By David Swanson, World BEYOND War, Janairu 5, 2022
World BEYOND War yana dogon tallafi kokarin don dakatar hayaniya, gurɓatar da jiragen saman Navy a kan wuraren shakatawa na jihohi a jihar Washington.
Yanzu a Rahoton Babban alkalin alkalan Amurka J. Richard Creatura ya samu Seattle Times ginin edita ba da shawara wani irin "concompromise."
Wasu zažužžukan zažužžukan:
Anan, duk da rikodin gudanarwa na gargantuan, wanda ke rufe kusan shafuka 200,000 na karatu, rahotanni, sharhi, da makamantansu, Rundunar Sojan Ruwa ta zaɓi hanyoyin tantance bayanan da ke goyan bayan burinta na haɓaka ayyukan Growler. Sojojin ruwa sun yi hakan ne da kashe jama’a da muhalli, inda suka rufe ido kan bayanan da ba za su goyi bayan wannan sakamakon da aka yi niyya ba. Ko kuma, don aron kalmomin sanannen manazarcin wasanni Vin Scully, Sojojin ruwa sun bayyana sun yi amfani da wasu ƙididdiga "kamar bugu yana amfani da fitilar fitila: don tallafi, ba haske ba."
Lokacin da ake ba da rahoto game da tasirin muhalli na hayakin mai na Growler, Rundunar Sojan Ruwa ta yi kasa a gwiwa wajen ba da rahoton hakikanin adadin hayakin mai na Growler kuma ta kasa bayyana cewa bai hada da hayakin jiragen sama sama da ƙafa 3,000 ba. Ko da bayan samun tsokaci kan batun, rundunar sojojin ruwan ta kasa bayyana rahotan da ba ta kai ga yin watsi da batun ba tare da yin watsi da batun.
Dangane da tasirin wannan ƙarin aiki a kan karatun yara, Rundunar Sojan Ruwa ta amince da bincike da yawa waɗanda suka kammala cewa hayaniyar jirgin za ta yi tasiri sosai a kan koyo amma sai ta yanke shawarar cewa saboda ba za a iya ƙididdige ainihin yadda ƙarin ayyukan zai kawo cikas ga karatun yara ba. bincike ya zama dole.
Dangane da tasirin ƙarar hayaniyar jet akan nau'ikan tsuntsaye daban-daban, sojojin ruwa sun sha bayyana cewa ƙarar hayaniya za ta yi tasiri na musamman kan nau'in tsuntsayen da ke yankin da abin ya shafa amma sai suka kasa gudanar da bincike na musamman na nau'in don sanin ko wasu nau'ikan. zai fi shafa fiye da sauran. Madadin haka, Rundunar Sojan Ruwa kawai ta yanke shawarar cewa wasu nau'ikan ba su da lahani sannan kuma aka fitar da su cewa duk sauran nau'ikan ba za su shafa ba, ko dai.
Dangane da kimanta hanyoyin da suka dace don fadada Growler a NASWI, wanda ake buƙatar Navy ya yi, Rundunar Sojan Ruwa ta ƙi ɗaukar ayyukan Growler zuwa El Centro, California daga hannu, tare da yanke shawarar cewa irin wannan matakin zai yi tsada da yawa kuma motsa aikin. zuwa wannan wurin zai sami nasa ƙalubalen muhalli. Dalilin da ya sa Rundunar Sojan Ruwa ta kasance mai sabani kuma mai kima kuma baya samar da ingantaccen tushe don ƙin madadin El Centro.
A bisa wadannan dalilai, Kotun ta bayar da shawarar cewa kotun gunduma ta gano FEIS din ya sabawa NEPA sannan ta bayar da duk wasu hukunce-hukuncen yanke hukunci a wani bangare sannan ta musanta su. Dkts. 87, 88, 92. Har ila yau, Kotun ta ba da izini ga masu gabatar da kara don gabatar da ƙarin shaidar rikodin don magance wasu batutuwa. Dkt. 85. Idan har Kotun Gundumar ta bi wannan shawarar, ya kamata ta ba da umarnin ƙarin bayani game da maganin da ya dace na cin zarafin NEPA da aka bayyana a nan.
