Gaskiya: Babu ɗaya daga cikin ƙa'idodin "ka'idar yaƙi mai adalci" da ke riƙe da wannan tsari na zamani, kuma buƙatarsa ta cewa a yi amfani da yaƙi a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe ba zai yiwu ba a wannan zamani da madadin marasa zaman lafiya ke tabbatar da cewa ba su da iyaka.
Ana ɗaukaka ra'ayin cewa yaƙe-yaƙe wani lokaci, daga aƙalla gefe ɗaya, a matsayin "daidai" a cikin al'adun Yamma ta hanyar ka'idar yaƙi kawai, wani tsari na tsoffin ƙa'idodi da na mulkin mallaka waɗanda ba sa tsayawa kan bincike.
Da ace yaƙi ya cika dukkan sharuɗɗan ka'idar yaƙi kawai, domin a zahiri ya zama adalci, da kuma dole ne ya fi duk lalacewar da aka yi ta hanyar ci gaba da kafa yaƙi. Ba zai zama da amfani ba a ƙarshe a sami yaƙi mai adalci idan shirye-shiryen yaƙe-yaƙe da duk yaƙe-yaƙe marasa adalci da waɗannan shirye-shiryen suka haifar sun yi barna fiye da yaƙin adalci ya yi kyau. Tsarin yaƙi, ba shakka, yana haifar da haɗarin afkuwar makaman nukiliya. Shi ne babban dalilin sauyin yanayi. Shi ne babban mai lalata muhalli. Yana yin barna mafi yawa ta hanyar karkatar da kuɗi daga buƙatun ɗan adam da muhalli fiye da ta hanyar tashin hankalinsa. Shi ne kawai wurin da za a iya samun isasshen kuɗi don yin ƙoƙari mai zurfi don canzawa zuwa ayyukan da za su dore. Babban dalilin rushewar 'yancin jama'a ne, kuma babban mai haifar da tashin hankali da ƙiyayya da son kai a cikin al'adun da ke kewaye. Soja yana sanya sojojin 'yan sanda na gida, da kuma tunani. Yaƙi mai adalci zai fi nauyi fiye da yaƙi mai adalci.
Amma babu yaƙi mai adalci da zai yiwu. Wasu sharuɗɗan ka'idar yaƙi kawai maganganun magana ne kawai, ba za a iya auna su kwata-kwata ba, don haka ba za a iya cimma su da ma'ana ba. Waɗannan sun haɗa da "niyya mai kyau," "dalili kawai," da "daidaitawa." Wasu ba dalilai ne na ɗabi'a ba kwata-kwata. Waɗannan sun haɗa da "an bayyana a bainar jama'a" da "an yi su ta hanyar halaltacciyar hukuma mai iko." Duk da haka wasu ba za a iya cimma wani yaƙi ba. Waɗannan sun haɗa da "makomar ƙarshe," "hasashe mai kyau na nasara," "marasa yaƙi ba su da kariya daga hari," "sojojin abokan gaba da ake girmamawa a matsayin mutane," da "fursunoni na yaƙi da aka yi musu kamar waɗanda ba sa yaƙi." An tattauna kowace ma'auni a cikin littafin David Swanson. Yakin Ba Yayi Kawai. Bari mu tattauna a nan ɗaya kawai, mafi shahara: "mafita ta ƙarshe," wanda aka ɗauko daga wannan littafin.
