By David Swanson
A kallon farko, jawaban Hillary Clinton ga Goldman Sachs, wanda ta ƙi nuna mana amma WikiLeaks ya yi iƙirarin cewa yanzu sun samar da rubutun, sun nuna munafunci mara kyau ko cin zarafi fiye da yadda saƙonnin imel da yawa suka bayyana kwanan nan. Amma duba kusa.
Kamfanin dillancin labaran kasar Amurka Clinton ya bayyana cewa, ta yi imanin cewa tana da matsayi na jama'a a kowane batun da ya bambanta da matsayinta. Wanne ya yi wa Goldman Sachs?
Haka ne, Clinton tana da'awar biyayya ga yarjejeniyar cinikayya na kamfanoni, amma a lokacin kalaman nata ba ta riga ta fara ba (a fili) tana ikirarin akasin haka.
Ina tsammanin, a zahiri, cewa Clinton na ci gaba da rike mukamai da dama kan batutuwa daban-daban, kuma wadanda ta bai wa Goldman Sachs sun kasance wani bangare ne na matsayinta na jama'a, a wani bangare kuma aminantarsa ga masu hadin gwiwa, kuma a wani bangare karar da take da shi na jam'iyyar Democrat a dakin 'Yan Republican game da dalilin da ya sa za su ba da gudummawa fiye da ita kuma ƙasa da GOP. Wannan ba ita ce irin maganar da za ta yi wa shugabannin kungiyar kwadago ba ko kwararru kan hakkin dan adam ko wakilan Bernie Sanders ba. Tana da matsayi ga kowane mai sauraro.
A cikin rubutun jawabin daga Yuni 4, 2013, Oktoba 29, 2013, da Oktoba 19, 2015, Clinton sun sami alamun biya sosai don yin abin da ta musunta mafi yawan masu sauraro. Wato, ta dauki tambayoyi cewa ya bayyana cewa ba a asirce shi ba ko kuma ta shiga tattaunawa a gaban lokaci. A wani ɓangare, wannan ya zama lamari ne saboda wasu tambayoyin sun kasance jawabai masu tsayi, kuma a wani bangare domin amsoshinsa ba dukkanin ma'anar banza ne masu ban sha'awa da ta samar idan an ba lokaci zuwa shirya ba.
Mafi yawan abubuwan da wadannan jawaban suka gabatar wa bankunan Amurka sun shafi manufofin kasashen waje, kuma kusan dukkanin hakan na yaki ne, da yiwuwar yaki, da kuma damar da sojoji ke jagoranta na yankuna daban-daban na duniya. Wannan abubuwan sun fi ban sha'awa da rashin gabatar da wulakanci fiye da wautattun maganganu da aka fitar a yayin muhawarar shugaban kasa. Amma kuma ya dace da hoton manufofin Amurka wanda watakila Clinton ta gwammace ta sirri. Kamar dai yadda babu wanda ya tallata hakan, kamar yadda imel ya nuna yanzu, masu banki na Wall Street sun taimaka wajen zaba ministocin Shugaba Obama, gaba daya muna karaya daga yin tunanin cewa yake-yake da sansanonin kasashen waje ana nufin su ne a matsayin ayyuka ga masu karfin kudi. “Ina wakiltar ku duka,” in ji Clinton ga bankunan dangane da kokarin da ta yi a wajen wani taro a Asiya. Yammacin Saharar Afirka na da babbar dama ga "kamfanoni da 'yan kasuwa na Amurka," in ji ta a game da ta'addancin Amurka a can.
Duk da haka, a cikin wadannan jawaban, Clinton tana aiwatar da wannan hanyar daidai, ko ba daidai ba, a kan sauran al'ummomi kuma suna zargin China da irin abin da masu sukar ta "hagu na nesa" ke zarginta da ita a kowane lokaci, duk da cewa ba a bincikar takunkumin kafafen yada labaran Amurka. . China, Clinton ta ce, na iya amfani da kiyayyar Japan a matsayin wata hanya ta dauke hankalin Sinawa daga manufofin tattalin arziki marasa kauna da cutarwa. China, Clinton ta ce, tana gwagwarmaya don kula da farar hula a kan sojojinta. Hmm. A ina kuma muka ga waɗannan matsalolin?
"Zamu kira China da tsaron makamai masu linzami," in ji Clinton ta gaya wa Goldman Sachs. "Za mu sanya karin rundunarmu a yankin."
Game da Syria, Clinton ta ce yana da wahala a gano wanda za a bai wa makamai - kwata-kwata ba tare da kula da duk wani zabi ba in ba wani ba. Yana da wahala, in ji ta, hango ko yaya abin da zai faru. Don haka, shawarar da za ta ba wa masu aikin banki, shi ne yin yaki a Siriya “a boye.”
A cikin muhawarar da ake yi a bainar jama'a, Clinton ta bukaci "babu yankin tashi" ko "babu yankin tashin bam" ko "yankin tsaro" a Siriya, daga inda za a shirya yakin kifar da gwamnati. A cikin wani jawabi ga Goldman Sachs, duk da haka, ta faɗi cewa ƙirƙirar irin wannan yanki zai buƙaci jefa bama-bamai a wasu yankuna da yawa fiye da yadda ake buƙata a Libya. "Za ku kashe yawancin Siriya," in ji ta. Har ma tana kokarin nesanta kanta daga shawarar ta hanyar ishara zuwa “wannan katsalandan din da mutane ke magana game da shi cikin annashuwa” - kodayake ita, kafin da lokacin wannan jawabin kuma tun daga wannan lokacin ita ce jagorar wannan mutumin.