Shin wannan yana kama da wani dan majalisa na gida da kuma babban kamfanin samar da makamai, Adam Smith ya kamata ya shiga ya warware batutuwan, kamar yadda Seattle Times yana ba da shawara? Ko kuma ya zama kamar wata dama ce da ba kasafai ba ne sa’ad da wani memba na hukumar shari’a ta Amirka ya ƙi yin sujada a gaban Allah na Yaƙi kuma ya ce “Ba shi da tufafi!” Shin wannan ba zai zama wata dama ce ga kotuna su tabbatar da haƙƙin ɗan adam a kan wata cibiya da ke kai hare-haren bama-bamai a wurare masu nisa da sunan haƙƙin ɗan adam?
Jaridar gida, da South Whidbey Record, so sosai jiragen sama masu lalata kunne, yara-ƙwakwalwa don ci gaba da jin daɗin 'yanci, amma ɗan gwagwarmaya Tom Ewell ya aika musu da wannan wasiƙar da ba ta buga ba:
Gabaɗaya na yarda da editan News-Times na 12/15, “Ƙarar da Sojojin Ruwa ba ƙuri'ar raba gardama kan Masu Noma ba." Amma kuma ba wai kawai kuri'ar raba gardama ce kan lura da gazawar tasirin tasirin da karar ke magana akai ba. Mafi mahimmancin binciken da aka samu a cikin rahoton majistare shine don tallafawa abin da masu sukar Growlers ke ƙoƙarin faɗi shekaru da yawa yanzu: Rundunar Sojan Ruwa kawai tana jin damar yanke shawarar kanta, dangane da bayanan son kai da bayanai, tare da daidaito. rashin kula da lafiya, aminci, da walwala na mutanen da hayaniyar Growler ke tasiri. Rahoton majistare a karshe ya ambaci girman kai da dabarun rashin da’a da sojojin ruwa suka yi amfani da su a tarihi wajen gujewa tare da musanta barnar da hayaniyar da ta wuce gona da iri. Kamar yadda rahoton ya ce, bayan dubban shafuka da nazari kan illolin da ba su dace ba kan kiwon lafiya, yara, tattalin arziki, da muhalli, rundunar sojojin ruwa ta kammala duk wannan ba kome ba ne idan bai dace da bukatunsu ba. Kuma don jaddada girman kai game da cutar da surutu, sun ba da shawarar yin hakan ta hanyar ƙara wasu sabbin jiragen sama XNUMX a cikin rundunarsu wanda hakan zai ƙara illa ga hayaniyar.
Batun tsakiya ya dade da rashin jituwa game da yadda za a auna hayaniyar da ke kan layi. Daidai da alkali na yin Allah wadai da haƙƙin da aka ɗauka na sojojin ruwa na yin amfani da bayanan da ke biyan bukatunsu kawai, Rundunar Sojan ruwa ta ci gaba da ɗauka cewa suna da ma'aunin hayaniya ɗaya kawai da za su gane. Suna yin tsayin daka don yin watsi da tasirin hayaniyar da mutane ke fuskanta kai tsaye a ƙarƙashin jiragen sama - sau da yawa na sa'o'i a lokaci guda - kuma a maimakon haka suna fitar da bayanan da ba su da kyau ta hanyar rarraba su ta kwanakin shekara. Ta haka za su iya kafa ma'aunin fifikon su wanda ya yi nisa da ainihin amo a kan wurin. Idan aka yi la’akari da kimar fuska, mutum zai iya yanke cewa manufar auna hayaniyar Navy ba bautar kai kaɗai ce ba amma, a gaskiya, rashin mutunci ne.
12/18 So. Whidbey Record ta sake buga editan daga Everett Herald wanda ke nuna rahoton majistare dama ce ta tattaunawa. Bayan shekaru da yawa na bijirewa da ƙin yarda daga Navy har ma da la'akari da muryoyin waɗanda Growlers suka shafa ba tare da tilasta musu yin hakan ba - har ma da watsi da bayanan da aka ƙirƙira - Na damu da dalilin da yasa yanzu mutane za su yi tsammani kuma su amince da Navy. don shiga cikin tattaunawar gaskiya.