Last Dabbab
Hakika mataki ne mai kyau idan al'ada ta koma daga sha'awar Theodore Roosevelt na sabon yaƙi don amfanin yaƙi, zuwa ga yin riya cewa kowace yaƙi ita ce kuma dole ne ta zama mafita ta ƙarshe. Wannan riya ta gama gari yanzu, har jama'ar Amurka kawai suke ɗauka ba tare da an gaya musu ba. Wani bincike na ilimi kwanan nan ya gano cewa jama'ar Amurka sun yi imanin cewa duk lokacin da gwamnatin Amurka ta gabatar da yaƙi, ta riga ta gama da duk wasu damammaki. Lokacin da aka tambayi wani rukuni na samfurin ko sun goyi bayan wani yaƙi, kuma aka tambayi wani rukuni na biyu ko sun goyi bayan wannan yaƙin bayan an gaya musu cewa duk wasu zaɓuɓɓuka ba su da kyau, kuma aka tambayi wani rukuni na uku ko sun goyi bayan wannan yaƙin duk da cewa akwai wasu zaɓuɓɓuka masu kyau, ƙungiyoyi biyu na farko sun yi rijistar matakin tallafi iri ɗaya, yayin da goyon bayan yaƙi ya ragu sosai a cikin rukuni na uku. Wannan ya sa masu binciken suka yanke shawarar cewa idan ba a ambaci wasu zaɓuɓɓuka ba, mutane ba sa tsammanin suna wanzuwa - maimakon haka, mutane suna tsammanin an riga an gwada su.[i]
An shafe shekaru da dama ana ta ƙoƙarin fara yaƙi da Iran. Wasu daga cikin manyan matsin lamba sun zo ne a shekarar 2007 da 2015. Da ace an fara wannan yaƙin a kowane lokaci, babu shakka za a bayyana shi a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe, duk da cewa an zaɓi zaɓin kada a fara wannan yaƙin sau da yawa. A shekarar 2013, Shugaban Amurka ya gaya mana game da buƙatar gaggawa ta "mafita ta ƙarshe" don ƙaddamar da babban yaƙin bama-bamai a kan Siriya. Sannan ya juya shawararsa, galibi saboda adawar jama'a ga hakan. Ya zama zaɓin ba An kuma samu damar kai hare-haren bam a Siriya.
Ka yi tunanin wani mashayi wanda ya yi nasarar shan giya mai yawa kowace dare kuma wanda kowace safiya ya rantse cewa shan wiski shine mafita ta ƙarshe, ba shi da zaɓi kwata-kwata. Babu shakka, mai shan wiski zai iya kare kansa, ko da yake dole ne a yi hakan a banza. A gaskiya, janye giya wani lokacin na iya haifar da farfadiya ko mutuwa. Amma shin janyewar yaƙi zai iya yin hakan? Ka yi tunanin duniyar da kowa ya yarda da kowane mai shan wiski, har da mai shan giyar yaƙi, kuma ya ce wa juna "Ba shi da wani zaɓi. Ya gwada komai." Ba haka ba ne mai yiwuwa, ko? Kusan ba za a iya tsammani ba, a gaskiya. Amma duk da haka:
Ana kyautata zaton cewa Amurka tana yaƙi a Siriya a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe, duk da cewa:
- Amurka ta shafe shekaru tana lalata yunkurin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya na samar da zaman lafiya a Siriya.[ii]
- Amurka ta yi watsi da wani kudiri na Rasha na samar da zaman lafiya a Siriya a shekarar 2012.[iii]
- Kuma lokacin da Amurka ta yi ikirarin cewa ana buƙatar wani hari na bama-bamai nan take a matsayin "mafaka ta ƙarshe" a cikin 2013 amma jama'ar Amurka sun yi adawa sosai, an bi wasu hanyoyin.
A shekarar 2015, 'yan Majalisar Dokokin Amurka da dama sun yi jayayya cewa yarjejeniyar nukiliya da Iran ta bukaci a yi watsi da ita, kuma an kai wa Iran hari a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe. Ba a ambaci tayin da Iran ta yi a shekarar 2003 na yin shawarwari kan shirin nukiliyarta ba, tayin da Amurka ta yi watsi da shi cikin sauri.
Ana kyautata zaton cewa Amurka na kashe mutane da jiragen sama marasa matuki a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe, duk da cewa a cikin 'yan tsirarun lokuta da Amurka ta san sunayen mutanen da take niyya, da yawa (kuma wataƙila duka) daga cikinsu iya kasancewa kamawa cikin sauƙi.[iv]
An yi imanin cewa Amurka ta kashe Osama bin Laden a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe, har sai da waɗanda abin ya shafa suka yarda cewa manufar "kisa ko kamawa" ba ta haɗa da wani zaɓi na kamawa (kamawa) ba kuma cewa bin Laden bai da makami lokacin da aka kashe shi.[v]
An yi imanin cewa Amurka ta kai hari kan Libya a shekarar 2011, ta hambarar da gwamnatinta, kuma ta rura wutar rikicin yankin a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe, duk da cewa a watan Maris na 2011 Tarayyar Afirka tana da shirin zaman lafiya a Libya amma NATO ta hana ta, ta hanyar ƙirƙirar "yankin da ba ya tashi da kuma fara kai hare-hare bama-bamai," don yin tafiya zuwa Libya don tattaunawa kan hakan. A watan Afrilu, Tarayyar Afirka ta sami damar tattauna shirinta da shugaban Libya Muammar Gaddafi, kuma ya bayyana amincewarsa.[vi] NATO ta sami izinin Majalisar Dinkin Duniya don kare 'yan Libya da ake zargin suna cikin haɗari, amma ba ta da izinin ci gaba da jefa bama-bamai a ƙasar ko kuma kifar da gwamnati.
