Daga Ben Norton, Janairu 8, 2018
daga Fair.org
Don shahararriyar hanyar sadarwar labarai ta USB MSNBC, bala'in jin kai mafi girma a duniya a fili bai cancanci kulawa ba - ko da yake gwamnatin Amurka ta taka muhimmiyar rawa wajen haifar da kuma kiyaye wannan rikici mara misaltuwa.
Wani bincike da FAIR ya yi ya gano cewa babbar hanyar sadarwa ta kebul mai sassaucin ra'ayi ba ta gudanar da wani yanki da aka keɓe musamman ga Yemen a rabin na biyu na 2017.
Kuma a cikin waɗannan ƙarshen kusan watanni shida na shekara. MSNBC ya gudu kusan kashi 5,000 fiye da sassan da aka ambata Rasha fiye da sassan da suka ambaci Yemen.
Haka kuma, a cikin duk 2017, MSNBC Sai dai daya watsa shirye-shirye kan hare-haren da Saudiyyar da Amurka ke marawa baya wanda ya yi sanadin mutuwar dubban fararen hular Yaman. Kuma ba a taba ambaton cutar kwalara da ke fama da talauci a kasar ba, wadda ta kamu da cutar ta Yaman sama da miliyan 1 a cikin annoba mafi girma a tarihi.
Duk wannan dai na faruwa ne duk da cewa gwamnatin Amurka ta taka rawar gani a yakin da aka shafe watanni 33 ana gwabzawa Yemen, inda aka sayar da shi. biliyoyin daloli na makamai zuwa kasar Saudiyya, suna kara mai da jiragen yakin Saudiyyar yayin da suke ci gaba da kai hare-hare a yankunan fararen hula da kuma samar da kayayyaki leken asiri da taimakon soja ga rundunar sojin saman Saudiyya.
Tare da ƙaramin ɗaukar hoto na kamfani daga MSNBC ko kuma a wani waje, Amurka - karkashin shugabannin biyu Barack Obama da Donald Trump - sun ba da goyon baya ga Saudi Arabiya yayin da take kakaba wa Yemen takunkumi mai tsauri, ta hanyar diflomasiyya tana ba da kariya ga mulkin kama-karya na yankin Gulf daga kowane irin hukunci yayin da ta jefa miliyoyin fararen hula na Yemen cikin jama'a. yunwa da tura kasa mafi talauci a Gabas ta Tsakiya zuwa ga yunwa.
1 An ambaci hare-haren da jiragen saman Saudiyya suka kai; Babu Ambaton Kwalara
FAIR ta gudanar da cikakken bincike MSNBCwatsa shirye-shiryen da aka ajiye akan Nexis labaran labarai. (Alkaluman da ke cikin wannan rahoton an samo su ne daga Nexis.)
A shekarar 2017, MSNBC ya gudanar da watsa shirye-shirye guda 1,385 da suka ambaci "Rasha," "Rasha" ko "Rashawa." Amma duk da haka kawai 82 watsa shirye-shirye sun yi amfani da kalmomin "Yemen," "Yemen" ko "Yemenis" a cikin dukan shekara.
Bugu da ƙari, yawancin 82 MSNBC watsa shirye-shiryen da aka ambata Yemen sun yi hakan sau ɗaya kawai kuma suna wucewa, galibi a matsayin ƙasa ɗaya a cikin jerin ƙasashe masu tsayi da takunkumin Shugaba Trump ya yi niyya.
Daga cikin waɗannan watsa shirye-shiryen 82 a cikin 2017, akwai guda ɗaya kawai MSNBC sashen labarai da ya kebance musamman kan yakin Saudiyya da Amurka ke marawa baya a Yemen.
A ranar 2 ga Yuli, hanyar sadarwar ta gudanar da wani yanki akan Ari Melber's The Point (7/2/17) mai taken "Sanadin makamai na Saudiyya na iya kara tsananta rikicin Yemen." Watsa shirye-shiryen na tsawon mintuna uku ya kunshi muhimman batutuwan da suka shafi goyon bayan Amurka ga mummunan yakin Saudiyya a Yemen.
Amma duk da haka wannan ɓangaren bayanin ya tsaya shi kaɗai a cikin dukan shekara. Binciken Nexis database da Yemen tag on MSNBCShafin yanar gizon ya nuna cewa, a cikin kimanin watanni shida bayan wannan watsa shirye-shiryen ranar 2 ga Yuli, cibiyar sadarwar ba ta ba da wani bangare ba musamman ga yakin Yemen.