Har ila yau, Clinton ta bayyana karara cewa, “masu jihadi” na Syria ne Saudi Arabia, UAE, da Qatar ke daukar nauyin su. A watan Oktoba 2013, kamar yadda jama'ar Amurka suka ƙi yin ruwan bama-bamai a Siriya, Blankfein ya tambaya ko jama'a yanzu suna adawa da "tsoma baki" - wanda a fili yake fahimtarsa a matsayin wata matsala da za a shawo kanta. Clinton ta ce kar ta ji tsoro. Ta ce, "Muna cikin wani lokaci a Siriya, inda ba su gama kashe junan su ba. . . kuma wataƙila ku jira kawai ku kalle shi. ”
Wannan ra'ayi ne na mutane da yawa marasa ma'ana da mutane da yawa waɗanda ke da kyakkyawar ma'ana waɗanda aka shawo kansu cewa zaɓuɓɓuka biyu kawai a cikin manufofin ƙasashen waje su ne jefa bamabamai da yin komai. Wannan a fili yake fahimtar tsohuwar Sakatariyar Gwamnati, wanda matsayinsa ya fi na takwarorinta a Pentagon wahala. Har ila yau, yana da kama da bayanin Harry Truman cewa idan Jamusawa suna cin nasara ya kamata ku taimaki Russia da akasin haka, don mutane da yawa su mutu. Wannan ba daidai ba ne abin da Clinton ta fada a nan, amma yana da kusantowa, kuma wani abu ne da ba za ta fada ba a cikin wani rubutaccen rubutun hadin gwiwa da kafofin yada labarai da aka gabatar a matsayin mahawara. Yiwuwar kwance ɗamarar yaƙi, aikin wanzar da zaman lafiya ba tare da tashin hankali ba, taimako na ainihi a kan sikeli mai girma, da kuma diflomasiyya mai mutuntawa wacce ta bar tasirin Amurka daga jihohin da ke haifar da hakan ba kawai yana kan radar Clinton ba ko da wanene ke cikin masu saurarenta.
A kan Iran, Clinton ta ci gaba da tallata ikirarin karya game da makamin nukiliya da ta'addanci, duk da cewa ta bayyana karara fiye da yadda muke amfani da ita a wancan lokacin shugaban addinin Iran din ya yi tir da adawa da makaman nukiliya. Ta kuma yarda cewa Saudiyya ta riga ta ci gaba da neman makaman kare dangi kuma da alama Hadaddiyar Daular Larabawa da Masar za su iya, a kalla idan Iran ta yi hakan. Ta kuma yarda cewa gwamnatin Saudiyya ba ta da kwanciyar hankali.
Shugaban kamfanin Goldman Sachs Lloyd Blankfein ya tambayi Clinton a wani lokaci yadda yaki mai kyau da Iran zai iya tafiya - yana mai ba da shawarar cewa sana'a (ee, suna amfani da wannan haramtacciyar kalma) mai yiwuwa ba shine mafi kyawun motsi ba. Clinton ta amsa cewa za a iya jefa bam din Iran kawai. Blankfein, maimakon abin firgita, yana roƙon gaskiyar - wani abu da Clinton ke ci gaba a tsayin daka game da sauran wurare a cikin waɗannan jawaban. Shin jefa bama-bamai ga yawan jama'a cikin ƙaddamarwa ya taɓa aiki, Blankfein ya tambaya. Clinton ta yarda da cewa ba haka bane amma tana ba da shawarar cewa kawai za ta iya aiki kan Iraniyawa ne saboda ba dimokiradiyya ba.
Game da Misira, Clinton ta bayyana ta adawa da sauyawar da aka yi.
Game da kasar Sin kuma, Clinton ta yi ikirarin cewa ta gaya wa Sinawa cewa Amurka na iya ikirarin mallakar dukkan yankin Pacific sakamakon “yantar da ita.” Ta ci gaba da da'awar cewa ta gaya musu cewa "Mun gano Japan ne saboda sama." Kuma: "Muna da tabbacin sayan [Hawaii]." Da gaske? Daga wa?
Wannan mummunan abu ne, aƙalla yana lalata rayuwar mutane kamar ƙazantar da ke zuwa daga Donald Trump. Amma duk da haka abin birgewa ne cewa hatta ma aikatan banki wadanda Clinton ta tona asirinsu a cikin mania ta masu yakin basasa suna yin tambayoyinta iri daya ga wadanda masu gwagwarmayar neman zaman lafiya suke yi min a yayin da suke jawabi: “Shin tsarin siyasar Amurka ya lalace gaba daya?” Shin ya kamata mu yi watsi da wannan mu tafi da tsarin majalisa? ” Da sauransu. A wani bangare damuwar su ita ce zato wanda aka kirkira ta hanyar bambance-bambance tsakanin manyan jam'iyyun biyu, alhali babban abin da ya fi damuna shi ne lalata mutane da muhallin da ba a taba gamuwa da shi ko da dan karamin tafiyar hawainiya a Majalisa. Amma idan kaga cewa mutanen Bernie Sanders a koda yaushe suna Allah wadai da shan gida duk ribar suna cikin farin ciki da halin da ake ciki, sake tunani. Suna fa'ida ta wasu hanyoyi, amma basa sarrafa dodorsu kuma hakan baya sa sun ji sun cika ba.