Kusan duk wanda ke aiki, kuma yana son ci gaba da aiki a kansa, wata babbar kafar yada labarai ta Amurka ta ce Amurka ta kai wa Iraki hari a shekarar 2003 a matsayin mafita ta ƙarshe ko wani abu da aka yi niyya, ko wani abu makamancin haka, duk da cewa:
- Shugaban Amurka yana ta shirya makircin cockamamie don fara yaƙi.[vii]
- Gwamnatin Iraki ta tuntubi Vincent Cannistraro na CIA da tayin barin sojojin Amurka su binciki dukkan kasar.[viii]
- Gwamnatin Iraki ta yi tayin gudanar da zaɓen da aka sanya ido a kai a duniya cikin shekaru biyu.[ix]
- Gwamnatin Iraki ta yi wa Richard Perle, jami'in Bush tayin bude dukkan kasar ga masu bincike, da kuma mika wanda ake zargi da kai harin bam a Cibiyar Kasuwanci ta Duniya ta 1993, don taimakawa wajen yaki da ta'addanci, da kuma fifita kamfanonin mai na Amurka.[X]
- Shugaban na Iraki ya bayar da hujjar cewa shugaban Amurka ya bai wa shugaban Spain izinin barin Iraki idan zai iya ajiye dala biliyan 1.[xi]
- Amurka koyaushe tana da zaɓin kada ta sake fara wani yaƙi.
Kowa ya yi zaton cewa Amurka ta mamaye Afghanistan a shekara ta 2001 kuma ta ci gaba da zama a can tun daga lokacin a matsayin jerin "wuraren hutu na ƙarshe," duk da cewa Taliban ta yi ta miƙa bin Laden ga wata ƙasa ta uku don a yi mata shari'a, amma al Qaeda ba ta da wani tasiri a Afghanistan a mafi yawan lokacin yaƙin, kuma janyewa zaɓi ne a kowane lokaci.[xii]
Mutane da yawa sun dage cewa Amurka ta shiga yaƙi da Iraki a tsakanin 1990-1991 a matsayin "makomar ƙarshe," duk da cewa gwamnatin Iraki ta yarda ta yi shawarwari kan janyewa daga Kuwait ba tare da yaƙi ba, kuma daga ƙarshe ta miƙa tayin janyewa daga Kuwait cikin makonni uku ba tare da sharaɗi ba. Sarkin Jordan, Paparoma, Shugaban Faransa, Shugaban Tarayyar Soviet, da sauransu da yawa sun yi kira da a yi sulhu cikin lumana, amma Fadar White House ta dage kan "makomar ƙarshe."[xiii]
Ko da an yi watsi da ayyukan gama gari da ke ƙara ƙiyayya, samar da makamai, da kuma ƙarfafa gwamnatocin soji, da kuma tattaunawar karya da aka yi niyya don sauƙaƙe maimakon guje wa yaƙi, tarihin yaƙin Amurka za a iya gano shi a cikin ƙarni da yawa a matsayin labarin jerin damarmaki marasa iyaka don zaman lafiya da aka kauce masa a hankali ko ta halin kaka.
