadda wannan ginshiƙi ke nunawa (Hoto na 3), mutuwar fararen hula a Afganistan kaɗai ya fi waɗanda harin 9/11 ya haddasa. Idan kuma muka kara kashe fararen hula da yakin Iraki ya haifar da ta'addancin da ya haifar a lokacin mamayar to lallai ne kamfanin ya kasance daya daga cikin mafi rashin fa'ida a tarihin soji.
Hoto na 3: Rikici daga yakin da ake yi da ta'addanci da mamaye kasar Iraki
Gaskiya ta hudu: Haqiqanin barazanar ta'addanci
Hare-haren ta'addanci sau da yawa ba su da tasiri, musamman idan masu tsattsauran ra'ayi 'kerkeci' ke kai su maimakon ƙungiyoyin soja kamar IRA. Fiye da rabin hare-haren ta'addanci ba su haifar da asarar rayuka ba. Ko da idan muka kalli lokacin da IRA ke da hannu wajen tayar da bama-bamai da kuma hoton duniya (Fig. 4) yawancin hare-haren ta'addanci ba su kashe kowa ba. Wannan ba don rage asarar rayuka da ke faruwa ba. Amma shi ne a sanya shi a cikin hangen nesa.
Yanzu kusan shekaru goma ke nan da harin bam na 7/7 a London. A cikin wadannan shekaru goma an sake samun karin kisa guda daya a Burtaniya sakamakon ta'addancin 'Musulunci', na mai buga ganga Lee Rigby. Wannan ya kawo adadin mutuwar shekaru 10 zuwa mutane 57. A shekarar da ta gabata kadai adadin mutanen da aka kashe a kisan gilla na 'al'ada' a Burtaniya sun kai 500. Kuma wannan shi ne daya daga cikin mafi karancin alkaluman shekaru da dama.
Babu shakka babu kwatance tsakanin matakin yakin IRA da ‘tsattsauran ra’ayin Musulunci’ na yau. Bayan haka, IRA, ta tarwatsa wani babban Tory a cikin Majalisar Dokoki, ta kashe wani dan gidan sarauta a cikin jirgin ruwa a gabar tekun Ireland, ta tarwatsa otal din da majalisar ministocin ke zama a cikin taron jam'iyyar Tory tare da kori. turmi a cikin lambun baya na 10 Downing Street. Kuma wannan shine in ambaci kaɗan ne kawai daga cikin manyan hare-hare masu ban mamaki.
Ko da a cikin lokacin tun 2000 an sami ƙarin haƙiƙa (kamar yadda aka tsara) hare-haren Real IRA da ɗalibin ɗalibin Islama na Ukrain Pavlo Lapshyn, waɗanda suka gudanar da kisan kai da jerin hare-hare a kan masallatai a West Midlands, fiye da wanda aka yi ta hanyar. 'Musulunci' masu tsattsauran ra'ayi.
Hoto na 4: Jimillar asarar rayuka a kowane harin ta'addanci
Amma kar ka dauki maganata. Karanta menene Foreign Policy, jaridar House of the US diplomatic elite, sai in ce a cikin 2010 wani labarin mai suna 'Sana'a ce, wawa!':
"A kowane wata, an fi samun 'yan ta'addar kunar bakin wake da suke kokarin kashe Amurkawa da kawayensu a Afghanistan, Iraki, da sauran kasashen musulmi fiye da duk shekarun da suka gabata kafin 2001. a hade. Daga 1980 zuwa 2003, an kai hare-haren kunar bakin wake 343 a duniya, kuma aƙalla kashi 10 cikin 2004 na ƙin jinin Amurka ne. Tun daga 2,000, an sami fiye da 91, sama da kashi XNUMX cikin XNUMX na yaƙi da sojojin Amurka da na ƙawance a Afghanistan, Iraki, da sauran ƙasashe.
Kuma Rand Corporation binciken kammala:
“Babban binciken ya yi nazari kan kungiyoyin ‘yan ta’adda 648 da suka wanzu tsakanin shekarar 1968 zuwa 2006, wanda aka zana daga bayanan ta’addanci da RAND da Cibiyar Tunawa da Tunawa da Ta’addanci ke kula da su. Hanyar da aka fi sani da kungiyoyin ta'addanci - kashi 43 cikin 7 - ta kasance ta hanyar sauya sheka zuwa tsarin siyasa…Rundunar soji ta yi tasiri a kashi XNUMX cikin XNUMX kawai na kararrakin da aka bincika'.
Darasin duk wannan a bayyane yake: yaki da ta'addanci yana haifar da ta'addanci. Kuma gwamnati na kara gishiri a cikin barazanar domin samun karbuwar manufar da ba ta dace ba. Yin hakan yana lalata al'ummomi gaba ɗaya kuma yana tabbatar da cewa wasu tsiraru suna da ƙarin kuzari don kai hare-haren ta'addanci. Wannan shi ne ainihin ma'anar manufar rashin amfani.
Source: Yaƙi