A search na MSNBC watsa shirye-shirye kuma ya nuna cewa, yayin da hanyar sadarwa a wasu lokuta a cikin wannan watsa shirye-shirye ta ambaci duka Yemen da hare-haren jiragen sama, ba - ban da bangaren Ari Melber - ya yarda da kasancewar hare-haren jiragen saman kawancen Amurka / Saudiyya. on Yemen.
Mafi kusancin hanyar sadarwar in ba haka ba ya zo yana cikin sashin Maris 31, 2017 akan Kalma ta ƙarshe Tare da Lawrence O'Donnell, wanda Joy Reid ya ce, "Kuma kamar yadda New York Times Rahotanni sun ce Amurka ta kaddamar da hare-hare a Yemen a wannan watan fiye da na shekarar da ta gabata. Amma Reid yana magana ne akan a New York Times rahoto (3/29/17) akan hare-haren da Amurka ta kai kan kungiyar Al Qaeda a yankin Larabawa (wanda ya kai da dama), ba wai hare-haren da kawancen Amurka/Saudiyya suka kai kan yankin da Houthi ke iko da Yemen ba (wanda ya kai dubbai).
Duk da yake yin watsi da hare-haren jiragen yakin kawancen Amurka/Saudiyya da kuma dubban fararen hula da suka kashe, duk da haka, MSNBC ya bayar da rahoton hare-haren Houthi a kan jiragen ruwan yakin Saudiyya na gabar tekun Yemen. A cikin nuninsa MTP Daily(2/1/17), Chuck Todd da kyau ya rufe gaba da nuna adawa da Iran na Trump da mai ba da shawara kan Tsaron kasa Michael Flynn. Shi yaudara Ya yi magana game da Houthis a matsayin wakilai na Iran kuma ya bai wa tsohon jami'in diflomasiyyar Amurka Nicholas Burns wani dandali don da'awar, "Iran ta kasance mai tayar da hankali a Gabas ta Tsakiya." A ranakun 1 da 2 ga watan Fabrairu kuma Chris Hayes ya bayar da rahoto kan harin na Houthi.
MSNBC ya yi sha'awar bayyana hare-haren da makiya jami'an Amurka ke kaiwa, amma duk da haka dubun dubatar jiragen sama da Saudiyya ta kaddamar a Yemen-da makamai, man fetur da kuma leken asiri daga Amurka da Birtaniya- kusan gaba daya cibiyar sadarwa ta sa ba a iya gani.
Shekaru da dama da kawancen Amurka/Saudiyya na kai hare-haren bama-bamai da killace kasar Yaman sun durkusar da tsarin kiwon lafiyar matalautan kasar, lamarin da ya jefa ta cikin annobar kwalara da ta kashe dubban mutane tare da karya dukkan bayanan da aka samu a baya. MSNBC bai taba yarda da wannan bala'in ba ko dai, bisa ga binciken Nexis da Gidan yanar gizon MSNBC. Cholera kawai aka ambata akan MSBNC a cikin 2017 a cikin mahallin Haiti, ba Yemen ba.
Sha'awar kawai Lokacin da Amurkawa suka mutu
Duk da yake MSNBC Ba ta damu da ambaton cutar kwalara a Yemen ba, ta nuna sha'awarta sosai game da wani mummunan hari da sojojin ruwa na Navy SEAL da Shugaba Donald Trump ya amince da su a kasar, wanda ya yi sanadin mutuwar wani Ba'amurke. Musamman farkon shekara, hanyar sadarwar ta sadaukar da ɗaukar hoto mai mahimmanci ga 29 ga Janairu, wanda ya kashe fararen hular Yemen da dama da kuma sojan Amurka daya.
Binciken bayanan Nexis yana nuna hakan MSNBC ya ambaci harin da Amurka ta amince da Trump a Yemen a cikin sassan 36 daban-daban a cikin 2017. Dukkanin manyan nunin cibiyar sadarwa sun samar da sassan da suka mayar da hankali kan harin: MTP Daily a ranar 31 ga Janairu da 1 ga Maris; Duk A a ranar Fabrairu 2, Fabrairu 8 da Maris 1; Don Record ranar 6 ga Fabrairu; Kalmar Karshe Fabrairu 6, 8 da 27; Hardball ranar 1 ga Maris; da kuma Rachel Maddow Show a ranar 2 ga Fabrairu, 3 ga Fabrairu, 23 ga Fabrairu da 6 ga Maris.