Mexico ta yarda ta yi shawarwari kan sayar da yankin arewacinta, amma Amurka ta so ta dauki matakin kisan gilla. Spain ta so batun Maine don shiga sulhu na ƙasashen duniya, amma Amurka tana son yaƙi da daular. Tarayyar Soviet ta gabatar da shawarwarin zaman lafiya kafin Yaƙin Koriya. Amurka ta lalata shawarwarin zaman lafiya na Vietnam daga Vietnam, Soviets, da Faransa, tana mai dagewa kan "mafita ta ƙarshe" fiye da kowane zaɓi, tun daga ranar da lamarin Tekun Tonkin ya tilasta yaƙi duk da cewa ba a taɓa faruwa ba.[xiv]
Idan ka duba yaƙe-yaƙe da yawa, za ka ga kusan irin waɗannan abubuwan da aka yi amfani da su a wani lokaci a matsayin uzuri na yaƙi, a wani lokacin kuma ba su da irin wannan. Shugaba George W. Bush ya ba wa Firayim Ministan Burtaniya Tony Blair shawara cewa samun jirgin sama na U2 zai iya sa su shiga yaƙin da suke so.[xv] Duk da haka lokacin da Tarayyar Soviet ta harbo jirgin sama na U2, Shugaba Dwight Eisenhower bai fara yaƙi ba.
Eh, eh, eh, mutum zai iya amsawa, ɗaruruwan yaƙe-yaƙe na gaske da marasa adalci ba mafita ta ƙarshe ba ce, duk da cewa magoya bayansu suna da'awar wannan matsayin a gare su. Amma Yaƙin Just na ka'ida zai zama mafita ta ƙarshe. Shin zai yi? Shin babu wani zaɓi da ya yi daidai da ɗabi'a ko mafi girma? Allman da Winright sun yi ambaton Paparoma John Paul II kan "wajibi ne a kwance damarar wannan mai zalunci idan duk wasu hanyoyi sun tabbatar da rashin inganci." Amma shin "kwace makamai" daidai yake da "bam ko mamaye"? Mun ga an ƙaddamar da yaƙe-yaƙe ana zargin an ƙaddamar da su ne don kwance damarar yaƙi, kuma sakamakon ya fi makamai fiye da da. Yaya game da? daina hannu a matsayin wata hanya mai yiwuwa ta kwance damarar makamai? Yaya batun takunkumin hana makamai na ƙasa da ƙasa? Yaya batun tattalin arziki da sauran abubuwan ƙarfafa gwiwa na kwance damarar makamai?
Babu lokacin da jefa bam a Ruwanda zai zama "makomar ƙarshe ta ɗabi'a." Akwai lokacin da 'yan sanda masu ɗauke da makamai za su iya taimakawa, ko kuma katse siginar rediyo da ake amfani da ita don haifar da kashe-kashe zai iya taimakawa. Akwai lokutan da masu aikin wanzar da zaman lafiya marasa makamai za su taimaka. Akwai lokacin da neman ɗaukar alhakin kisan shugaban ƙasa zai taimaka. Akwai shekaru uku kafin hakan lokacin da guje wa ɗaukar makamai da kuma ba da kuɗaɗen masu kisan gilla a Uganda zai taimaka.
Da'awar "makomar ƙarshe" yawanci tana da rauni sosai idan mutum ya yi tunanin komawa baya a lokacin da rikicin ya faru, amma kuma ta yi rauni sosai idan mutum ya yi tunanin komawa baya kaɗan. Mutane da yawa suna ƙoƙarin tabbatar da Yaƙin Duniya na Biyu fiye da Yaƙin Duniya na Ɗaya, duk da cewa ɗayan ba zai taɓa faruwa ba tare da ɗayan ko kuma ba tare da wauta ba na kawo ƙarshensa, wanda ya sa masu kallo da yawa a lokacin suka yi hasashen Yaƙin Duniya na Biyu da daidaito. Idan kai hari kan ISIS a Iraki yanzu wata hanya ce "makomar ƙarshe" to kawai saboda yaƙin da ya ƙaru a 2003 ne, wanda ba zai iya faruwa ba tare da Yaƙin Gulf na baya ba, wanda ba zai iya faruwa ba tare da ba da makamai da goyon bayan Saddam Hussein a yaƙin Iran da Iraki, da sauransu a cikin ƙarni da yawa. Tabbas dalilan rikice-rikice marasa adalci ba sa sanya duk sabbin shawarwari marasa adalci ba, amma suna ba da shawarar cewa wani mai ra'ayi banda yaƙi da yawa ya kamata ya shiga cikin wani zagaye mai lalata na samar da rikici mai kare kansa.
Ko da a lokacin rikici, shin da gaske rikici ne mai gaggawa kamar yadda magoya bayan yaƙi ke iƙirari? Shin lokaci yana tafiya a nan fiye da gwaje-gwajen tunanin azabtarwa? Allman da Winright sun ba da shawarar wannan jerin madadin yaƙi waɗanda dole ne a ƙare su don yaƙi ya zama mafita ta ƙarshe: "takunkumi mai wayo, ƙoƙarin diflomasiyya, tattaunawar ɓangare na uku, ko kuma ƙarshe."[xvi] Shin haka ne? Wannan jerin yana cikin cikakken jerin zaɓuɓɓukan da ake da su, abin da shirin Gidan Rediyon Jama'a na Ƙasa mai suna "Duk Abubuwan da aka Yi la'akari da su" yake nufi ga komai. Ya kamata su sake masa suna "Kashi Biyu cikin ɗari na Abubuwan da aka Yi la'akari da su." Daga baya, Allman da Winright sun yi ambaton wata da'awa cewa kifar da gwamnatoci ya fi alheri fiye da "ƙirƙirar" su. Marubutan sun nanata cewa wannan hujjar, tana ƙalubalantar "masu ra'ayin yaƙi na zaman lafiya da na zamani iri ɗaya." Shin haka ne? Wane zaɓi ne waɗannan nau'ikan biyu suka fi so? "Ƙirƙirar"? Wannan ba hanya ce ta lumana ba kuma ba shakka ba ita ce kawai madadin yaƙi ba.
Da a ce an kai wa wata ƙasa hari kuma ta zaɓi ta yi yaƙi don kare kanta, ba za ta sami lokacin takunkumi da kuma kowace zaɓin da aka lissafa ba. Ba za ta ma sami lokacin tallafin ilimi daga masu ra'ayin Just War ba. Kawai za ta sami kanta tana yaƙi da kanta. Saboda haka, yankin da ka'idar Just War za ta yi aiki a kai shine, aƙalla a babban ɓangare, waɗannan yaƙe-yaƙen da ba su da kariya, waɗancan yaƙe-yaƙen da ke "kare kai," "kariya," "kariya," da sauransu.
Mataki na farko daga matakin tsaro na gaske shine yaƙin da aka ƙaddamar don hana hari mai zuwa. Gwamnatin Obama, a cikin 'yan shekarun nan, ta sake fasalta "gabatowa" don nufin yiwuwar a ka'ida wata rana. Sannan suka yi iƙirarin cewa suna kashe mutane da jiragen sama marasa matuƙa waɗanda suka zama "barazana mai zuwa ga Amurka." Tabbas, idan ya zo kusa a ƙarƙashin ma'anar da aka saba, ba zai ci gaba ba, domin zai faru.
Ga wani muhimmin sashi daga Ma'aikatar Shari'a "White Paper" wanda ke bayyana "nan gaba":
“[Sharaɗin] cewa shugaban aiki zai gabatar da barazanar kai hari ga Amurka ba ya buƙatar Amurka ta sami shaida bayyananniya cewa wani hari kan mutanen Amurka da muradun su zai faru nan gaba kaɗan.”[xvii]
Gwamnatin George W. Bush ta ga abubuwa iri ɗaya. Tsarin Tsaron Ƙasa na Amurka na 2002 ya ce: "Mun fahimci cewa mafi kyawun tsaronmu shine kyakkyawan hari."[xviii] Ba shakka, wannan ba gaskiya ba ne, domin yaƙe-yaƙen da ake yi suna haifar da ƙiyayya. Amma kuma gaskiya ne ƙwarai.