Amma bayan wannan farmakin ya bar labarin, haka ita ma kasar Yemen. Binciken Nexis da alamar Yemen akan gidan yanar gizon MSBNC ya nuna cewa, ban da ɓangaren Yuli na Ari Melber, sabon sashi. MSNBC An sadaukar da musamman ga Yemen a cikin 2017 shine Rachel Maddow ShowRahoton ranar 6 ga Maris kan harin SEAL.
Sakon da aka isar a bayyane yake: ga babbar kafar yada labaran Amurka mai sassaucin ra'ayi, Yemen tana da mahimmanci idan Amurkawa ne suka mutu - ba lokacin da ake kashe dubban Yemeniyawa ba, Saudi Arabiya ta yi ruwan bama-bamai kullum, da makaman Amurka, man fetur da leken asiri; ba lokacin da miliyoyin 'yan Yemen ke gab da mutuwa sakamakon yunwa ba yayin da kawancen Amurka/Saudiyya ke amfani da yunwa a matsayin makami.
Ƙarshen cewa rayukan Amurkawa ne kawai labarai ya tabbatar da cewa Trump ya sake ƙaddamar da wani bala'i hari a Yemen a ranar 23 ga Mayu, inda aka sake kashe fararen hular Yemen da dama. Amma sojojin Amurka ba su mutu a wannan farmakin ba, don haka MSNBC ba shi da sha'awa. Cibiyar sadarwa ba ta sadaukar da kai ga wannan harin na Yaman da aka kai wa hari na biyu ba.
Tsananin Hankali ga Rasha
Bisa ga binciken Nexis na watsa shirye-shiryen cibiyar sadarwa daga Janairu 1 zuwa Yuli 2, 2017, an ambaci "Yemen," "Yemen" ko "Yemenis" a cikin 68. MSNBC sassan—kusan dukkaninsu na da alaka da harin SEAL ko kuma jerin kasashen da Trump ya haramtawa musulmi hari.
A cikin kimanin watanni shida daga 3 ga Yuli zuwa ƙarshen Disamba, kalmomin "Yemen," "Yemen" ko "Yemenis" an furta su ne kawai a sassa 14. A yawancin waɗannan sassan, an ambaci Yemen sau ɗaya kawai a wucewa.
A cikin wannan tsawon kwanaki 181 wanda MSNBC ba shi da wani yanki da aka keɓe musamman ga Yemen, kalmomin "Rasha," "Rasha" ko "Rasha" an ambaci su a cikin watsa shirye-shiryen 693 masu ban mamaki.
Wannan shine, a cikin rabin karshen 2017. MSNBC an watsa sau 49.5 fiye—ko kashi 4,950 cikin ɗari—ɓangarorin da suka yi magana game da Rasha fiye da sassan da ke magana kan Yemen.
Hasali ma, a cikin kwanaki hudu daga 26 ga Disamba zuwa 29 ga Disamba kadai. MSNBC ya ce "Rasha," "Rashanci" ko "Rashawa" kusan sau 400 a cikin watsa shirye-shirye daban-daban guda 23, akan dukkan manyan nunin hanyar sadarwa, gami da Hardball, Duk A, Rachel Maddow, Kalmar Karshe, Haɗu da Jaridar Daily da kuma The Beat.
Washegari bayan Kirsimati an ba da labarin harin da aka yi wa Rasha. A ranar 26 ga Disamba, kalmomin "Rasha", "Rasha" ko "Rashanci" an furta sau 156 a cikin watsa shirye-shirye daga 5 pm EST zuwa 11 pm. Mai zuwa shine raguwar adadin ambaton Rasha:
- sau 33 akan MTP Daily a 5 am
- sau 6 akan The Beat a 6 am
- sau 30 akan Hardball a 7 am
- sau 38 akan Duk A a 8 am
- 40 sau Rachel Maddow a 9 am
- sau 9 akan Kalmar Karshe (tare da cikon Ari Melber don O'Donnell) da ƙarfe 10 na yamma
A wannan rana, MSNBC da aka ambata Rasha kusan sau biyu a cikin sa'o'i shida na ɗaukar hoto fiye da yadda aka ambata Yemen a cikin duk 2017.
Duk da yake MSNBC Ba shi da wani yanki da aka keɓe musamman ga yaƙin Yemen in ban da shirye-shiryen Ari Melber na Yuli kawai, ana ambaton ƙasar nan da nan.