Da zarar muna magana game da shawarwarin yaƙi marasa kariya, game da rikice-rikicen da mutum ke da lokacin takunkumi, diflomasiyya, da kuma wa'adin aiki, mutum kuma yana da lokacin yin duk wasu abubuwa. Abubuwan da za su iya yiwuwa sun haɗa da: tsaron farar hula mai zaman kansa (marasa makami): sanar da tsarin adawa da duk wani yunƙurin mamaye ƙasa, zanga-zangar duniya da zanga-zangar, shawarwarin kwance damarar yaƙi, sanarwar kwance damarar yaƙi ta gefe ɗaya, alamun abota gami da taimako, kai ƙarar kotu ko kotu, kiran kwamitin gaskiya da sulhu, tattaunawa kan sulhu, jagoranci ta hanyar misali ta hanyar shiga yarjejeniyoyi masu ɗaurewa ko Kotun Laifuka ta Duniya ko ta hanyar mayar da dimokuraɗiyya ga Majalisar Ɗinkin Duniya, diflomasiyyar farar hula, haɗin gwiwar al'adu, da kuma rashin tashin hankali mai ƙirƙira iri-iri.
Amma fa idan muka yi tunanin yaƙin kariya, ko dai mamayar Amurka da ake tsoro amma ba za a iya yi ba, ko kuma yaƙin Amurka da aka gani daga ɗayan ɓangaren? Shin Vietnam ne kawai za su yi yaƙi? Shin 'yan Iraki ne kawai za su yi yaƙi? Da sauransu. (Ina nufin wannan don haɗa da yanayin hari a kan ainihin ƙasar Amurka, ba hari a kan, misali, sojojin Amurka a Siriya ba. Kamar yadda nake rubutawa, gwamnatin Amurka tana barazanar "kare" sojojinta a Siriya idan gwamnatin Siriya ta "kai musu hari".)
Amsar da aka bayar ga wannan tambayar ita ce, da ace mai kai hari zai daina, da ba a buƙatar wata kariya ba. Juya adawa ga yaƙe-yaƙen Amurka zuwa hujjar ƙarin kashe kuɗin sojojin Amurka abu ne mai sarkakiya ko da ga mai fafutukar kare haƙƙin jama'a na K Street.
Amsar da ta ɗan yi tsayi kaɗan ita ce, ba aikin da ya dace ba ne ga wanda aka haifa kuma yake zaune a Amurka ya ba wa mutanen da ke zaune a ƙarƙashin bama-bamai na Amurka shawara cewa su gwada juriyar rashin zaman lafiya.
Amma amsar da ta dace ta ɗan fi ta ɗayan waɗannan wahala. Amsa ce da za ta fi bayyana idan muka duba duka hare-haren ƙasashen waje da juyin juya hali/yaƙe-yaƙen basasa. Akwai ƙarin misalai na ƙarshe da za a duba, kuma akwai ƙarin misalai masu ƙarfi da za a nuna. Amma manufar ka'idar, gami da ka'idar Anti-Adalci-Yaƙi, ya kamata ta taimaka wajen samar da ƙarin misalan sakamako masu kyau, kamar amfani da rashin tashin hankali kan hare-haren ƙasashen waje.
Bincike kamar na Erica Chenoweth ya tabbatar da cewa juriyar rashin tausayi ga zalunci ta fi samun nasara, kuma nasarar ta fi dorewa, fiye da juriyar tashin hankali.[xix] Don haka idan muka kalli wani abu kamar juyin juya halin rashin zaman lafiya a Tunisiya a shekarar 2011, za mu iya ganin cewa ya cika sharuɗɗa da yawa kamar kowace irin yanayi na Yaƙin Adalci, sai dai cewa ba yaƙi ba ne kwata-kwata. Mutum ba zai koma baya a lokaci ya yi jayayya kan dabarun da ba za su yi nasara ba amma wataƙila zai haifar da ƙarin zafi da mutuwa. Wataƙila yin hakan na iya zama hujjar Yaƙin Adalci. Wataƙila za a iya yin hujjar Yaƙin Adalci, ba tare da wata shakka ba, don "shiga tsakani" na Amurka a shekarar 2011 don kawo dimokuradiyya ga Tunisiya (banda rashin iyawar Amurka na yin irin wannan abu, da kuma bala'in da zai haifar). Amma da zarar kun yi juyin juya hali ba tare da duk kisan kai da mutuwa ba, ba zai yi ma'ana ba a gabatar da duk kisan kai da mutuwa - ba idan an ƙirƙiri sabbin Yarjejeniyar Geneva guda dubu ba, kuma komai rashin nasarar rashin zaman lafiya.
Duk da ƙarancin misalai na adawa da mamayar ƙasashen waje, akwai waɗanda suka fara da'awar cewa sun sami nasara. Ga Stephen Zunes:
"Tsaron rashin zaman lafiya ya kuma yi nasarar kalubalantar mamayar sojojin ƙasashen waje. A lokacin zanga-zangar Falasɗinu ta farko a shekarun 1980, yawancin al'ummar da aka mamaye sun zama ƙungiyoyi masu mulkin kai ta hanyar rashin haɗin kai da kuma ƙirƙirar wasu cibiyoyi, wanda hakan ya tilasta wa Isra'ila ta ba da damar ƙirƙirar Hukumar Falasɗinu da kuma mulkin kai ga yawancin biranen Yammacin Kogin Jordan. Tsoron rashin zaman lafiya a Yammacin Sahara da aka mamaye ya tilasta wa Maroko ta bayar da shawarar 'yancin kai wanda - duk da cewa har yanzu ba ta cika wa'adin Maroko na bai wa Sahrawi 'yancinsu na cin gashin kansu ba - aƙalla ya yarda cewa yankin ba kawai wani ɓangare ne na Maroko ba.
"A cikin shekarun ƙarshe na mamayar Jamusawa a Denmark da Norway a lokacin Yaƙin Duniya na Biyu, 'yan Nazi ba su ƙara iko da jama'a ba. Lithuania, Latvia, da Estonia sun 'yantar da kansu daga mamayar Soviet ta hanyar adawa da tashin hankali kafin rugujewar Tarayyar Soviet. A Lebanon, ƙasar da yaƙi ya lalata tsawon shekaru da dama, shekaru talatin na mamayar Siriya an kawo ƙarshenta ta hanyar wani babban bore mai cike da tashin hankali a 2005. Kuma a bara, Mariupol ta zama birni mafi girma da 'yan tawayen da Rasha ke marawa baya suka 'yantar daga iko da shi a Ukraine, ba ta hanyar bama-bamai da hare-haren manyan bindigogi da sojojin Ukraine suka kai ba, amma lokacin da dubban ma'aikatan ƙarfe marasa makamai suka yi tattaki cikin lumana zuwa sassan tsakiyar birnin da aka mamaye suka kuma kori 'yan awaren da ke dauke da makamai."[xx]
Mutum zai iya neman damar a cikin misalai da yawa na juriya ga Nazis, da kuma juriyar Jamusawa ga mamayar Faransa a Ruhr a 1923, ko kuma wataƙila a cikin nasarar da Philippines ta samu a karo na farko da kuma nasarar da Ecuador ta samu wajen korar sansanonin sojin Amurka, da kuma misali na Gandhi na korar Birtaniya daga Indiya. Amma misalai da yawa na nasarar rashin zaman lafiya fiye da zaluncin cikin gida suma suna ba da jagora ga matakin da za a ɗauka nan gaba.
Domin a yi adalci a ɗabi'a, juriya ga hari ba lallai ne ta fi kama da nasara ba fiye da martanin tashin hankali. Sai dai kawai ta yi kama da wacce za ta iya kasancewa. Domin idan ta yi nasara, za ta yi hakan ba tare da wata illa ba, kuma nasararta za ta daɗe.
Idan babu wani hari, yayin da ake da'awar cewa ya kamata a ƙaddamar da yaƙi a matsayin "makomar ƙarshe," mafita marasa zaman lafiya ba lallai ne ta zama mai yiwuwa ba. Ko da a cikin wannan yanayin, dole ne a yi ƙoƙarinsu kafin a fara yaƙi a matsayin "makomar ƙarshe." Amma saboda ba su da iyaka a cikin nau'ikansu kuma ana iya gwada su akai-akai, a ƙarƙashin irin wannan dabarar, mutum ba zai taɓa isa ga inda kai hari ga wata ƙasa ya zama mafita ta ƙarshe ba.
Idan za ka iya cimma hakan, shawarar da ta dace za ta buƙaci cewa fa'idodin da aka yi tunanin yaƙinka sun fi duk lalacewar da aka samu ta hanyar kiyaye tsarin yaƙi.
Duba Jerin Ayyukan da Suka Yi Nasara Akan Tashin Hankali Maimakon Yaƙe-yaƙe.