Chris Hayes ya yarda a taƙaice Yemen ƴan lokuta, ko da yake bai keɓe wani yanki ba. A cikin watsa shirye-shiryen ranar 23 ga Mayu Duk AMai masaukin baki ya yi nuni da cewa, "Mun kasance muna ba wa Saudiyya makamai da goyon baya yayin da suke ci gaba da yaki da 'yan tawayen Shi'a, Houthis a Yemen." Baya ga gaskiyar cewa yakin da ake yi wa Saudiyya/Iran a yakin Yemen wanda a fili Hayes ya yi ishara da shi, magana ce mai rudar da gwamnatin Amurka da hukumomin leken asiri suka rura wutar da kafafen yada labarai na kamfanoni cikin biyayya ((FAIR.org, 7/25/17), Hayes har yanzu bai amince da hare-haren da kawancen Amurka/Saudiyya ke kaiwa ba wanda ya yi sanadin mutuwar dubban fararen hula.
A cikin wata hira Yuni 29 on Duk A, 'Yar fafutukar Ba'amurke Linda Sarsour ta kuma yi magana a madadin "'yan gudun hijirar Yemen da ke fama da yakin basasa da muke ba da tallafi." Hayes ya kara da cewa, "Waɗanda ke fama da yunwa don mutuwa, saboda da gaske muna ba da tallafin Saudis don ci gaba da mamaye su." Wannan shi ne lokacin da ba kasafai a ciki ba MSBNC ya amince da killace kasar Yemen da Saudiyya ta yi—amma kuma, ba a yi magana kan hare-haren da Saudiyya ke marawa Amurka baya ba, wanda ya yi sanadin mutuwar dubban ‘yan kasar Yemen.
A ranar 5 ga watan Yuli, Chris Hayes ya yi magana ta hanyar amfani da kalamai masu tsauri, yana mai cewa, "Tun lokacin da shugaban kasar ya hau kan karagar mulki, an zaburar da shugaban kasar ya dauki bangaren Saudiyya a rikicin da ke tsakaninsa da Yemen." Duban bayan gaskiyar cewa "musa-mutumi" wani mummunan ra'ayi ne na mummunan yakin da ya kai ga mutuwar dubban dubban mutane, Hayes ya kasa nuna cewa tsohon shugaban kasar Barack Obama, kamar Trump, ya goyi bayan Saudi Arabia yayin da ta jefa bama-bamai da kuma kewaye. Yemen.
Rachel Maddow ta kuma yi tsokaci a takaice game da harin da Amurka ta kai a Yemen a watan Janairu a cikin shirye-shiryenta a ranakun 7 da 24 ga Afrilu. Haka ma Hayes ta yi a ranar 16 ga Oktoba.
On MTP Daily a ranar 6 ga Disamba, Chuck Todd ma yayi magana game da Yemen a wucewa, yana lura:
Yana da ban sha'awa, Tom, cewa da alama shugaban yana da waɗannan kawayen ƙasashen Gulf. Yana ba su m carte blanche kadan a kan abin da suke yi a Yemen, shi ne irin kallon sauran hanya.
Amma shi ke nan. Baya ga bangaren Ari Melber na Yuli na daya, a cikin 2017 MSNBC ba shi da wani labari game da yakin da Amurka ke marawa baya wanda ya haifar da bala'in jin kai mafi girma a duniya.
Abin mamaki shi ne MSNBC a fili yana sukar Donald Trump sosai, amma duk da haka ya wuce daya daga cikin mafi kyawun damar yin Allah wadai da manufofinsa. Maimakon rufe wasu munanan ayyukan Trump, mafi munin tashin hankali — ayyukansa na yaƙin da ya yi sanadin mutuwar dubban fararen hula—MSNBC ya yi watsi da mutanen Yemen da Trump ya shafa.
Wataƙila wannan saboda shi ne shugaban Demokraɗiyya-Barack Obama, wanda ya fi so MSNBC-wanda ya fara kula da yakin Yemen kusan shekaru biyu kafin Trump ya shiga ofis. Amma MSNBCkishiyar dama, Fox News, ya sake nuna cewa ba shi da wata matsala ta kai hari ga 'yan Democrat don yin abin da 'yan Republican suka yi a gabansu.
Kuna iya aika sako zuwa Rachel Maddow a Rachel@msnbc.com (ko ta hanyar Twitter: @ Maddow). Ana iya samun Chris Hayes ta hanyar Twitter: @ChrisLHayes. Da fatan za a tuna cewa sadarwar mutuntawa ita ce mafi inganci.