Bayanan kalmomi
[i] David Swanson, "Nazari Ya Gano Mutane Suna Ɗauka Cewa Yaƙi Ne Kawai Mafaka Ta Ƙarshe," http://davidswanson.org/node/4637
[ii] Nicolas Davies, Madadin, "'Yan Tawayen Makamai da Ƙarfin Gabas ta Tsakiya Suna Taka rawa: Yadda Amurka Ke Taimakawa Wajen Kashe Zaman Lafiya a Siriya," http://www.alternet.org/world/armed-rebels-and-middle-eastern-power-plays-how-us-helping-kill-peace-syria
[iii] Julian Borger da Bastien Inzaurralde, “West 'ta yi watsi da tayin Rasha a shekarar 2012 na a bar Assad na Syria ya sauka daga mulki,” https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/sep/15/west-ignored-russian-offer-in-2012-to-have-syrias-assad-step-aside
[iv] Shaidar Farea Al-muslimi a zaman sauraron zaman kwamitin Majalisar Dattawa kan Yaƙin Jiragen Sama, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtQ_mMKx3Ck
[v] Mirror, "Rundunar Sojan Ruwa Rob O'Neill wanda ya kashe Osama bin Laden ya yi ikirarin cewa Amurka ba ta da niyyar kama ɗan ta'adda," http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/navy-seal-rob-oneill-who-4612012 Duba kuma: ABC News, Fadar White House ta ce "Osama Bin Laden ba shi da makami lokacin da aka kashe shi"
[vi] The Washington Post, "Gaddafi ya amince da taswirar zaman lafiya da shugabannin Afirka suka gabatar"
[vii] Duba http://warisacrime.org/whitehousememo
[viii] Julian Borger a Washington, Brian Whitaker da Vikram Dodd, The Guardian, "Tayin da Saddam ya yi na hana yaƙi," https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/nov/07/iraq.brianwhitaker
[ix] Julian Borger a Washington, Brian Whitaker da Vikram Dodd, The Guardian, "Tayin da Saddam ya yi na hana yaƙi," https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/nov/07/iraq.brianwhitaker
[x] Julian Borger a Washington, Brian Whitaker da Vikram Dodd, The Guardian, "Tayin da Saddam ya yi na hana yaƙi," https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/nov/07/iraq.brianwhitaker
[xi] Bayanin taron: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Bush-Aznar_memo da rahoton labarai: Jason Webb, Reuters "Bush ya yi tunanin Saddam ya shirya guduwa: rahoto," http://www.reuters.com/article/us-iraq-bush-spain-idUSL2683831120070926
[xii] Rory McCarthy, The Guardian, "Sabuwar tayin kan Bin Laden," https://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/oct/17/afghanistan.terrorism11
[xiii] Clyde Haberman, New York Times, “Paparoma Ya Yi Allah Wadai Da Yaƙin Tekun Gulf a Matsayin 'Duhu',” http://www.nytimes.com/1991/04/01/world/pope-denounces-the-gulf-war-as-darkness.html
[xiv] David Swanson, War ne A Lie, http://warisalie.org
[xv] Takardar Bayani ta Fadar White House: http://warisacrime.org/whitehousememo
[xvi] Mark J. Allman da Tobias L. Winright, Bayan Hayaki Ya Shafe: Al'adar Yaki Adalci da Adalci Bayan Yaki (Maryknoll, NY: Littattafan Orbis, 2010) p. 43.
[xvii] Takardar Farar Fata ta Ma'aikatar Shari'a, http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/msnbc/sections/news/020413_DOJ_White_Paper.pdf
[xviii] Dabarun Tsaron Ƙasa na 2002, http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/policy/national/nss-020920.pdf
[xix] Erica Chenoweth da Maria J. Stephan, Dalilin da Yasa Juyin Juya Halin Jama'a Ke Aiki: Dabaru na Dabaru na Rikicin Rashin Tashin Hankali (Columbia University Press, 2012).
[xx] Stephen Zunes, “Madadin Yaƙi Daga Ƙasa,” http://www.filmsforaction.org/articles/alternatives-to-war-from-the-bottom-up/
Muhawara
Labaran kwanan nan:





